Proof That Ash Was Denied a Championship Nearly a Decade Before His Historic Victory

In 2019, Pokémon‘s iconic character, Ash Ketchum, achieved a historic milestone by winning a Pokémon League tournament within the Alola region. This victory was especially significant given that he had come close to claiming the title several times in the past. However, a particular match from a decade earlier continues to irritate fans, as it prevented Ash from winning the coveted title of League Champion much sooner.

Throughout the Sun & Moon series, Ash seemed to adopt a more laid-back approach to his journey, leading many to believe that his team lacked the competitive edge needed for success, even though it included some formidable Pokémon. For ardent fans of the franchise, winning isn’t simply a matter of having the strongest Pokémon; it involves forming deep connections with them, exemplified by Ash’s bond with Pikachu. Ironically, the very opponent who leveraged powerful Legendary Pokémon, Tobias, has become one of the most reviled characters in the series’ history.

Tobias Represents Everything Wrong With Pokémon

Tobias’s Victory Destroys the Series’ Themes

Pokemon anime screenshot of Tobias and his Darkrai facing off against Ash in the Sinnoh finals.

During the Pokémon Diamond and Pearl saga, Ash underwent significant character development as both a trainer and an individual. He built on the experience gained from three prior tournaments and enjoyed several compelling story arcs, including his intense rivalry with Paul and his mentorship of Chimchar. By the time of the Sinnoh League, Ash had matured enough to showcase a kinder, more respectful approach to Pokémon training, which contrasted sharply with Paul’s harsh methods.

The tournament represented a culmination of Ash’s growth, providing the perfect opportunity for him to shine. However, the sudden introduction of a mysterious and formidable opponent, Tobias, quickly shifted the narrative. With minimal characterization and an imposing demeanor, Tobias seemed more like a plot device than a fleshed-out character. While he had the standard six Pokémon for competition, it was soon revealed that he possessed the incredibly powerful Mythical Pokémon Darkrai, which effectively ensured his dominance over all adversaries.

From a storytelling perspective, Tobias’s role appears to be an artificial barrier engineered to prevent Ash from clinching victory. His lack of development and emotional connection to his Pokémon diminished the impact of his win. This outcome contradicted the season’s overarching themes centered on the importance of respect and companionship in building effective trainer-pokemon relationships.

Ash’s Team Was At Its Best, And Should’ve Been Rewarded With Victory

Ash Had a Fantastic Team Composition in Sinnoh

Unlike previous tournaments where Ash exclusively featured Pokémon caught within that respective region, the Lily of the Valley Conference introduced old favorites into his lineup. Pokémon like Sceptile and Heracross returned, allowing Ash to form a uniquely strategic team composition. This shift brought fans hope that he could finally seize the championship after so many near misses—until the unwelcome appearance of Tobias.

Notably, Ash had the flexibility to adjust his strategy between matches, using his Sinnoh team to battle Paul before reverting to his classic Pokémon for subsequent rounds. Had he faced any other competitor—a trainer like Cynthia, for example—he would likely have had a strong chance of advancing to the finals. Sceptile, in particular, proved powerful enough to defeat Tobias’s Darkrai, showcasing Ash’s potential in the tournament.

Circumstances are even more egregious when considering competitive Pokémon tournament standards, which often prohibit the use of Mythical Pokémon like Darkrai due to their rarity. Such restrictions are typically adopted to ensure fairness, and one might reasonably assume they were also in effect within the anime’s narrative. Curiously, the only other trainer who has wielded a Mythical Pokémon in an anime tournament is Ash himself with Melmetal.

Ash Deserved to Win for Thematic Reasons, Too

The Diamond and Pearl Season Felt Like It Was Leading to Ash’s Success

The frustration surrounding Tobias’s match against Ash has lingered among fans for years due to its blatant unfairness. The Diamond and Pearl series was meticulously crafted to showcase Ash’s evolution as a trainer, making it the ideal setting for him to finally claim victory. Strongly embodying the show’s core values, Ash’s journey demonstrated the significance of nurturing relationships with Pokémon and overcoming personal challenges. Triumphant over Paul in their League encounter marked a significant highlight in the series, contrasting sharply with the disappointment of the subsequent battle against Tobias.

Tobias’s existence as a character feels unjustified, and Ash’s encounter with Paul should have served as the climactic battle, ultimately rewarding him with both the trophy and a meaningful moral victory. Such an outcome would have not only solidified Ash’s legacy but also paved the way for a revitalized narrative coinciding with the fifth-generation reboot within the games. Sadly, due to the reluctance of the Pokémon anime to advance Ash’s journey or allow him to experience true success, audiences witnessed one of his most disheartening losses, overshadowing a significantly celebrated chapter in the series’ history.

Source&Images