Tim Allen returns to the small screen with the new comedy series Shifting Gears, but initial impressions suggest that the show might not live up to expectations. Premiered by ABC as a midseason sitcom, Shifting Gears aims to fill programming gaps while bringing a nostalgic touch by featuring Allen alongside Kat Dennings, known for her role in 2 Broke Girls. The narrative centers on father and daughter duo, Matt Parker and Riley Parker, who are forced to reunite after years of estrangement.
The show boasts a noteworthy supporting cast, including Seann William Scott playing Gabriel, Daryl Chill Mitchell as Carter, and young actors Maxwell Simkins and Barrett Margolis as Riley’s kids, Carter and Georgia, respectively. As of now, Shifting Gears has a Rotten Tomatoes rating of 45%. While this indicates a “rotten”status, it is crucial to note that only the pilot episode has aired thus far. Unfortunately, the series appears to suffer from issues that could have been addressed to enhance its potential.
Familiar Comedy Tropes in Shifting Gears
An Unexciting Premise for Tim Allen’s Return
Family-oriented sitcoms have long been a mainstay of network television, often reflecting real-life experiences through more relatable storylines. Tim Allen has previously excelled in such roles with classics like Home Improvement and The Last Man Standing. His character in Shifting Gears, Matt Parker, shares the foundational values reminiscent of his earlier work, though unfortunately, the series lacks deeper engagement.
The narrative structure of Shifting Gears also seems somewhat stagnant, relying heavily on established comedy tropes common in family sitcoms. The story kicks off with a forced living arrangement, underpinned by the emotional weight of Matt’s recent loss of his wife. While this plot device sets the stage for heartfelt moments between father and daughter, the emotional connection fails to resonate as intended. The show seems at risk of being overshadowed by its competition, particularly in an era rich with evolving comedic styles, as seen in acclaimed series like Abbott Elementary and the rising St. Denis Medical.
Potential for Growth in Shifting Gears
Harnessing Potential for Lasting Success
On a positive note, Shifting Gears is achieving impressive ratings for ABC, even outperforming The Conners. This suggests that the show has room for improvement before declining viewer interest becomes an issue. Although the series primarily capitalizes on Allen’s star power, it stands to benefit from focusing on smaller narratives that can enhance its storytelling. For instance, Riley’s complex backstory involving her abusive husband and the budding relationship with Gabriel offers an intriguing subplot. Additionally, the dynamic between Matt and his grandkids, Carter and Georgia, was a bright spot in the pilot.
As the show evolves, there’s room to explore character development beyond the father-daughter relationship. It’s notable that Katz Dennings demonstrates a strong rapport with Allen, suggesting that her character’s arc could also be expanded for greater depth. Exploring her storyline in relation to Matt’s could enrich the overall narrative. Focusing on their relationships may prove beneficial, given the premiere episode hinted at the potential for meaningful development.
Ultimately, with Tim Allen at the helm, Shifting Gears has a built-in audience waiting to see how the series unfolds. Its initial ratings indicate that viewers are intrigued, despite the lukewarm reviews. For ABC, the challenge will be to ensure the show evolves beyond merely being another Tim Allen vehicle into a multifaceted family comedy capable of standing the test of time. Fortunately, with a well-rounded cast, the potential is there to create something special.
Leave a Reply