Ranking Every Game Pack in The Sims 4

In August 2000, the iconic Sims franchise introduced its first downloadable content (DLC) pack, marking the beginning of a legacy that would significantly expand gameplay experiences. This initial addition, The Sims: Livin’ Large, was thematic in nature, enriching the game with new objects and gameplay possibilities. Over the years, each successive version of the game brought a wealth of expansions, starting with seven for The Sims 1 and escalating to eight for The Sims 2. By the conclusion of The Sims 3, players had access to an impressive eleven expansions as well as nine stuff packs.

As the franchise evolved, so did its approach to DLC. Currently, The Sims 4 boasts an astonishing 84 DLC packs, incorporating expansions, game packs, stuff packs, and kits. With 12 game packs available, the variance in their value calls for a detailed assessment of these packs, highlighting the top contenders and their unique features.

Understanding the Scoring Methodology

The evaluation of each game pack is based on a structured point system, ensuring that we analyze each aspect’s contribution to gameplay:

Worlds: Gain 2 points for introducing a new world. Worlds are rated for interactivity, design, and feasibility of use.
CAS Items: Earn 2 points for offering quality and thematic variety in clothing and accessories.
Build/Buy Objects: Another 2 points can be earned for providing unique, versatile items that enhance building creativity.
Gameplay Mechanics: Up to 2.5 points are available here for innovative new features, gameplay depth, and replayability.
Base Game Enhancement: Finally, packs receive 1.5 points for effectively integrating with the base game without reliance on other DLCs.

This scoring system totals a possible 10 points per pack. It’s important to note that performance issues like bugs and glitches—common in nearly all The Sims 4 DLC—are not considered in this evaluation. Fortunately, many community mods exist to rectify these issues, making them fully playable even when official patches are lacking.

12 Star Wars: The Journey

A Mouthful with Limited Value

Score	Key Takeaway
Overall Score	3/10	A niche pack that contributes minimally to the broader Sims 4 narrative.
CAS	0/2	While the clothing is authentic, it lacks versatility and relevance outside Batuu.
Build/Buy	1/2	Offers some well-designed items, but these lack practicality outside the Batuu experience.
World	0/2	Though visually impressive, Batuu is impractical for residential gameplay.
Gameplay	1.5/2.5	Engaging story missions, but lacking in replayability and integration with main gameplay.
Added Value	0.5/1.5	Despite its ambition, it remains niche and impractical for general gameplay.

As a die-hard Trekkie, I appreciate the effort put into this pack; however, the actual gameplay value falls short. The stunning visuals and quality items don’t enhance the core experience of The Sims 4. If you’re looking to create a permanent home in Batuu, you’ll be disappointed as it’s designed solely for short visits.

11 Outdoor Retreat

A Brief Escape to Nature

Score	Key Takeaway
Overall Score	5/10	Ideal for short camping trips but lacking depth for long-term gameplay.
CAS	1/2	Offers some outdoor-themed clothing but is quite limited in variety.
Build/Buy	1.5/2	Provides decent camping items but insufficient for a full cabin setup.
World	1/2	Granite Falls features beauty but lacks interactive depth and activities.
Gameplay	1/2.5	Introduces the Herbalism skill but overall gameplay feels simplistic.
Added Value	0.5/1.5	Modestly complements outdoor-themed expansions but lacks standalone depth.

This early Sims 4 addition lacks the assets and functionality to justify its purchase. While it excels in some areas, it ultimately requires other expansions for players to get the most out of camping experiences.

10 Dine Out

Enhancement With User Modifications

Score	Key Takeaway
Overall Score	6/10	A niche but fun addition that shines when enhancements are utilized.
CAS	1.5/2	Offers stylish options, primarily for restaurant staff attire.
Build/Buy	2/2	Provides essential elements for building functional restaurants.
World	0/2	No new world is added; players utilize existing ones.
Gameplay	1.5/2.5	Owning restaurants can be enjoyable, albeit with limited roles for staff.
Added Value	1/1.5	Offers storytelling potential, but may disappoint those not interested in restaurant management.

Dine Out is well-known for its shortcomings, particularly in the gameplay mechanics. Players gain access to a variety of clothing options, but most are functional only for staff. Construction elements offer some aesthetic choices, but many issues prevent it from being purely enjoyable.

9 Parenthood

A Family-Oriented Gameplay Experience

Score	Key Takeaway
Overall Score	6.5/10	An adequate starter pack focusing on family gameplay.
CAS	1.5/2	Offers quirky family-themed attire, although limited in offerings.
Build/Buy	2/2	Provides a solid selection of furniture and activities for a family setup.
World	0/2	No new world included.
Gameplay	2/2.5	Offers valuable character-building interactions but limited overall depth.
Added Value	1/1.5	While useful, it feels incomplete without owning additional family-themed packs.

A spiritual successor to The Sims 3’s Generations, the Parenthood pack aims to enrich family dynamics. The expansive building and buying options allow for the creation of warm, homely environments, yet without the supporting family packs, it feels like just a piece of a larger puzzle.

8 Spa Day

Relaxation and Gameplay Combined

Score	Key Takeaway
Overall Score	6.5/10	A staple for builders and gameplay enthusiasts post-refresh.
CAS	1.5/2	Modern activewear and cosmetic choices are a significant welcome.
Build/Buy	2/2	A wide array of contemporary objects necessary for a spa.
World	0/2	No new world introduced, but access to new spa venues remains.
Gameplay	2/2.5	Introduces skills and activities enriching the experience, albeit without a playable career.
Added Value	1/1.5	Offers enough engaging features to warrant its value in The Sims 4.

