Superman Lawsuit Threatens International Release: 3 Notable Controversies in Superhero Movies

A recent legal challenge may hinder the anticipated release of James Gunn’s upcoming Superman film. The lawsuit, filed by the estate of Joseph Shuster, a co-creator of Superman, aims to prevent the film’s distribution in Canada, the United Kingdom, Ireland, and Australia. The unique copyright laws in these countries permit rights to revert to the original authors’ estates 25 years after their demise, which is at the core of this litigation.

Shuster passed away in 1992, while his collaborator Jerry Siegel died in 1996. Consequently, Shuster’s foreign copyrights reverted to his estate in 2017 for most territories and 2021 for Canada. The lawsuit argues that DC Comics, DC Entertainment, and Warner Bros. Discovery (WBD) have continued to exploit the Superman character without the Shuster estate’s permission.

Shuster died in 1992 and Siegel in 1996. By operation of law, Shuster’s foreign copyrights automatically reverted to his estate in 2017 in most of these territories (and in 2021 in Canada).Yet Defendants continue to exploit Superman across these jurisdictions without the Shuster Estate’s authorization…

A spokesperson for WBD stated, “We fundamentally disagree with the merits of the lawsuit, and will vigorously defend our rights.”The Shuster estate is seeking a complete cease and desist order, alongside a jury trial. With Superman scheduled for a global release on July 9, 2025, the potential for a protracted legal battle may serve the interests of the estate more than those of WBD.

Exploring Superhero Movie Controversies

It’s not unprecedented for superhero films to face significant controversies. Here, we examine three notable instances where beloved franchises have encountered challenges.

3.Avengers: The Kang Dynasty

Major Cast Changes

The Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) had gradually positioned Kang as its next major villain, first introduced in the finale of Loki Season 1. The storyline set the stage for the fifth Avengers film, slated to elevate Kang to a threat on par with Thanos. However, following Jonathan Majors’ criminal charges related to harassment and reckless assault, Marvel Studios chose to sever ties with the actor after his conviction in December 2023.

After months of speculation, Marvel confirmed in July 2024 that the film would be retitled Avengers: Doomsday, while Robert Downey Jr.would make a comeback—not as Tony Stark, but as the formidable Victor Von Doom.

2.Man of Steel

The Controversial Climax

Man of Steel, released in 2013, generated tremendous excitement as it marked DC’s serious attempt to compete with the established Marvel Cinematic Universe. Featuring Henry Cavill as Superman, who visually embodied the superhero, anticipation was elevated by Zack Snyder’s directorial prowess, known for his striking visual style.

While the film dazzled audiences with its visual effects, backlash erupted following the climactic scene where Superman kills General Zod by breaking his neck. This moment contradicted the moral principles that have historically defined Superman, leading to polarized reactions among fans. The divide lay between traditionalists who rejected Snyder’s approach and those who embraced the bold cinematic choices. These creative differences led to ongoing tensions between Snyder and the studio, affecting the DC Universe for years until Warner Bros. Discovery opted to reboot the franchise under James Gunn.

1.The Dark Knight

Casting Controversies

Joker waiting to be interrogated by Batman

Christopher Nolan’s Batman Begins, released in 2005, marked a significant shift towards a darker and more serious portrayal of the Caped Crusader, following the lighter, ridiculed 1997 film Batman & Robin. Anticipation built for the sequel, The Dark Knight, as the Joker was teased as the primary antagonist.

In mid-2006, the announcement that Heath Ledger would portray the Joker sparked widespread debate among fans online. Many expressed skepticism regarding Ledger’s suitability for the role, citing his previous performances and physical appearance. Reactions ranged from disappointment to outright anger over the casting choice.

Batlaw: woof.(crossing my fingers this is false)!
The Dark Knight: Ledger? o_0 The guy from [Brokeback Mountain]? No thanks. He’s a great actor but I definitely don’t see him as Joker.
darkclaw: oh well if this rumor is true, there goes the franchise!
Severen: I hope to God that this rumor proves false, or that he turns down the role. The guy is an adequate actor at best, and usually less than [that], with all the screen presence of a wet fish.

Despite initial backlash, Ledger delivered an outstanding performance that redefined the Joker, ultimately earning him a posthumous Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor.

Source & Images