Review of The Couple Next Door: Starz’s Domestic Thriller Struggles with Focus

The Couple Next Door tantalizes viewers with an intriguing narrative that delves into themes of secrecy and betrayal. Unfortunately, the six-episode series becomes bogged down with excessive plotlines, failing to let any single story arc shine. While the performances are commendable and the cast exhibits palpable chemistry, the overall effect is a convoluted thriller that rushes to an unsatisfying conclusion.

Overstuffed and Underwhelming: An Analysis of The Couple Next Door

Upon moving into their new suburban home, Evie (Eleanor Tomlinson) and Pete (Alfred Enoch) are eager to establish themselves as part of their friendly neighborhood. However, as their excitement builds for the arrival of their baby, they quickly find that their seemingly idyllic surroundings are anything but. The drama escalates as the series introduces a multitude of subplots, including a cult, a mob angle, various romantic entanglements, and an ominous neighbor, leading to a frenzied pace that overwhelms the core narrative.

Despite the show’s limited six-episode format, it attempts to juggle an array of interconnected plotlines. Although the dynamics among the central characters—Evie, Pete, their neighbors Becka (Jessica De Gouw), and Danny (Sam Heughan from Outlander)—are engaging, they become obscured by the show’s inclination to take on too much. The result is a viewing experience that is often more exhausting than enjoyable.

Watch the trailer here.

While the multiple story arcs attempt to create tension, they instead contribute to a sense of chaos that distracts from the main themes of the series. The constant drama stretches beyond the central couples, making it difficult for viewers to connect deeply with any single storyline. Even as the series tries to tie these narratives together towards its conclusion, the overall experience remains unyieldingly intense.

Strong Performances: A Highlight of The Couple Next Door

Amidst the cluttered plot, the series shines through its captivating performances, particularly from Eleanor Tomlinson. As Evie’s character evolves throughout the episodes, the audience witnesses her journey intricately tied to the show’s unfolding drama. Tomlinson’s steady performance provides a solid anchor, as she navigates the convoluted narrative with grace.

While other cast members also deliver notable performances, it is Tomlinson’s portrayal that stands out consistently, offering depth and emotional resonance to the series. The actors are well-utilized, with each contributing to their respective story arcs, yet the overarching complexity of the narrative detracts from their individual strengths.

Had the creators concentrated on just a couple of plotlines instead of overextending themselves, the series may have struck a stronger chord with viewers. Streamlining the narrative would have allowed for a more immersive experience, keeping audiences engaged without feeling overwhelmed.

Despite its numerous missteps, The Couple Next Door manages to weave together its disparate storylines, including the fragile nature of relationships and the tension between established and emerging bonds. Yet, as it hastily approaches its conclusion, viewers are left craving a more focused storytelling approach devoid of unnecessary filler. If refined, this series had the potential to transition into a gripping psychological thriller.

Don’t miss The Couple Next Door, airing weekly on Fridays at 9 PM ET on Starz.

Source & Images