Reimagining Assassin’s Creed: Why a Complete Franchise Reboot is Essential

Assassin’s Creed remains an exceptionally popular franchise, yet it faces significant challenges. Since its inception in the late 2000s, Ubisoft has transformed this series from a straightforward historical action-adventure into an expansive open-world RPG anthology. While this evolution has had its successes, it has also generated a mixed bag of responses from fans and critics alike.

The release of Assassin’s Creed Valhalla marked a high point for the franchise, but discussions regarding the forthcoming title, Assassin’s Creed Shadows, have highlighted the current precariousness of the IP’s reputation. In recent years, interest in the series has waned, largely due to an increasingly convoluted storyline and gameplay mechanics that risk becoming stagnant. Although the current formula may still yield some success, it is evident that without genuine innovation, the series could face diminishing returns. A hard reset could be precisely what is needed to rejuvenate the franchise.

Why a Hard Reboot Could Be the Best Path Forward for Assassin’s Creed

Assassin's Creed Shadows Yasuke on Horse

Assassin's Creed Syndicate - Jack the Ripper

Assassin’s Creed Has Lost Its Way

The narrative of the Assassin’s Creed franchise has become increasingly convoluted and disjointed. Unlike other storied franchises like Metal Gear Solid or Kingdom Hearts, which manage to weave complex plots chaotically yet charm their audiences, Assassin’s Creed appears to be layering new story elements without a clear direction or resolution. Each new game seems more focused on setting the stage for future installments rather than delivering satisfying conclusions.

Previously, the series appeared to be building toward a coherent finale with Assassin’s Creed 3, where protagonist Desmond Miles’ journey felt purpose-driven. There was speculation that the narrative would culminate in a modern-age game connecting the dots of previous entries. However, the current trajectory leaves the franchise feeling aimless, with new, seemingly standalone titles that offer fresh protagonists while complicating the overarching story without meaningful payoff.

This narrative disarray is mirrored in the gameplay itself, which has shifted from being innovative to trend-driven, pulling elements from other successful titles like The Witcher and Dark Souls without offering a distinctive twist. Consequently, Assassin’s Creed risks losing its unique identity, morphing instead into a generic action RPG filled with predictable gameplay, rather than serving as a cohesive and groundbreaking series.

Assassin’s Creed Requires a New, Definitive Creative Direction

In essence, Assassin’s Creed can be described as wandering without a clear course. The franchise seems trapped in a cycle of reacting to previous successes and failures, rather than evolving its core components toward a greater vision.

A bold shift away from the modern-day storyline and a renewed focus on the fundamental conflict between Assassins and Templars might help the series rediscover its unique character and appeal. Similarly, introducing innovative stealth mechanics, moving away from supernatural elements, and developing more concise, immersive gameplay experiences could ease the player fatigue that currently plagues the franchise. Additionally, eliminating microtransactions could enhance player satisfaction and trust.

Source & Images