Over the last decade, The Game Awards has become a hallmark event in the gaming industry, shining a spotlight on the finest video games across various genres. The Game of the Year (GOTY) award, however, remains the most prestigious recognition, celebrating the standout title chosen by an esteemed panel of experts along with feedback from the gaming community.
This annual event frequently incites debate, yet it draws significant attention, making it essential in the eyes of developers and gamers alike. As we look back, it’s worth reviewing the winners from the past ten years and offering a ranking from least to most deserving GOTY titles.
This analysis will strictly evaluate the winners themselves, without delving into their competition or the nomination process.
11 Overwatch
A Dead Revolution
Despite the discussions surrounding Overwatch’s influence on modern multiplayer gaming, it remains the sole GOTY winner that is no longer playable, creating a significant concern for its legacy. Following its transition to Overwatch 2, the original game has faded from both digital and physical landscapes, erasing the experience for players.
While it certainly built on the groundwork laid by Team Fortress 2 and showcased a striking audiovisual aesthetic, its overall uniqueness is debatable. The game undeniably shaped the online landscape, but whether that impact was beneficial remains an open question.
10 It Takes Two
Charming Co-op For Couples
It Takes Two stands out as one of the most delightful cooperative experiences in recent gaming history, offering an innovative puzzle-platformer that is inviting to a wide audience. However, after engaging in a session with a friend, I noted several significant flaws that detract from its cooperative gameplay.
The story lacks memorability, the campaign feels unevenly paced despite its length, and at times the focus on sheer volume leads to inconsistent chapter quality. Though I commend The Game Awards for celebrating unique titles outside typical blockbusters, It Takes Two may not have been the best representative in this effort.
9 God of War
A Potential Not Yet Fulfilled
God of War is commendable for its transformation of an established franchise by Santa Monica Studio, undertaking a bold reimagining. Nevertheless, the full potential of the 2018 release only truly materialized with God of War: Ragnarök, which improved upon its predecessor in multiple aspects.
This initial entry in the Nordic saga exhibits several design shortcomings, such as repetitive enemy encounters and a confusing interface. While I have great affection for the original trilogy, God of War falls short of the level of precision and quality that fans expect from the series.
8 The Last of Us Part II
Among the Greatest Sequels
While many argue that the original The Last of Us eclipses its sequel, I find that The Last of Us Part II vastly enriches the franchise. Although it struggles with pacing and cohesiveness, it enhances every element the first game introduced.
This sequel displays Naughty Dog’s mastery of storytelling, and though it’s not my personal pick for GOTY, its acknowledgment as such reflects commendable boldness within the AAA game sector.
7 Astro Bot
Controversial But Deserved
In an industry where platformers are often sidelined, Astro Bot reestablishes the genre’s value and charm. Crafting a heartfelt tribute to the PlayStation brand and showcasing exceptional platforming, Team ASOBI delivers an experience replete with nostalgia and creativity.
It is my hope that Astro Bot will prompt Sony to embrace its roots and diversify its portfolio, moving beyond a sole focus on cinematic, third-person narratives.
6 Dragon Age: Inquisition
BioWare’s Gem
Upon the arrival of the eighth console generation, Dragon Age: Inquisition emerged as a pivotal title that exemplified the era’s change. Alongside Mass Effect 2, this installment showcases BioWare’s peak creativity and design across all dimensions.
With its epic gameplay, artistic vision, and captivating storyline, it represented a pinnacle for RPGs during its time. Notably, many successors have built upon its legacy, yet even today, Dragon Age: Inquisition remains a timeless role-playing adventure.
5 Baldur’s Gate 3
A Necessary GOTY
In an industry often driven by genre trends, Baldur’s Gate 3 emerges as a standout RPG that not only excels in gameplay but also sets a benchmark for future titles. Larian Studios has consistently impressed, and this title encapsulates their vision in its finest form.
Baldur’s Gate 3 offers a diverse range of gameplay and narrative choices, establishing itself as a seminal work within the RPG category that will surely be remembered.
4 The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
Unique and Unmatched
Some games leave an indelible mark, transforming player perceptions of a genre. For me, that game is The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt.
Following my adventure in CD Projekt RED’s world, I found my expectations for RPGs raised significantly, making it challenging to find similar enjoyment in others. With its unparalleled depth, immersive environment, and rich character development, The Witcher 3 offers an experience that stands the test of time.
3 Axe: Shadows Die Twice
Perfection Achieved
Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice stands out as a remarkable benchmark in my gaming journey, showcasing near-perfection across gameplay, storytelling, visuals, and sound. FromSoftware’s creation delivers a level of polish that is rare for games of its stature.
Its combat system is not only the finest but also inspires remarkable replayability. Sekiro represents a remarkable achievement that I doubt will be matched in the near future.
2 The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild
The Turning Point of Open Worlds
Many consider 2017 to be one of the best years in gaming, greatly influenced by The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild. It wouldn’t be hyperbolic to claim it stands as one of Nintendo’s finest achievements, redefining how players engage with gaming as an art form.
Even those not ardently following the series are captivated by its intricacies and visuals, creating an immersive experience that few games can replicate for years to come. Despite a few tedious elements, such as the Korok Seeds, Breath of the Wild symbolizes Nintendo’s legacy and innovation.
1 The Fire Ring
The Journey of a Lifetime
In my extensive gaming experience, no title has resonated with me like Elden Ring. Despite its flaws relative to others, this game is a prime example of why I firmly believe video games are an art form that commands universal recognition.
The emotional journey and the rich experiences it offers within The Lands Between create unforgettable memories that are foundational to my passion for the medium. Over the past decade, Elden Ring’s dominance stands as undeniable, marking an unparalleled chapter in gaming history.
Leave a Reply