
Chapter 5 of Red Dead Redemption 2 presents a unique adventure that, while not heavily laden with missable content, still offers players numerous opportunities to collect valuable items and complete crucial missions. The Guarma section is especially notable for its potential misses, and understanding what to look out for can significantly enhance the gaming experience. Before embarking on Arthur’s escape from this vibrant tropical island, players should familiarize themselves with its collectible treasures and missions.
This chapter features a variety of missable elements, ranging from collectibles to essential missions. Below, we highlight key aspects that players should not overlook during their time in Guarma.
1 Savagery Unleashed
Help Hercule and Leon Save Local Workers

- Location: Vibora Stream
As stranded on the island, Arthur Morgan urgently needs assistance, making Hercule and Leon vital allies. However, before he can make his exit, Arthur must assist them in rescuing local workers who have fallen victim to oppressive forces. This mission not only offers a rewarding experience but is crucial to completing all quests in this chapter.
It’s important to note that although this mission appears early on in the Guarma section, players may miss it if they prioritize a conversation with Dutch instead. Fulfilling Hercule’s request first is essential for players seeking to capture the full narrative experience.
2 Guarma’s Secret Random Encounters
Guarma Rebels and Arthur’s Pit Fall

Despite its relatively small size, Guarma is teeming with life and encounters that can enrich the gameplay experience. Players who explore diligently will encounter random events involving Spanish soldiers pursuing Guarma rebels. If Arthur crosses paths with these soldiers, they will not hesitate to attack.
Additionally, players should be mindful of a hidden pit trap located to the east of Arroyo De La Vibora. Stepping into it triggers a mini-cutscene, requiring Arthur to swiftly eliminate two guards. Being aware of this encounter can add an exciting layer to the gameplay.
3 Sun Hat
A Rare Hat Found Only in Guarma

The Sun Hat is an exclusive item found only on specific enemies encountered through missions in Guarma, such as “Savagery Unleashed”and others. Since Guarma is not a location players can revisit, obtaining this rare hat is worthwhile for completionists.
Players should watch for enemies donning the Sun Hat and collect it to enrich Arthur’s wardrobe, creating a memorable keepsake from this chapter.
4 Guarma’s Missable Animals
A Collection of Guarma-Exclusive Animals to Study and Hunt


Guarma teems with unique wildlife, including several species of snakes and birds. Although players can log these creatures in the Compendium for tracking purposes, note that they do not contribute toward the Zoologist trophy. For dedicated collectors, here’s a rundown of the notable animals exclusive to the island, along with their locations:
Animal | Location |
---|---|
Scarlet Macaw | North of Arroyo De La Vibora River |
Blue and Yellow Macaw | North of Arroyo De La Vibora River |
Great Green Macaw | Between La and Vibora of Arroyo De La Vibora River |
Red-Footed Booby | Between La and Vibora of Arroyo De La Vibora River |
Red-Tailed Boa Snake | Between Arroyo and De of Arroyo De La Vibora River |
Rainbow Boa Snake | Between Arroyo and De of Arroyo De La Vibora River |
Sunglow Boa Snake | Between Arroyo and De of Arroyo De La Vibora River |
Green Turtle | Ocean of Bahia De La Paz |
While players cannot hunt the Green Turtle, observing and studying it will allow Arthur to sketch it in his journal, providing a sense of accomplishment.
5 Letter from Caroline
A Secret Letter That Reveals the Gang’s New Hideout

After departing Guarma and returning to Lemoyne, players should make their way to Shady Belle, where they can uncover the location of the Van der Linde gang’s new hideout. Within Shady Belle, players can find the Letter from Caroline, which is a vital collectible.
It’s important to remember that players may complete the “Dear Uncle Tacitus”mission without collecting this letter. Thus, prioritizing a visit to Shady Belle over Lakay is crucial to ensuring this collectible isn’t missed.
6 Bounty Hunting
All Bounty Hunter Targets Must Be Completed in Chapter 5 or Before

Bounty hunting in Red Dead Redemption 2 is an exhilarating aspect of gameplay, offering a chance to hunt down various targets across the expansive game world. Each target brings a unique storyline and value, presenting players with the thrill of frontier justice.
However, it’s essential for players to complete all bounty targets before concluding the final Chapter 5 mission, “Murfree Country.”Completing this mission at Beaver Hollow will lock players out of bounty hunting until the game’s Epilogue, so timing is key to preserving this engaging facet of the game.
This includes earlier bounty hunting missions like “Good, Honest, Snake Oil”set in Valentine.
Leave a Reply