Ranking Every Mainline Pokemon Generation Based on Storyline Quality

Ranking Every Mainline Pokemon Generation Based on Storyline Quality

For aspiring Pokémon trainers, there are a multitude of paths one can take in the Pokémon universe. Whether your goal is to complete the Pokédex, assemble a Living Dex, or train a top-tier competitive team by perfecting individual values (IVs), there’s something for everyone. Some players immerse themselves in the rich lore of the games, seeking out enigmatic mysteries like the Lumiose City Ghost in Pokémon X and Y. Others simply enjoy the vibrant characters and engaging narratives that unfold throughout the series.

If you’re curious about which stories from the mainline Pokémon series stand out as the most iconic, continue reading!

This article will specifically examine the original entries in each Pokémon generation, intentionally excluding remakes and semi-spin-offs like Pokémon Legends: Arceus. These later titles often serve to enhance the narratives of earlier games.

Warning: Spoilers ahead for various Pokémon game plots!

9. Generation 2

Pokémon Gold/Silver/Crystal

Pokémon Gold and Silver Trainer Red Battle

The second generation, featuring Gold, Silver, and Crystal, builds directly upon the narrative of Generation 1 with Team Rocket’s return and their ongoing search for Giovanni, the notorious villain from the prior games. What truly distinguishes this generation is its unique feature: after the credits, players can explore Kanto and witness its transformation over the three years since Generation 1.

This installment also introduces significant Box Legendaries, such as Ho-Oh and Lugia, alongside the roaming Pokémon Suicune, Entei, and Raikou, allowing for more extensive storytelling. Additionally, players face off against Red, the hero from the previous generation, in a satisfying narrative callback.

While the story impact may not be as profound, due to its reliance on previous characters and plots, Generation 2 compensates with an expansive world and gameplay improvements that enhance the overall experience.

8. Generation 8

Pokémon Sword/Shield

Pokémon Sword and Shield Route Walking, Trainer Spotted

Generation 8 marks the Pokémon franchise’s debut on the Nintendo Switch with Pokémon Sword and Shield, set in the author’s home country of the UK. Players navigate the challenges posed by gym leaders on their journey to the Champion Cup, all while uncovering the mysteries surrounding Box Legendaries Zacian and Zamazenta, connected to Galar’s current energy crisis.

However, many players have noted issues with the narrative pacing, particularly regarding late-game reveals that diminish the impact of villain reveals. The downloadable content (DLC) provides a more rewarding experience, showcasing memorable moments featuring characters like Calyrex and the rivals Klara and Avery. Nevertheless, it falls short compared to the storytelling depth of Generation 7.

7. Generation 1

Pokémon Red/Blue/Green/Yellow

Pokémon Red and Blue Town

As the foundational titles of the franchise, Generation 1 presents a straightforward narrative in comparison to later installments. Its central theme revolves around the moral lesson of not stealing, a valuable message that may not resonate as strongly as themes presented in subsequent generations.

Notably absent are the Box Legendaries, although the enigmatic appearances of Mewtwo and the urban legend of Mew added intrigue. The rivalry with characters like Blue/Gary, who is genuinely competitive rather than a mere ally, coupled with the climactic reveal of Giovanni’s dual role as the Viridian City Gym Leader, creates a memorable, albeit simplistic, adventure.

6. Generation 3

Pokémon Ruby/Sapphire/Emerald

Pokémon Ruby Sapphire Player Surfing, Trainer Spotted

Released on the Game Boy Advance, Generation 3 showcased enhanced graphics and a more intricate storyline. Players encounter not one, but two villainous organizations, Team Aqua and Team Magma, each with their own goals to reshape the world by controlling water and land using the Box Legendaries Kyogre and Groudon.

The narrative deepens in Pokémon Emerald, where both teams engage in a race that ultimately requires the player to enlist the aid of Rayquaza to restore balance. This generation presents varied rival experiences, with characters like May/Brendan lacking development, while Wally’s progression is notably impactful.

