Ranking the 2025 Oscars Best Picture Nominees from Worst to Best

The nominations for the 97th Academy Awards highlight some of the finest cinematic achievements of 2024, showcasing a diverse selection of films that reflect the intricate tapestry of modern storytelling. While this year’s film slate presented a mixture of offerings, it also featured a range of unique and engaging narratives, despite encountering several box office disappointments. From religious political thrillers to body horror satires and critically acclaimed musicals, the versatility of contemporary cinema is on full display.

The 97th Oscars aim to celebrate excellence in filmmaking, with the nominated films representing some of the most impactful and thought-provoking works of the past year. While all nominated films for Best Picture possess their own merits, certain titles rise above as compelling, timely, and entertaining, establishing themselves as standout offerings of 2024.

10. A Complete Unknown

Directed By James Mangold

A Complete Unknown is a solid yet unremarkable biopic that features commendable direction and standout performances, particularly from Timothée Chalamet as Bob Dylan. Despite the film’s predictable nature, it emerges as the least impressive among this year’s Best Picture nominees. While Mangold draws on his experience from previous accolades, such as Walk the Line, his latest effort doesn’t quite match the visual or thematic innovation of its competitors. Surrounding Chalamet are notable performances from Edward Norton, Elle Fanning, and Boyd Holbrook, enhancing the film but failing to overshadow its more inspirational counterparts.

Watch Trailer

9. Emilia Perez

Directed by Jacques Audiard

Emilia Pérez presents a vibrant soap opera that blends melodrama with musical elements to deliver an entertaining, if flawed, experience. This crime thriller, revolving around a Mexican kingpin transitioning into a woman, is both daring and colorful, effectively showcasing catchy musical numbers that elevate its otherwise campy narrative. Director Jacques Audiard embraces bold storytelling that captivates audiences with its fusion of genres.

Featuring dynamic performances from Karla Sofía Gascón and Zoe Saldana, the film artfully intertwines themes of mafia intrigue with the flair of telenovelas, resulting in a uniquely engaging spectacle. While its more serious competitors may overshadow it, for fans of exuberant storytelling, Emilia Pérez is a delightful ride worth experiencing.

8. The Brutalist

Directed By Brady Corbet

The Brutalist presents a somber yet profound exploration of the immigrant experience in America through the lens of László Tóth, played by Adrien Brody. This epic character drama stands out for its comprehensive world-building and poignant performances, evoking the rich humanistic narratives of 20th-century literature. The film dives into the darker shadows of the American dream, carving out a narrative that, while occasionally bleak, offers critical insights on the human condition.

7. Dune: Part Two

Directed By Denis Villeneuve

Dune: Part Two masterfully completes the adaptation of Frank Herbert’s seminal science fiction saga, delivering an exhilarating cinematic journey. This sequel amplifies the world-building of its predecessor and focuses on Paul Atreides’ transformative journey toward leadership, presenting a unique take on the archetypal hero’s journey. The film boasts remarkable performances, particularly from Javier Bardem and Zendaya, marking it as a cinematic event that deserves to be viewed on the big screen.

6. Wicked

Directed By Jon M. Chu

Following suit with Dune: Part Two, Wicked stands as a vibrant, thrilling adaptation of the beloved Broadway musical. With dazzling sets and lively musical numbers, this film quickly engages audiences. Cynthia Erivo and Ariana Grande deliver standout performances, effectively breathing life into their roles while retaining emotional depth and comedic charm.

Though the film occasionally grapples with character development and the depth of its supporting cast, its infectious joy and dazzling production make it a memorable cinematic experience, especially when contrasted with the year’s darker narratives.

5. I’m Still Here

Directed By Walter Salles

Adapted from Marcelo Rubens Paiva’s poignant memoir, I’m Still Here dives deep into the emotional toll of political bravery on its protagonist’s loved ones, particularly centering on his wife Eunice as she seeks the truth behind her husband’s mysterious disappearance. The film, while heavy in subject matter, presents a powerful narrative that resonates with human emotion.

Leading the cast with a breathtaking performance, Fernanda Torres generates significant acclaim, earning a Golden Globe for her portrayal. The film places the weight of its narrative squarely on the human experience, skillfully balancing pathos with political realities, resulting in a quietly profound work that speaks to timely themes of grief and resilience.

4. Nickel Boys

Directed By RaMell Ross

Nickel Boys emerges as one of the most innovative entries in this year’s lineup, capturing the harrowing experiences of two African-American boys subjected to abuse within a reform school during a racially charged era. Through a unique first-person perspective, director RaMell Ross immerses the audience in the struggles faced by the protagonists, ensuring a powerful connection to their plight.

3. The Substance

Directed By Coralie Fargeat

In a bold blending of satire, horror, and comedy, The Substance tackles the intersection of celebrity culture and societal issues through a gripping narrative. Demi Moore shines in her transformative role, delivering a performance that encapsulates both vulnerability and strength. Fargeat’s direction harnesses the potency of genre filmmaking to create a resonant commentary on society, providing a thrilling yet reflective cinematic experience.

2. Conclave

Directed By Edward Berger

Conclave is a politically charged drama that transcends typical storytelling clichés, thanks to its remarkable screenplay and compelling performances led by Ralph Fiennes. This film’s artistry lies in its ability to transform a seemingly mundane plot into a visually rich exploration of faith and responsibility. The screenplay by Peter Straughan successfully elevates the narrative stakes, making it a notable contender in this year’s Best Picture nominees.

1. Pomegranate

Directed By Sean Baker

As a modern American fable, Anora emerges as the pinnacle of 2024’s cinematic offerings, capturing the complexities of its characters while remaining both entertaining and introspective. Sean Baker’s direction shines as he skillfully weaves humor and tragedy, giving audiences an authentic glimpse into the lives of his characters, particularly through the standout performance of Mikey Madison. Anora expertly challenges expectations, delivering a multifaceted examination of wealth, human experience, and the societal structures that define us.

The film sets itself apart from its competitors, marking it as a deserving winner among the Best Picture nominees at the 97th Academy Awards.

Source & Images