Roger’s Controversial Choice in Outlander Season 7 Resolves a Disturbing Issue from the Book

Warning: Spoilers ahead for Outlander Season 7, Episode 15!

In a fascinating turn of events in Outlander Season 7, Episode 15, Roger faced significant backlash for a critical decision. However, his choice ultimately averted a controversial moment from the source material, showcasing how the Starz adaptation diverges beneficially from Diana Gabaldon’s books. By altering the trajectory of Roger’s storyline, the series provided a more uplifting conclusion for both him and Buck in 1739, despite Buck’s initial outrage.

Throughout this season, Roger and Buck embarked on a journey through time to locate Jemmy, who had been abducted by Rob Cameron. Unbeknownst to them, Rob had not transported Jemmy through the stones. However, their 18th-century experience proved pivotal. Roger learned that he needed to save his father, Jeremiah, while Buck played a crucial role in ensuring the survival of his lineage by uniting his future parents. It wasn’t until Episode 15 that Buck uncovered the true identity of his parents.

Roger’s Decision to Conceal Buck’s Parentage

Buck Was Unaware of His Parentage

Roger and Buck in the 1700s in Outlander Season 7, Episode 9

As Roger encountered Geillis Duncan and Dougall MacKenzie in 1739, he recognized them as Buck’s parents, unaware to Buck himself. Their union would eventually lead to Roger’s own ancestry. Unfortunately, Geillis’s tragic fate—being arrested and executed after Buck’s birth—meant that Buck grew up not knowing his true lineage. Although Roger had the opportunity to reveal this truth after they left Geillis’ home, he opted to keep it hidden.

When Roger finally disclosed Buck’s parentage in Episode 15, Buck was understandably furious. This revelation marked his only opportunity to connect with his parents, which Roger deprived him of. Roger justified his secret by expressing concern about the risks of altering history—fears that stemmed from witnessing how past events could not be changed, only secured. While Roger’s reasoning fell short, it nevertheless served the evolving narrative.

Avoiding Controversial Book Moments

Buck’s Meeting With His Mother Was Controversial

In Gabaldon’s books, Roger didn’t protect Buck’s secret for long; Buck learned of his parent’s identities sooner and even had a controversial encounter with his mother. This confrontation, rather than being an emotional reunion, tragically involved inappropriate behavior, ultimately leading to Buck discussing this unsettling experience with Roger.

While such themes of Oedipus syndrome exist in literature, the television adaptation wisely sidestepped this shocking scenario. Despite including explicit content, the notion of incest would clash with the established narrative and character development throughout the series. By having Roger withhold vital information, Buck was spared a disturbing and inappropriate interaction.

A Heartwarming Resolution for Buck

A Wholesome Conclusion to Buck’s Journey

Buck and Roger in Outlander Season 7, Episode 10

After cooling off, Buck found it in his heart to forgive Roger. He then seized the opportunity to pen a letter to his mother, expressing his desire for closure. Buck reminded Roger that their presence in 1739 had fortuitously led to Geillis and Dougall’s meeting, ensuring his own existence. He delivered a heartfelt message about how Roger and Jem were akin to his sons, emphasizing his commitment to safeguarding their family.

As Outlander Season 7 approaches its conclusion with Episode 16, and with Season 8 slated for release in 2025, Buff’s evolving story remains a touching testament to the bonds forged through heartache and revelation. The series’ decision to reshape Buck’s narrative ensured a more wholesome development, one that preserved the integrity of his relationship with Roger, free from the burden of their past.

This adaptation demonstrates the potential for narrative choices to enhance storytelling, providing a distinct and engaging experience for viewers while maintaining a respectful distance from uncomfortable themes presented in the source material.

Source & Images