5. Generation 6

Pokémon X/Y

Pokémon X and Y Running Over Bridge

Generation 6 is marked by a sense of unrealized potential. While Pokémon X and Y venture into a fictional French region with grand themes such as Mega Evolutions and ancient history, the narrative falls short of fully exploiting these ideas.

The adventure features Team Flare, who initially appear to embody traditional villainy through their quest for beauty. However, their darker ambitions involve pursuing a weapon of mass destruction, an unexpected element for a game aimed at a younger audience. Further complexity comes from the character AZ, a 3000-year-old figure who previously wielded this weapon to end a great war.

Regrettably, the game fails to delve into these profound concepts sufficiently, leaving many questions unanswered—until the announcement of Pokémon Legends: ZA, which may provide the long-awaited exploration of these themes.

4. Generation 4

Pokémon Diamond/Pearl/Platinum

Pokémon Platinum Giratina Spear Pillar

With Generation 4, the series deepens its narrative complexity, exploring themes of emotion, knowledge, and willpower while still revolving around the traditional quest to thwart evil teams. The introduction of Arceus as the God Pokémon, alongside Dialga, Palkia, and Giratina, brings significant depth to the lore, adding layers of intrigue to the gameplay.

Fan-favorite supporting characters like Barry and Cynthia, along with the detective figure Looker, contribute to Generation 4’s lasting legacy as a beloved chapter in Pokémon storytelling.

3. Generation 5

Pokémon Black/White & Black 2/White 2

Pokémon Black and White Elesa Battle - Lilligant vs Zebstrika

Regarded as a pinnacle of narrative execution in the Pokémon series, Generation 5 sets itself apart by challenging established conventions. Taking place in a fictional version of New York, these titles introduce 156 new Pokémon while grappling with philosophical themes surrounding ideals and truths versus humanity’s relationship with Pokémon.

The character development of N serves as a highlight, providing insight into his disillusionment with humanity’s treatment of Pokémon. While the climax eventually returns to familiar tropes of world domination, Generation 5 explores deeper moral questions that resonate well beyond the scope of traditional Pokémon narratives.

Additionally, the introduction of sequels with Black 2 and White 2 expands on the story, enriching the experience and offering fans more to explore. The dialogue includes some of the most memorable quotes in the franchise, leaving a lasting impact on players.

2. Generation 7

Pokémon Sun/Moon & Ultra Sun/Ultra Moon

Mimikyu Pokémon Sun and Moon - Seeeeee Please?! Text

Generation 7 is often described as being more guided, with a narrative that becomes intricately layered. The games feature alternate dimensions and the intriguing concept of Ultra Beasts, alongside a central villain characterized by a deep, almost obsessive connection to family.

While the gameplay may feel excessively linear to seasoned players, the emotional depth portrayed in Sun/Moon and their enhanced counterparts reveals the potential for a more nuanced story within the franchise—if they were allocated the necessary resources to develop these storytelling threads further.

1. Generation 9

Pokémon Scarlet/Violet

Pokémon Scarlet And Violet DLC Carmine Telling Kiki She Told Him To Hush

Despite criticism surrounding Pokémon Scarlet and Violet, including concerns over premature releases and glitches, I assert that these games are noteworthy, primarily due to their storytelling approach. They introduce an open-world design, breaking free from the linear exploration of previous titles, allowing players to tackle gyms in any order.

In addition to the traditional gym battles, players can embark on unique questlines, like the compelling ‘Path of Legends’ which involves battling Titan Pokémon. The post-game content, particularly Area Zero, presents an emotional narrative that stands out as one of the most heartfelt in the franchise’s history.

With the DLC, the overarching story evolves even further, filled with twists and introducing some of the franchise’s most dynamic characters, such as Carmine and Kieran. Overall, while the academy setting and treasure hunt premise may seem contrived, the story in Generation 9 signifies a substantial evolution in Pokémon narratives, instilling optimism for the franchise’s future.

Source&Images

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *