Sony Files Lawsuit Against Tencent for Alleged “Slavish Clone” of Horizon Series Game, Light of Motiram

Sony Takes Legal Action Against Tencent for Alleged Copyright Infringement

Sony Interactive Entertainment has filed a lawsuit against Tencent, citing serious violations of copyright and trademark pertaining to the latter’s new game, Light of Motiram. Sony contends that this title bears too close a resemblance to its acclaimed Horizon series, labeling it a “slavish clone.”

Overview of Light of Motiram’s Launch

Announced in November 2024, Light of Motiram quickly raised eyebrows amongst gaming enthusiasts and industry experts alike. Initial impressions indicated that the game was heavily inspired by the Horizon series, with many critics arguing that it resembled a copy-and-paste effort featuring only minor modifications, primarily superficial changes and a different title.

Concerns Raised by the Gameplay Trailer

Earlier this year, Tencent unveiled a gameplay trailer for Light of Motiram. However, it did little to dispel concerns regarding its originality. According to a recent report by Reuters, Sony closely monitored the game’s reception and the media’s characterizations, which frequently referred to it as a “knock-off.”Specific phrases like “Horizon Zero Originality”have surfaced, reinforcing Sony’s allegations.

The Complexity of Proving Copyright Infringement

While public perception may lean toward viewing Light of Motiram as a derivative work, demonstrating this in a legal context poses a significant challenge. This complexity is echoed in Nintendo’s ongoing legal battles against PocketPair, the creators of Palworld. Their case illustrates the difficulties in navigating issues of originality in game development.

Looking Ahead: Industry Implications

The outcome of Sony’s lawsuit could set critical precedents for the gaming industry, particularly regarding intellectual property rights and the boundaries of creative inspiration versus outright imitation. As this case unfolds, many will be watching closely to understand its ramifications and the legal landscape for game developers moving forward.

Source & Images