Reasons Behind Reggie Mantle’s Recasting in Riverdale Explained & Updates on the Actors’ Current Careers

Reggie Mantle, a pivotal supporting character in the acclaimed series Riverdale, has captivated audiences throughout all seven seasons since its inception in 2017. Created in 1942, Reggie emerged as a rival to Archie Andrews in the original Archie Comics, where their dynamic oscillated between friendly banter and outright rivalry. The live-action adaptation emphasized this contentious relationship significantly, particularly during its inaugural season.

As the series progressed, Reggie transitioned into a much more relatable and positive figure. Unlike many other characters on Riverdale, whose arcs reflected drastic shifts, Reggie Mantle underwent a unique evolution post-season one that left a lasting impact on his characterization.

The Recasting of Reggie Mantle

Ross Butler’s Departure for 13 Reasons Why

Ross Butler as Reggie Mantle conversing with Archie in Riverdale

Initially portrayed by Ross Butler, Reggie Mantle left a memorable impression during the first season of Riverdale. However, with the arrival of season two, Butler was replaced due to his commitments to the critically acclaimed series 13 Reasons Why. In a 2017 communication with TV Line, series creator Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa confirmed the change was largely due to Butler’s scheduling conflicts with his Netflix project.

Butler excelled in his role as Reggie, making his absence noticeable. However, the choice he made to focus on 13 Reasons Why—a landmark teen drama—was both understandable and looked upon favorably in hindsight. Reflecting on his decision in an interview with Vulture, he remarked:

Before season 2 was confirmed for 13 Reasons Why, I had to make the decision of whether I wanted to focus on one character or split two characters and have a smaller role on both shows… Reggie’s a great character, but it’s a different tone. I connected with Zach on a much more real level where I didn’t have to create so much of a character for him.

Charles Melton: Reggie’s New Face

A Fresh Take on Reggie Mantle

Charles Melton as Reggie Mantle engaging in basketball in Riverdale

With Ross Butler’s exit, Charles Melton stepped in to portray Reggie Mantle from the start of season two. Notably, Aguirre-Sacasa advised Melton to refrain from emulating Butler’s interpretation, encouraging him to shape his rendition of Reggie. This strategic guidance allowed Melton to develop a character infused with significantly more depth than previously showcased.

While Butler depicted Reggie as predominantly a jock, Melton’s portrayal provided a more nuanced character evolution. This shift allowed for a more complex exploration of Reggie’s personality and motivations. Despite facing his own challenges while filming—such as not being able to take part in the first half of the final season due to scheduling conflicts—Melton ultimately returned to the role, continuing to contribute to the series’ legacy.

Where Are They Now? The Futures of Reggie’s Actors

Butler’s Journey in Shazam! and Melton’s Acclaim in May December

Both Ross Butler and Charles Melton have carved out successful careers, leveraging their roles in Riverdale to achieve further opportunities. Butler remained a staple in 13 Reasons Why across its four-season run and later expanded his credits with notable projects such as Shazam! and Shazam! Fury of the Gods, alongside appearances in Awkwafina is Nora from Queens and Love in Taipei. He currently has several upcoming projects in post-production, including Zipline and Shiver.

Meanwhile, Charles Melton has also made a name for himself, particularly with his acclaimed performance in May December, a film exploring a complex romantic narrative, which garnered him a Golden Globe nomination. Looking ahead, he is set to appear in the upcoming film Warfare, directed by Ray Mendoza and Alex Garland.

In retrospect, both actors have successfully navigated their careers post-Riverdale, showcasing their talents across diverse projects and genres.

Source & Images