The Pokémon anime stands out for its ability to reinvent itself periodically, a strategy that has contributed significantly to its enduring success. Each new iteration showcases not only fresh characters and settings but also a reimagined Ash Ketchum, altering his appearance and, at times, his personality to match the evolving narrative.
This constant evolution has sparked extensive debates among fans regarding the various versions of Ash. Frequently, these discussions align with the perceived quality of writing in different series. To rank the various incarnations of Ash Ketchum, various factors will be assessed, including his design, appeal, and combat performance. The aim is to create a comprehensive ranking that encapsulates fan sentiments towards these iterations over the years.
8 You become Ash
Pokémon: Black and White
The Unova version of Ash, featured in the Black and White series, is often regarded as the least favorable. This iteration can be seen as a reboot, stripping Ash of much of the knowledge and experience he had acquired in past seasons. Notably, he suffered an unexpected defeat against a novice trainer’s Snivy early in the series—a moment that stands out for its controversy. Furthermore, Ash’s performance in league tournaments faltered, as he settled for a top-eight finish compared to his previous final four ranking in Sinnoh.
Compounding these issues, Ash’s companions during the Unova journey, Iris and Cilan, did not resonate well with audiences. Many considered their roles to be pale imitations of previous companions, Misty and Brock. The dynamic between Ash and Iris began on a rocky note with frequent disputes, and their relationship failed to evolve into a more meaningful bond. Meanwhile, Cilan often came across as dull, leaving little impact on Ash’s journey.
7 Alola Ash
Pokémon: Sun & Moon
The series Pokémon: Sun & Moon generated its own set of controversies, chiefly due to its distinctive art style. Ash’s exaggerated new look and animated expressions were met with mixed reactions among fans. Instead of embarking on a traditional journey, Ash attended a Pokémon school, which some viewers critiqued as unnecessary given his vast experience.
However, the series also celebrated notable features, most significantly Ash’s first league championship victory. With classmates as companions, Ash developed unique relationships—particularly with Lillie and Professor Kukui. Ash’s progression was highlighted through Z-Crystals, which provided an exciting new method for empowering Pokémon while feeling rewarding.
6 Hoenn Ash
Pokémon: Ruby and Sapphire
In the Ruby and Sapphire series, viewers witnessed significant revisions to Ash’s character. This marked the first major redesign, generating mixed opinions at first, although audiences eventually embraced his new aesthetic. Unlike in Black and White, Ash retained the skills and composure he had previously developed, portraying a more refined and mature persona.
Accompanied by Brock and new friends May and Max, Ash navigated this new region with a blend of camaraderie and mentorship. While moments arose where he prioritized training over May’s performances, they shared a supportive and transformative journey that echoed the guidance he received from Misty and Brock in earlier series.
5 Stump/Cord Ash
Pokémon the Original Series
The original series features the inaugural rendition of Ash, noted for his growth and development as a Pokémon trainer. This initial phase showcases a fledgling Ash who embarks on his journey with enthusiasm yet faces many challenges, exemplified by his humbling experience in the Indigo League. As his travels progressed into Johto, Ash’s prowess improved significantly, culminating in a victory over his longtime rival, Gary.
Recognized for its iconic design, this version of Ash remains the most recognized and nostalgic depiction. The dynamics with his companions, particularly Misty and Brock, added depth to his character, even with frequent bickering between him and Misty. His rivalry with Gary became one of the most compelling aspects of his journey, pushing him beyond his limits.
4 Sinnoh Ash
Pokémon: Diamond and Pearl
The Diamond and Pearl series is often celebrated as a fan favorite, showcasing Ash’s impressive growth and strategic advancement. Carrying over elements from his earlier character development, this series highlighted Ash’s inventive battling methods, such as the introduction of techniques like the Counter Shield. His impressive strategies allowed him to secure a top-four placement in the Sinnoh League, marking a peak in his competitive success.
Brock continued as Ash’s constant companion in this series, with the introduction of Dawn, whose supportive friendship with Ash became one of the defining features of their journey. Meanwhile, Paul emerged as a formidable rival, offering a contrasting training ideology that challenged Ash and pushed him to refine his skills.
3 Journeys Ash
Pokémon Journeys
In the Pokémon Journeys series, Ash’s development reached new heights, marking a culmination of his character arc. His team in this series is arguably the strongest he has ever assembled, showcasing thorough training and strategic prowess during battles. This was clearly demonstrated during the World Coronation Series when he triumphed over the undefeated Leon.
With only one primary companion, Goh, Ash’s journey featured support from various characters, including familiar faces like Chloe and Gary, who took on new roles. Despite mixed opinions on Goh, the camaraderie between the two proved to be a highlight. Ash’s modern design retained elements from his past, thereby providing both nostalgia and freshness.
2 Alternate Universe Ash
Pokémon Movies: I Choose You!, The Power of Us, and Secrets of the Jungle
Often not fully appreciated, the alternate universe version of Ash showcased in the recent Pokémon movies stands out as a compelling reinterpretation. These films retell significant moments from Ash’s origin while adopting a streamlined narrative approach, resulting in a portrayal of Ash as a remarkably competent trainer, devoid of some of the sillier elements of the original series.
In these movies, Ash interacts with different companions across each installment, emphasizing his relationship with Pikachu. Although his connections with others may be less developed, Ash still experiences notable growth and maintains his inherent likability, albeit with a more refined demeanor compared to the original series.
1 Kalos Ash
Pokémon: XY
Concluding our ranking is the Kalos version of Ash, presented in the Pokémon XY series. This iteration features a refreshed design that subtly suggests an older Ash despite his age still being officially 10 years. This aligns beautifully with the series’ shonen tone while reflecting a maturation in Ash’s character, particularly as he guides Serena in her journey.
In the company of Clemont, his sister Bonnie, and Serena, Ash fostered a positive and nurturing environment. His admiration for Clemont’s inventions and support for Serena’s aspirations enriched the narrative. Most impressively, Ash’s battle techniques reached an all-time high, culminating in a second-place finish in the Kalos League, alongside enhanced bonds with his Pokémon, particularly Greninja. Therefore, the Kalos version of Ash is widely regarded as the pinnacle of his character throughout the Pokémon series.
Leave a Reply