RSF reacts to Apple Intelligence report on Luigi Mangione suicide claims

Apple Faces Backlash Over AI Notification Error

In a recent misstep, Apple is under scrutiny for inaccuracies generated by its Apple Intelligence feature. Introduced with the latest updates in iOS 18.1, iPadOS 18.1, and macOS Sequoia 15.1, this AI-driven tool offers functionalities such as notification summaries, tailored Siri queries, a photo organization tool, email digests, and the ability to create personalized emojis through Genmoji. One of its standout features is advanced image recognition on the iPhone 16, which enhances user interaction.

Incident Overview: A Disturbing Notification

The controversy erupted when Apple Intelligence provided a notification summary from the BBC News app that contained a grave error. The AI reported that Luigi Mangione had shot himself, a claim that was categorically false. The misinterpretation of news headlines has sparked concerns over the reliability of AI in relaying critical information.

A screenshot of the troublesome notification — Image: BBC

Context of the Error

This incident is particularly troubling given the context surrounding it. Earlier this month, Brian Thompson, CEO of UnitedHealthcare, was tragically killed, and his alleged assailant, Luigi Mangione, was arrested. Mangione’s involvement became a focal point in news coverage, but the Apple Intelligence system mistakenly conflated the details, leading to a highly misleading summary that could incite confusion and anxiety among users.

Response and Implications

The fallout from this blunder was swift. The BBC lodged a complaint with Apple, prompting global advocacy group Reporters Without Borders (RSF) to call for the deactivation of the Apple Intelligence notification feature. RSF highlighted this incident as a prime example of AI’s shortcomings in accurately handling sensitive news content. They stated:

This accident highlights the inability of AI systems to systematically publish quality information, even when it is based on journalistic sources. The probabilistic way in which AI systems operate automatically disqualifies them as a reliable technology for news media that can be used in solutions aimed at the general public.

Broader AI Issues

This isn’t an isolated event in the realm of artificial intelligence. Earlier this year, Google’s chatbot Gemini faced backlash for generating controversial images that reimagined historical figures inappropriately. In response to these issues, Google temporarily suspended the ability to generate images of individuals in Gemini, acknowledging they had “missed the mark.”

Source & Images