Marvel Studios has taken a bold step in redefining the character of the Scarlet Witch in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness. Upon revisiting this Phase 4 sequel, I find myself thrilled with the creative direction they pursued. Over the decade since her debut in Captain America: The Winter Soldier, Elizabeth Olsen’s portrayal of Wanda Maximoff has become a personal favorite. The moment when Wanda fully transforms into the Scarlet Witch is still spine-chilling; moreover, I found her role in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness to be far more compelling than the character’s initial arc that Marvel had envisioned.
Wanda Maximoff’s transformation into Scarlet Witch has significantly elevated her importance within the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU). Her evolution became especially pronounced during Phase 4, as both WandaVision and Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness placed her at the forefront of the story. This shift from a supporting role to a central character resonated deeply with fans, including myself, who have rewatched the film multiple times and appreciated the richness of her character arc. It fills me with gratitude that Marvel chose to diverge from the original plan for Scarlet Witch’s storyline.
Scarlet Witch’s Initial Role as a Mentor in Doctor Strange 2
Insights from X-Men ’97’s Creator on the Original Scarlet Witch Narrative
In September 2024, Beau DeMayo, the creator of X-Men ’97 and former Marvel Studios showrunner, shed light on the original storyline for Scarlet Witch in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness. His revelation revealed that Wanda was intended to be depicted as a recovering character after the events of WandaVision. This would have presented a more subdued version of Scarlet Witch compared to the formidable villain she ultimately became.
Correct. OG drafts did her justice. Wanda was with Strange recovering after Westview, feeling bad about what she did. She helps him, Wong and Chavez (who she tutors) beat Nightmare across Multiverse, where she also sees her variants happy with her kids.https://t.co/3fQwROzuXJ — Beau DeMayo (@BeauDemayo) September 12, 2024
Crucially, DeMayo suggested that, instead of pursuing America Chavez for her multiversal abilities, Wanda would have been a mentor to Chavez while battling Nightmare alongside Doctor Strange and Wong. Though this original narrative had its merits, I personally favor how the actual storyline unfolded in the film.
The Appeal of the Scarlet Witch as a True MCU Villain
The History of the Scarlet Witch as a Villain in Marvel Comics
The decision to pivot Wanda Maximoff into a villainous role in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness ignited considerable debate among fans. Some argued that this portrayal felt out of sync with her journey in WandaVision. However, I strongly contend that the conclusion of WandaVision positioned Wanda more as an anti-hero than a true hero, especially after she seized the Darkhold. Her dark transformation in the sequel felt like a logical progression.
In the comics, Scarlet Witch has oscillated between villainous and anti-hero roles, making her descent into villainy a fitting exploration for her character in the MCU. As one of the most powerful figures in the universe, seeing her potential unleashed as she navigated the multiverse was thrilling. The hints of her darker impulses throughout the MCU helped build anticipation for the climax in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness.
Shortcomings of the Original Scarlet Witch Plan
The Logic Behind Scarlet Witch’s Villainous Arc in Phase 4
It’s difficult to truly comprehend Scarlet Witch’s full power in the MCU. Historically, her abilities have been constrained by Wanda’s moral compass and desire to act heroically. If the original plot had followed through with her arc as a mentor seeking redemption, I doubt it would have showcased her true capabilities. Transitioning her into a fully-fledged villain allowed her to shed these limitations and reveal the full extent of her extraordinary power.
|
Elizabeth Olsen’s MCU Appearances |
Release Year |
Character Role |
|---|---|---|
|
Captain America: The Winter Soldier |
2014 |
End-Credits Cameo |
|
Avengers: Age of Ultron |
2015 |
Main Cast |
|
Captain America: Civil War |
2016 |
Main Cast |
|
Avengers: Infinity War |
2018 |
Main Cast |
|
Avengers: Endgame |
2019 |
Supporting Cast |
|
WandaVision |
2021 |
Lead |
|
Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness |
2022 |
Main Cast as Villain |
|
What If…? Season 2 |
2023 |
Voice as Wanda Merlin |
|
Marvel Zombies |
2025 |
Voice as Zombie Scarlet Witch |
It would have been disappointing for Elizabeth Olsen’s first appearance after WandaVision to relegate her to a naïve, remorseful character. Considering the morally complex acts she committed in WandaVision, where she imprisoned the residents of Westview, a quick resolution of her guilt would have felt insincere. I firmly believe that the transformation of Scarlet Witch into a true villain was a wise narrative choice, yet I am eager to witness her journey towards redemption as well.
A Hopeful Outlook for Wanda Maximoff’s Return to the MCU
Elizabeth Olsen Rumored to Reprise Her Role in the MCU
The climax of Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness sees the Scarlet Witch acknowledging her mistakes and ultimately choosing to destroy the Darkhold in a self-sacrificial act. Although Marvel Studios stated that the Scarlet Witch is deceased, this has not dampened the fervent speculation and hope surrounding Elizabeth Olsen’s return to the MCU. After all, in superhero lore, the absence of a body often leaves room for possibility. The prospect of her reemergence offers fans enchanting opportunities to explore her character’s depth further.
While I wanted the Scarlet Witch’s ascension into villainy, there remains a collective craving for her to redeem herself as a hero, should Elizabeth Olsen return. It would be thrilling to see Wanda Maximoff back in the MCU, particularly in light of recent developments in Agatha All Along, which revealed the reincarnation of her sons, Billy and Tommy. The Multiverse Saga may provide avenues for a poignant reunion, defying the finality of death highlighted in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness.
Related Articles:
Jurassic Park and 9 Other Films Blurring the Line Between Horror and Adventure
11:14
Top 10 War Movies Highlighting Boot Camp Experiences
11:07
Understanding Why Legolas Shoots Gríma Wormtongue While Killing Saruman in The Return of the King
10:42
Leave a Reply