The Mario franchise has made a remarkable leap into the realm of 3D gaming, consistently delivering hit titles that resonate with players. As we anticipate the launch of the upcoming Switch 2, the excitement builds around the prospect of a new 3D Mario adventure. In light of this, let’s take a moment to reflect on the remarkable legacy of this iconic series.
For the purpose of this discussion, I will exclusively evaluate the core 3D Super Mario platformers. While there may be varying opinions on what constitutes a mainline entry, I’ll focus on the unique titles within this category. Notably, this ranking will not consider “enhanced”ports, as they would distract us with debates about variations like Mario 64 DS or the improved Switch release of 3D World.
Our goal is to rank the games based on their unique contributions, ensuring that each title is evaluated on its own merit. Let’s see how they measure up against some of the greatest games of all time.
8 Super Mario 3D Land
Tiny, Repetitive Adventures
In all honesty, every game on this list is enjoyable, but Super Mario 3D Land ranks lowest primarily due to its more confined scope. Drawing significant inspiration from Super Mario Bros.3, it offers a fun experience throughout, although it lacks a distinct identity, leading to a feeling of repetitiveness.
This game exemplifies a somewhat formulaic approach typical of early 2010s Mario games. While it’s certainly not as disappointing as New Super Mario Bros., I wish it had embraced more originality. Unlike other entries, it doesn’t introduce groundbreaking ideas or power-ups—rather, it plays it safe, making it a game I find myself less inclined to revisit.
7 Super Mario Galaxy 2
Somewhat Slighted Sequel
Super Mario Galaxy 2 brings a wealth of fun with its new power-ups and engaging mechanics, though it inevitably falls short when compared to its predecessor. Originally intended as downloadable content, this title somewhat disregards the narrative impact of the first game, opting instead for a less compelling story.
While the Cloud Flower stands out as a highlight, most power-ups feel underwhelming or are frustrating to use. The notorious bird levels detract from the experience, and the game’s linear structure, while still enjoyable, keeps it from achieving the same level of excellence as the original.
6 Super Mario Sunshine
Propelled to New Heights
Often seen as the black sheep in the Mario family, Super Mario Sunshine reflects the experimental spirit of the GameCube era. Though it faces criticism for its unconventional gameplay and control mechanics, those willing to embrace its quirks can find a uniquely entertaining experience.
Initially challenging, the controls become more intuitive as players familiarize themselves with Mario’s movements. Despite its bugs and occasionally baffling character dialogues, the game’s unique nature helps it secure a spot on this ranking.
5 Super Mario 64
Supremely Slick
Despite its historical significance as one of the first 3D platformers, Super Mario 64 remains a captivating adventure, albeit hindered by a few dated mechanics. Conventional and fun gameplay is offset by a frustrating camera system and the presence of tedious star collecting tasks, specifically the 100-coin and red-coin challenges.
While it retains its charm, the game’s visuals and textures sometimes detract from the overall experience. Although Super Mario 64 is an enjoyable game, there are other titles in this list that surpass it in terms of quality and innovation.
4 Super Mario 3D World
Platforming Perfected
While Super Mario 3D World sometimes suffers from a lack of innovation similar to that of New Super Mario Bros., it compensates with beautifully designed levels, vibrant themes, and a fantastic soundtrack. The game excels in quality and consistently entertaining design, making it stand out within the series.
Although it doesn’t break new ground beyond the introduction of the cat suit, the enjoyment derived from playing is akin to savoring satisfying comfort food—it’s a good experience that appeals to the masses.
3 Bowser’s Fury
Short, But Surprising
Bowser’s Fury may be brief, but it is a delightful experience that successfully merges elements from 3D World with an open-world exploration format. It features linear platforming challenges woven into a larger interconnected map, inviting players to explore the islands at their own pace.
Just like in titles such as Sonic Frontiers, wandering through expansive spaces and tackling platforming tasks is satisfying, although the game isn’t without its issues—namely the frustration caused by unexpected Bowser encounters and the constant need to re-enter islands.
2 Super Mario Odyssey
Whimsy Incarnate
Among the titles that evoke emotional responses, Super Mario Odyssey tops the list due to its sheer brilliance. Each kingdom is meticulously crafted, boasting unique elements that captivate players. Collecting moons, adorning Mario in whimsical outfits, and engaging with the world’s story arcs offer endless delight.
The open-ended exploration and smooth movement mechanics create an immersive gaming experience that inspired me to attempt speedrunning—though unsuccessfully. Regardless of minor annoyances with the capture feature, the game left a profound impact, bringing me to tears of joy during its finale.
1 Super Mario Galaxy
Landed Among the Stars
It would be a disservice not to recognize Super Mario Galaxy as the pinnacle of 3D platforming. This masterpiece embodies everything that makes Mario games incredible while offering additional layers of depth and emotion.
Featuring an unforgettable soundtrack that varies from energetic to poignantly somber, the game delivers a genuinely touching narrative that is unmatched in the series. The lasting influence of Super Mario Galaxy is a testament to its quality, with many fans yearning for a third installment to this day.
Leave a Reply