Review of Train Dreams: Stunning Western Drama Starring Joel Edgerton That Didn’t Capture My Heart

Train Dreams requires a considerable degree of patience. This film offers a contemplative and intimate journey through the American West during the early 20th century. Under the direction of Clint Bentley, who adapted the screenplay alongside co-writer Greg Kwedar from Denis Johnson’s novel, the film evokes the stylistic sensibilities of Terrence Malick. While it is visually stunning—boasting some of the finest cinematography showcased at this year’s Sundance Film Festival—it often falls prey to its own introspective nature, leading to pacing issues that may challenge its audience.

Train Dreams: An Overextended Narrative

The allure of Train Dreams is undeniable, particularly its breathtaking cinematography by Adolpho Veloso. Much of the film unfolds in the great outdoors, fully embracing the natural beauty of the majestic forests and serene riversides. The protagonist, Grainier, portrayed by Joel Edgerton, frequently finds himself captivated by the landscape—stargazing or wandering through the woods in search of meaning. While his journey through life is marked by moments of joy and tragedy, the film’s central theme revolves around the elusive quest for purpose.

Unique in its narrative approach, the film diverges from the conventional belief that everything in life has inherent meaning. Rather, it offers a more nuanced perspective, suggesting that the natural world holds greater significance than its passing characters. Bentley crafts a poignant tribute to individuals like Grainier, who contribute their labor to the logging industry yet remain largely unrecognized. This connection serves as a reminder that while human actions have consequences for the earth, not every event in life bears clear significance. Grainier’s inclination to attribute his misfortunes to a self-imposed curse represents an attempt to find justification for his suffering, all while he meanders through his existence.

However, one of the film’s key tragedies occurs prematurely, leaving the audience navigating a narrative that at times mirrors Grainier’s own disorientation.

The film’s exploration of guilt extends longer than necessary, focusing on the anguish tied to a nameless figure whose fate tragically aligns with the archetypal silent Asian trope. The narration, delivered by Will Patton, strikes a harmonious chord without becoming overly verbose, yet the film’s minimal dialogue within its stretched runtime risks diminishing viewer engagement. Edgerton does commendable work in a demanding role, yet even his strong performance cannot fully overcome the film’s pacing challenges. Moments of deep philosophical introspection punctuate the plot, particularly during instances of Grainier’s inner turmoil. However, the overarching sorrow described can overshadow the narrative, leaving the audience feeling somewhat adrift.

Joel Edgerton Delivers a Standout Performance

A Nuanced Portrayal

Edgerton excels in the role of Grainier, authentically embodying the weariness and heartbreak intrinsic to a logger’s life—one that is marked by hard labor and sacrifice. Although he seems resigned to his fate, he yearns for the comforts of home with his wife and child. Edgerton’s performance is imbued with layers of fatigue and quiet reflection, oscillating between moments of happiness and sorrow. His physicality complements the grueling demands of logging, as his primarily silent role requires him to express a wealth of emotion through facial nuances and body language.

Felicity Jones also shines as Gladys, portraying a strong and nurturing presence who deftly manages the household and family finances. The chemistry between her and Edgerton is palpable, enhancing the film’s emotional depth. Meanwhile, supporting performances—such as that of William H. Macy, whose brief yet impactful role adds texture to the narrative—further enrich the overall experience. Despite the film’s compelling moments and its striking visuals, its philosophical explorations occasionally lose clarity amidst the repetition, rendering it a slow-moving narrative that touches upon life’s more profound moments without delving deeply into their significance.

Train Dreams premiered at the 2025 Sundance Film Festival.

Source & Images