Reasons Why Tokyo Ghoul Should Be Remade

Essential Insights

Studio Pierrot’s adaptation of Tokyo Ghoul faced significant pacing and animation challenges, leading to disappointment among its fanbase.
Season 2, titled Tokyo Ghoul √A, strayed from the original manga, igniting frustration among manga readers due to its hurried storytelling.
Many fans are advocating for a more faithful remake, hoping that studios like MAPPA, Studio Wit, or Madhouse can faithfully recreate this beloved series.

When Tokyo Ghoul debuted as a manga in 2011, it quickly captivated the anime community. Created by Sui Ishida, this series explored dark fantasy themes while delivering deeply layered characters. The manga’s success inevitably led to its anime adaptation in 2014.

Fans were initially optimistic when Studio Pierrot was announced as the production studio. Known for iconic series like Bleach and Naruto, expectations were sky-high. Unfortunately, the adaptation fell short of becoming a monumental work.

Understanding the Shortcomings

Key Missed Opportunities in the Tokyo Ghoul Anime

The first season of Tokyo Ghoul comprised 12 episodes, showcasing impressive visuals, well-drawn characters, and a memorable opening theme, “Unravel.” However, it was marred by rushed sequences that omitted crucial plot points. Notable scenes, such as Kaneki’s training under Touka and his fateful confrontation with Ayato, were altered in ways that disappointed fans of the manga.

The arrival of the second season, Tokyo Ghoul √A, marked a drastic departure from the manga’s storyline, generating outrage among readers due to its original content that felt disconnected from Ishida’s narrative. By the time the third season aired in 2018, viewers encountered another hastily put-together season that failed to do justice to essential character arcs, leaving many fans unsatisfied.

A Beloved Story That Deserves a Second Chance

Fans are uniting in a longing for a remake that accurately reflects the depth of the original Tokyo Ghoul manga. Not only did pivotal characters like Kisho Arima and Ayato lack sufficient development in the anime, but the emotional weight of their relationships also fell flat. The story delves not just into thrilling battles, but also into profound themes like moral ambiguity and personal struggle.

Though a few notable fights emerged, many narrative layers and character dynamics remain unaddressed. The disservice to the side characters alone highlights the need for a thoughtful remake that embraces the rich character arcs integral to the manga.

“Sometimes good people make bad choices; it doesn’t mean they are bad people. It means that they are human.”
— Arima Kishou

Potential Studios for a Reverent Adaptation

Reviving Tokyo Ghoul to Its Former Glory

If a new adaptation of Tokyo Ghoul comes to fruition, many fans hope that studios like MAPPA, which has garnered acclaim for its high-quality animation in Jujutsu Kaisen, or other powerhouses like Studio Wit and Madhouse, will take on the task. Kaneki Ken’s story is one of tragedy and complexity, far beyond a typical narrative of sudden power; it showcases his struggle to acknowledge his new reality and the witness the toll it took on his humanity.

Given Kaneki’s journey through loss and moral dilemmas, a respectful and well-crafted remake could reignite interest in this hauntingly beautiful tale. Tokyo Ghoul has the potential to achieve widespread acclaim if adapted thoughtfully. With the trend of successful remakes in the industry, there remains hope that one day, a studio will give this cherished series the care it deserves, free from rushed storytelling and neglected character development.

Source & Images