This pack stands out with its spa-completion themes and refreshing activities. Though it lacks a world of its own, it provides excellent gameplay through hireable spa services and a variety of modern build items, enhancing overall user experiences.

7 My Wedding Stories

Elevating the Wedding Experience

Score	Key Takeaway
Overall Score	7/10	Despite the bugs, this is a renewed take on weddings with diverse options.
CAS	2/2	High-quality diverse wedding garments.
Build/Buy	2/2	Rustic and elegant elements suitable for Mediterranean aesthetics.
World	1.5/2	Tartosa is visually stunning with functional venues.
Gameplay	1/2.5	Limited replayability with a variety of interactions and activities.
Added Value	0.5/1.5	A great addition though not essential for gameplay.

This pack excels in offering diverse wedding attire and innovative gameplay features. Despite its bugs, it successfully refreshes the wedding experience within The Sims 4.

6 StrangerVille

Engaging Quirkiness

Score	Key Takeaway
Overall Score	7/10	A unique addition that supports an engaging narrative.
CAS	1.5/2	Good variety of quirky and functional clothing.
Build/Buy	1.5/2	Unique build items with various styles and themes.
World	1.5/2	An intriguing and beautifully designed location.
Gameplay	2/2.5	Compelling detective gameplay with complexity and replay value.
Added Value	0.5/1.5	Key for storytelling but primarily targets mystery enthusiasts.

This pack offers a delightful detective experience set in a quirky, visually captivating world. Its unique design assets and a detective story make it a great addition to your Sims toolkit.

5 Dream Home Decorator

A Home Renovation Experience

Score	Key Takeaway
Overall Score	7/10	An impressive pack with functionality across multiple gameplay styles.
CAS	2/2	Offers fashionable options perfect for renovation professionals.
Build/Buy	2/2	Modern furniture sets to accommodate any build style.
World	0/2	No new world, but provides excellent assets for various projects.
Gameplay	2/2.5	Interactive career redesign for major engagement and fun.
Added Value	1/1.5	A valuable addition for builders and gameplay enthusiasts alike.

The Dream Home Decorator pack invites players to take on a professional renovation role. It offers extensive build options and an engaging career path that provides a fresh take on interior design within the game.

4 Werewolves

Unleashing a New Experience

Score	Key Takeaway
Overall Score	7.5/10	A worthwhile pack for Sims players of all kinds.
CAS	1.5/2	Excellent grunge attire options ideal for storytelling.
Build/Buy	1.5/2	Unique thematic items for a suitably rustic build outcome.
World	1.5/2	Moonwood Hill offers an atmospheric setting, albeit small.
Gameplay	2/2.5	Rich lore and engaging systems for werewolves enhance the experience.
Added Value	1/1.5	Fosters a unique occult environment with substantial gameplay offerings.

With a fresh take on The Sims 4, this pack brings forth a unique werewolf lifestyle with engaging gameplay mechanics and rich lore, providing players with diverse options in customization and storytelling.

3 Realm of Magic

Mastering the Arcane

Score	Key Takeaway
Overall Score	8/10	A seamless addition to the broader suite of magic-themed assets.
CAS	2/2	A range of spellcaster outfits catering to diverse aesthetics.
Build/Buy	1.5/2	Offers unique magical furniture pieces, but fewer overall than desired.
World	1.5/2	Glimmerbrook is enchanting despite limited residential options.
Gameplay	2/2.5	Innovative mechanics with student-like growth and discovery.
Added Value	1/1.5	Provides compelling mechanics and enchantments, benefiting players across themes.

This pack offers an expansive and engaging dive into magical gameplay, with numerous customization options, themed assets, and interactive features that round out the Sims experience beautifully.

2 Vampires

A Classic Gothic Adventure

Score	Key Takeaway
Overall Score	8.5/10	An essential addition to the supernatural experience in The Sims 4.
CAS	2/2	High-quality Gothic-inspired clothing options for customization.
Build/Buy	2/2	Provides comprehensive decor for creating Gothic-themed buildings.
World	1/2	Forgotten Hollow offers a melancholic atmosphere, though it feels underutilized.
Gameplay	2.5/2.5	A robust and replayable vampire experience brimming with lore.
Added Value	1/1.5	Rich in content that caters to varied storylines and character types.

The introduction of the vampire life state is a game-changer, allowing players to craft a truly immersive dark narrative. The beautifully curated aesthetics complement gameplay, ensuring that this pack is a must-have for fans of the supernatural.

1 Jungle Adventure

An Exploratory Delight

Score	Key Takeaway
Overall Score	9/10	The ultimate pack for exploration, creativity, and storytelling.
CAS	2/2	Vibrant clothing options that reflect adventurous spirit.
Build/Buy	2/2	A wide range of items suitable for various builds.
World	2/2	Selvadorada is a breathtaking and interactive environment.
Gameplay	2/2.5	Exploration-oriented gameplay featuring archaeological elements.
Added Value	1/1.5	Invaluable for enriching the gameplay experience across the board.

This pack successfully merges various cultural influences and retro adventure elements, providing a well-rounded experience for players. The blend of exploration, storytelling, and unique gameplay outcomes solidifies Jungle Adventure as a standout addition to the Sims universe.

Source & Images