Kevin Costner stands as one of the last true movie megastars whose acclaim resonates across Hollywood, echoing the extravagance of classic film legends. Since his acting debut in 1981, Costner has cemented his career both in front of and behind the camera, captivating fans throughout the decades. Recently, he even ventured into directing and acting in the first part of his epic four-part Western saga, Horizon: An American Saga – Chapter I , one of the 2024 films that could become a cult hit in the future.
Throughout his career, Costner has proven to be prolific in every decade, with some of his best work coming in the 1990s as well as his most iconic roles in the 80s being highlighted. The 2000s, however, perfectly illustrate his star power. Despite only having a couple of big films in this period, his career never slowed down, reflecting his tenacity as an actor, director, and producer across over 50 films. Costner has shown that he can withstand major box office defeats and still remain a top-tier performer.
10
Rumor Has It… (2005)
Directed by Rob Reiner
The 2000s were full of “so bad they’re good” movies, and Rumor Has It… slots right into that space. A fun concept that could have become an irreverent comedy in more capable hands ends up being a disappointing experience. Despite its intentions, the film, which attempts to connect to the iconic film The Graduate (1967), wanders into problematic territory that results in a slippery narrative.
With Jennifer Aniston playing a woman who cheats on her fiancé with a man (Costner) whom she believed to be her father until shortly before committing the act, a sensitive subject is touched upon. This film, even considering its context, fails to hold its own and fails to become a meaningful social critique.
9
The New Daughter (2009)
Directed by Luiso Berdejo
In The New Daughter , Costner takes on the role of a single father faced with the difficult task of raising teenagers, whose development is intertwined with elements of horror. Although the premise suggests a powerful drama, it is undermined by the narrative about supernatural creatures that makes the film forgettable and conventional.
Costner’s performance feels disconnected, causing his character to fall into inertia as the plot progresses. Although the final few minutes offer some action, it comes too late to regain interest, as the story’s development seems to rely more on Google search results than on solid narrative development.
8
Swing Vote (2008)
Directed by Joshua Michael Stern
As a political satire, Swing Vote falls short, attempting to explore social responsibility but feeling shallow in its execution. Costner portrays an apathetic character who undergoes an archetypal evolution, culminating in neutral observations that lack real impact.
The highlight comes from Madeline Carroll, who brings sincerity and anchors the cast in a script that otherwise feels absurd. The cartoonish performances of other political characters, such as Kelsey Grammar and Stanley Tucci, add a touch of fun that helps smooth out the narrative shortcomings.
7
3000 Miles to Graceland (2001)
Directed by Demian Lichtenstein
3000 Miles to Graceland , a heist film featuring Elvis impersonators, is in the odd camp of cult films, though it is known more for its uneven performances than its success. Despite Costner’s quirky appearance, the worst part of his performance is felt in the lack of depth of his character.
Despite these drawbacks, there are moments that keep your attention. The exciting action sequences, especially during the shootouts, blend well with the humor that arises between Costner and Russell. Indeed, it can be argued that it manages to fit into the list of Costner’s best action movies.
6
Dragonfly (2002)
Directed by Tom Shadyac
Considered by many to be one of Costner’s worst works, Dragonfly attempts to capture the essence of The Sixth Sense without the expected success. Its low rating on Rotten Tomatoes does not fully reflect the talent that overflows in his performance as a grieving doctor.
Despite being dragged down by a script that gets lost in its own sci-fi universe, Costner’s compassion shines through at key moments. However, the film leans too heavily into building its supernatural mythology, neglecting the emotional force that could have elevated it.
5
Mr. Brooks (2007)
Directed by Bruce A. Evans
Mr. Brooks is a disturbing film that combines elements of psychological thriller and crime drama with a concept of personal duality. While the film deserves to be considered an undiscovered gem, it struggles with tonal inconsistencies and unengaging character development, which risks getting lost in clichés.
Even so, the subplots offer a level of intrigue that sustains interest, even though some parallel stories do not contribute to the central plot. The direction often diverts the narrative towards the superficial, preventing its potential from fully shining.
4
The Upside of Anger (2005)
Directed by Mike Binder
In this comedy-drama, Joan Allen gives an exceptional performance, portraying a mother creaking under the weight of bitterness and disillusionment. Her emotional complexity sets a dramatic backdrop that allows The Upside of Anger to flourish, despite some subplots that lack narrative value.
The chemistry between Costner and Allen is memorable, becoming an emotional anchor in a film that portrays the rediscovery of love and reconciliation. The evolution of each character toward a greater emotional connection provides a nice hopeful twist amid the family tumult.
3
The Guardian (2008)
Directed by Andrew Davis
A precursor to Top Gun: Maverick , The Guardian tells the story of a Coast Guard veteran who trains new recruits, including a young man who represents a challenge and potential danger to his fellow officers. Costner embodies a character on the threshold of retirement, bringing a mix of wisdom and leadership.
The film shines in its formative montage, creating a dynamic context that culminates in moments of great intensity. Costner’s strength shines through in the lessons he provides to his students, and his natural charisma brings the role to life, thus strengthening the narrative focused on personal growth and teamwork.
2
Thirteen Days (2000)
Directed by Roger Donaldson
Based on the Cuban Missile Crisis, Thirteen Days is hailed as an outstanding political thriller that manages to maintain tension through a docu-drama-style approach. Despite criticisms about its historical accuracy, the film manages to create an atmosphere of urgency and danger as the military maneuvers unfold.
Costner plays an advisor to John F. Kennedy, bringing a level of credibility to the narrative. Although his role in the actual crisis was not decisive, his portrayal gives the viewer an emotional connection to an event that nearly brought the world to nuclear annihilation, making this an unforgettable cinematic experience.
1
Open Range (2003)
Directed by Kevin Costner
Fifteen years before Yellowstone made its entrance into television, Costner took the reins of his own production, directing and starring in Open Range , widely considered his best film of the 2000s. His mastery of direction and the authenticity of his performance highlight his versatility within the Western genre, showing a character in deep internal struggle as he navigates old temptations.
Costner challenges traditional Western conventions, enriching the characters and the world they inhabit. Moments that don’t focus exclusively on tension, such as the protagonist saving a dog, allow us to glimpse his love of storytelling beyond the action, highlighting the humanity hidden behind the genre.
Leave a Reply