Overview
- The anime adaptation of Sakamoto Days has sparked mixed feelings among fans, prompting discussions about the possibility of a remake.
- Fans have expressed dissatisfaction with the adaptation, particularly regarding the quality of the action scenes and the omission of key comic sequences.
- Despite strong viewership ratings on Netflix, the accompanying manga sales have not reached expected levels, raising concerns about the show’s economic viability.
Table of Contents
The Sakamoto Days anime has become a topic of debate among fans, with many advocating for a potential remake of its first season. Although the show has achieved notable success on Netflix, the response from fans has been largely critical. Initial grievances centered around the action sequences, which many found to be less dynamic compared to expectations for a prominent series. As the episodes progressed, further complaints emerged regarding significant comic scenes that were omitted, leaving both action enthusiasts and fans of the manga’s humor dissatisfied. Interestingly, discussions are unfolding on platforms like Reddit about whether Sakamoto Days merits a remake akin to the renowned Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood. For context, the original Fullmetal Alchemist anime, launched in 2003, deviated significantly from the source material, which led to the creation of Brotherhood in 2009— this time, remaining faithful to the manga’s narrative.
“Should It Be Remade?”
One frustrated fan posed a question regarding the need for a remake:
This is gonna be a stupid ******* question, but in your opinion does season 1 of the anime deserve to be remade like Brotherhood?
Responses from other users were overwhelmingly supportive, with the consensus leaning towards a definitive “Yes.”However, some voices added a grounded perspective, suggesting that while Sakamoto Days may warrant a remake, many other series might also deserve similar treatment. For instance, one user remarked:
Yes. But so does Tokyo Ghoul. And Berserk. And Blue Lock. And etc etc etc.
The underlying issue remains the fans’ desire for Sakamoto Days to feature animation quality comparable to Jujutsu Kaisen and impeccable choreography reminiscent of renowned director Sunghoo Park, even while acknowledging the improbability of such outcomes.
Another user added a more cautious viewpoint regarding the feasibility of a remake:
For the near future, best case scenario is the animation is cleaned up a bit for the blu-ray release and cour 2 onwards looks better. Or at least a future season 2.
While the discussions reveal the palpable disappointment among fans about the current adaptation, it’s essential to note the production realities the team encounters.
Conversely, viewers who are solely familiar with the anime appear to be more receptive, with some even beginning to explore the manga. This shift may illuminate a better understanding of the criticisms that have emerged, emphasizing the division within the community over this adaptation compared to recent Shonen Jump offerings.
Comparing Netflix Ratings to Manga Sales
Upon its launch, Sakamoto Days quickly ascended to the top of Netflix Japan’s viewership charts, maintaining a strong showing on global rankings as well. Observers have suggested it may be one of the most-watched anime titles on the platform to date.
Despite this impressive viewership, the manga’s sales seem disconnected, not reflecting the same high demand. While recent figures indicate satisfactory sales, they have not met the anticipated expectations. It remains uncertain whether the show’s popularity will translate into increased manga sales as new seasons roll out, potentially swaying the opinions of disillusioned fans.
Currently, Sakamoto Days is available for streaming on Netflix, offering both subbed and dubbed versions in multiple languages.
Source: Reddit
Leave a Reply