Warning: This guide contains early-game story spoilers for Vampire: The Masquerade – Bloodlines 2.
Your First Major Confrontation
As players delve into the intriguing narrative of Bloodlines 2, they will eventually face their first significant boss battle. The encounter takes place in a desolate warehouse, evoking a portrayal of a German nightclub, where you will confront Benny Muldoon, the rogue Sheriff of Seattle, amidst the chaos following Prince Campbell’s untimely murder.
The Backstory
At this juncture in the plot, Muldoon’s hostility towards Thinbloods is unmistakably on display. While the Nomad may find the gruesome remains of vulnerable vampire spawns unsettling, Prince Ryong’s directive is clear: track down Benny and ensure he answers for his actions in the court. This adds a layer of urgency and moral complexity to your mission.
Your Decision After the Confrontation
Once you successfully subdue Benny, the game’s narrative presents you with a significant moral choice. Katsumi Ishizaki, a prominent figure who might not fully lead Seattle’s Anarch faction but has the capability to unify the fragmented groups, confronts you at Benny’s location. She argues compellingly that Benny should face judgment from the communities he has hurt rather than the indifferent Camarilla, who regard the deaths of Thinbloods as mere formalities.
This pivotal moment constitutes your first major branching decision in Bloodlines 2, setting the stage for subsequent developments in the story, even if the outcomes may not align with your expectations.
Your Options: Handing Benny Over vs. Returning Him to the Camarilla
It’s essential to understand that while this decision may seem impactful, its immediate consequences are minimal. Regardless of your choice, Prince Ryong will appoint you as the new Sheriff after you report back. This scenario is preordained, as Seattle requires stability, and Ryong must monitor your actions closely as you continue to unravel the unsettling mysteries surrounding your character.
Implications of Handing Benny to Katsumi
If you decide to submit Benny to Katsumi, despite your initial commitment to the Camarilla, this will negatively affect your relationship with Ryong, despite still being granted a degree of power. However, this choice will resonate well with Katsumi and the Anarchs, who may appreciate your inclination toward justice rather than adherence to the law.
Returning Benny to Weaver Tower
On the flip side, returning Benny to Weaver Tower will likely strengthen your standing with Prince Ryong. While this choice may not win over Katsumi, who permits your departure without contest, it positions you favorably with the Camarilla. However, expect no advancements with the Anarchs as a result.
Building Alliances for Future Endings
Establishing trust with the faction leaders is crucial and influences the game’s multiple endings. This initial choice offers a glimpse into the factions’ dynamics, even if you feel you lack complete information at this stage. If your goal is aligning with the Camarilla, return Benny to Ryong; if the Anarchs intrigue you more, consider letting Katsumi take him.
Further Choices in Bloodlines 2
There are many story choices awaiting players, including potential romantic options and important character interactions. For a deeper understanding of your early conversations, such as making a good impression on Lou Graham, keep exploring!
Leave a Reply