Silo Season 2 Subtly Retcons Key Lore From Season 1

Silo has crafted an intricate world, but the second season of Apple TV+’s dystopian sci-fi series introduces a significant and easily overlooked alteration to its lore. This change, while pivotal, is underpinned by logical reasoning that resonates with the series’ overarching narrative. The adjustment is notable for its implications not only on the current character dynamics but also for former cast members. Moreover, due to the nature of the finale in Season 2, it is improbable that this particular detail will revert to its original form established in Season 1.

Throughout its adaptation of Hugh Howey’s acclaimed novels, Apple TV+ has made various modifications. However, the core storyline and its associated lore have generally remained intact. The show’s creative team made deliberate choices to amend certain elements of the source material, enhancing its effectiveness in a televised format. Yet, the decision to revise a prior adaptation choice indicates some level of reconsideration regarding a creative decision made in Season 1.

Significant Alterations in Traversing Silo 18’s Stairs in Season 2

Mayor Jahns Took Days to Reach Mechanical in Season 1

Major Jahns and Hank walking down the stairs in Silo

Tim Robbins’ character, Bernard Holland, currently holds the office of mayor in Silo 18; however, it’s worth remembering that Geraldine James’ Ruth Jahns was the initial leader at the start of this story. Her tenure involved a significant journey from the Upper Levels to Mechanical in the Down Deep—a journey initially depicted as taking multiple days. Yet, in Season 2, this lengthy commute has seemingly been reduced.

This season presents several instances where characters quickly move between the extremes of Silo 18, defying the previously established timeline where such movements would take days, as demonstrated by Mayor Jahns. Although one might dismiss these rapid transitions as a result of editing choices meant to maintain viewer engagement, the structure of Season 2 actually suggests a fundamental alteration in how the show treats the geography of its setting. It appears the writers have opted to streamline these journeys for narrative pacing.

The Necessity of the Retcon in Silo’s Narrative

Avoiding Repetition: The Case Against Lengthy Journey Scenes

As Season 2 of Silo unfolds, the action centers around the conflict between the Upper Levels and the Lowers. Given the limited avenues for communication between these areas, it is logical that characters must engage in physical meetings with their rivals. The quest for balance and power hinges on their ability to navigate the crucial staircase, which is a vital element for the inhabitants of Silo 18.

Maintaining a prolonged journey duration akin to Season 1 would have significantly hindered the narrative flow of Season 2. Endless sequences showing characters slowly ascending or descending the staircase would detract from the critical momentum of the plot. Thus, the adjustment made in Season 2 was a necessary creative decision to avoid redundancy while enhancing the storytelling experience.

Source & Images