Ranking the 10 Main Characters of American Primeval from Worst to Best

Warning: Contains SPOILERS for American Primeval!

The Netflix miniseries American Primeval features an impressive ensemble cast, showcasing a sprawling narrative set against the backdrop of the American frontier. Central to the story are Sara Rowell and her son Devin as they navigate numerous dangers in their quest to find Devin’s father. However, the series is rich with intersecting storylines that introduce a host of other compelling characters. Here’s a ranking of the ten main characters from least to most engaging.

10. James Wosley

Played By Joe Tippett

Dane DeHaan rides a horse as Jacob Pratt with Mormon soldiers in American Primeval — Image via Netflix

Among the main cast, James Wosley stands out as the least captivating character. As the leader of the Mormon militia, he grapples with the fallout of the Mountain Meadows Massacre. While Wosley’s partnership with Jacob Pratt has its moments, it’s largely overshadowed, as Jacob’s character often steals the scene. Played effectively by Joe Tippett, Wosley’s underdeveloped villainy makes him forgettable compared to other figures in the series.

9. Virgil Cutter

Played By Jai Courtney

Virgil Cutter is depicted as a rugged bounty hunter in search of Sara and her party for a financial reward. Although portrayed by the well-known Jai Courtney, this character struggles to leave a lasting impression within the broader narrative of American Primeval. Despite his ruthless nature, Cutter lacks the charisma and depth of other antagonists, making him feel like just another face in a crowded villain lineup.

8. Red Feather

Played By Derek Hinkey

Red Feather, a leader of the Shoshone tribe’s Wolf Clan, reflects the stereotypical depiction of a Western antagonist within the early episodes of American Primeval. Although portrayed by Derek Hinkey, his character lacks depth initially. Over time, Red Feather’s storyline becomes more nuanced, especially through his evolving relationships, yet he still embodies a conventional role in the narrative.

7. Two Moons

Played By Shawnee Pourier

Two Moons, an Indigenous girl who escapes her village, initially possesses intrigue as she joins Sara and Devin’s journey. Nonetheless, as the plot unfolds, her role diminishes, reducing her to a passive character observing rather than participating actively. Her relationship with Devin adds some complexity, but ultimately her arc feels sidelined.

6. Abish Pratt

Played By Saura Lightfoot-Leon

Abish Pratt emerges as a compelling figure within the series. Initially introduced as a survivor of the Mountain Meadows Massacre, her journey with red feather’s tribe brings unique perspectives to the storyline. Despite her significant themes and the shocking twist of her fate in the finale, Abish’s role sometimes feels more like a plot device than a fully realized character.

5. Devin Rowell

Played By Preston Mota

As Sara’s son, Devin Rowell confronts numerous challenges throughout the series. Played by Preston Mota, the young actor brings depth to his character, particularly through the struggles stemming from his leg injuries, which introduce tension into Sara’s quest. However, Devin’s repetitive injuries weaken his arc and confine him to a supporting role by the finale.

4. Isaac Reed

Played By Taylor Kitsch

Taylor Kitsch shines as Isaac Reed, the male lead who embodies the archetype of the rugged frontiersman. While his involvement in action-packed scenes adds excitement, Isaac’s character lacks depth beyond the traditional stoicism. A more nuanced portrayal would have elevated his significance in the series.

3. Sara Rowell

Played By Betty Gilpin

Sara Rowell, the main protagonist played by Betty Gilpin, shows resilience as she embarks on a relentless quest to find her son’s father. Her complex criminal backstory enriches her character. Despite presenting as a strong lead, her development stagnates until the crucial final moments of the series.

2. Jacob Pratt

Played By Dane DeHaan

Dane DeHaan’s portrayal of Jacob Pratt brings much-needed complexity to the narrative. His character transforms from a seemingly simple Mormon settler to a man on a gripping quest to rescue his wife, Abish. The exploration of his faith and moral dilemmas showcases a rich character arc, making him one of the standout figures in the miniseries.

1. Jim Bridger

Played By Shea Whigham

Jim Bridger, brilliantly portrayed by Shea Whigham, emerges as the most engaging character in the series. While his storyline occasionally diverges from the main plot, his sharp wit and critiques of the Mormon governance provide levity to an otherwise intense narrative. Bridger’s intriguing backstory adds layers to his character, solidifying his status as the most captivating figure in American Primeval.

Source & Images