Scream 7 Fan Theory Reveals How This Original Character Returns

Overview of Fan Theories for Scream 7

Reddit theories speculate that Stu may be alive and connected to characters Judy and Mickey.
While fan theories can enrich the franchise, their authenticity should be approached cautiously.
Scream 7 will reveal the truth about Stu’s fate, maintaining an air of mystery as the release date approaches.

The upcoming installment of the Scream franchise, Scream 7, is generating excitement as several original characters make a return. Speculations are widespread regarding the survival of iconic character Stu, originally portrayed by Matthew Lillard. As two leading actors from the previous film, Melissa Barrera and Jenna Ortega, step back, the narrative is energized by the comeback of familiar figures, including Neve Campbell, Matthew Lillard, and Scott Foley. However, the inclusion of Lillard and Foley sparks debate, given that their characters seemed to have met their demise in earlier films. The ambiguity around Stu’s fate, however, has led to intriguing fan theories, particularly one that sheds light on how he could plausibly re-enter the storyline.

Reddit User Theories

Active discussions among Scream enthusiasts on Reddit have brought forth a riveting theory suggesting that Stu may indeed be alive, creating an engaging premise for the seventh movie. A Reddit user, known as ComfortableHall8887, proposes an intriguing backstory involving Judy Hicks (played by Marley Shelton), who was a contemporary of both Stu (Lillard) and Billy (Skeet Ulrich) during their senior year. The user delves into Judy’s potential motivations, asserting that her complex feelings toward Sidney (Neve Campbell)—stemming from a shared high school theater production of Peter Pan—could deepen the narrative.

According to the theory, Judy had harbored feelings for Stu and witnessed the pivotal moment when Sidney threw a TV at him during the events of the first Scream movie. The theory goes on to suggest that Judy partnered with Mickey (Timothy Olyphant) to help Stu escape after the fatal incident. This collaboration offers a creative twist on the story, insinuating that the law enforcement response led to a misunderstanding of the crime scene, effectively allowing Stu’s survival to be overlooked.

Comment by u/ThaRudeBoy from discussion in Scream

As the plot unfolds in Scream 7, Judy’s secret potential role in concealing Stu’s survival adds layers of complexity to her character. The theory suggests that Judy maintained communication with Stu while serving as a police officer in subsequent films, allowing her to relay crucial updates about Sidney’s whereabouts. This dynamic grows darker as Judy’s fate intersects with the chaos of the later films, culminating in her and her son Wes becoming victims of the notorious Ghostface.

As the Scream saga continues, the suggestion that Stu could harbor intentions of vengeance against Sidney—due to being disfigured and left in the shadows—provides a gripping narrative arc. With hallucinations of past associates haunting Stu, viewers are likely to witness a psychological unraveling as he seeks to reclaim power amid the bloodshed caused by Ghostface.

The idea of a connection between Judy, Mickey, and Stu is a fascinating, albeit speculative, addition to the storyline. While previous films offer little evidence of their collective relationship, the abundance of untold plots allows for imaginative interpretations. Fan-driven theories should be regarded with skepticism, yet they undeniably enrich the franchise’s intricate storytelling.

Scream 7 is set to premiere on February 27, 2026, and will provide much-awaited clarity regarding the fate of Stu and the intricacies of returning characters.

For more insight, check out the discussion on Reddit.

Source & Images