“Outdated and Over Saturated”: Woman of the Hour Movie Receives Criticism Online

Anna Kendrick makes her directorial debut with Woman of the Hour, which delves into the harrowing true story of Rodney Alcala, a notorious serial killer also known as the Dating Game Killer. The film premiered on Netflix on October 18, 2024, following its unveiling at the Toronto International Film Festival on September 8, 2024.

Despite the excitement leading up to Kendrick’s inaugural project as a director, the film has faced significant criticism on social media. Viewers have labeled the concept as “uninspired and overdone,” suggesting that the movie does not contribute anything fresh or thought-provoking to the true crime realm.

“Uninspired & overdone concept. This might have fared better in 1997,” noted one user on Reddit.

Critics argue that although the chaos surrounding Alcala’s participation in The Dating Game in 1978 is chilling, Anna Kendrick has shifted focus towards her character. Feedback from Reddit users highlights these concerns:

“This serial killer was active for over a decade. This film deserves at least a three-part mini-series to properly address the weight of his crimes. Reviewers seem hesitant to critique Kendrick’s first time directing, but those critiques can coexist,” said another Reddit user.

“Wow, this could’ve been handled much better. The premise is strong, yet the game show aspect felt sidelined, despite being marketed as central to the plot. I’m puzzled why the narrative centers around Kendrick when her struggles for acting roles in LA seem irrelevant,” observed another commenter.

“Kendrick transformed a story about a decades-long serial killer into something focused on her own character in a game show, with only a few brief mentions of other victims. The most substantial information was presented in a postscript. Disappointed. Also, a similar movie titled Dating Game Killer has already been made,” a Reddit user criticized.

Other users echoed the sentiment regarding the repetitive nature of Woman of the Hour.

“Ah yes, the overdone narrative of real-life serial killer Rodney Alcala targeting women through a game show. It seems like we get a film about this specific individual every couple of weeks,” commented one user.

“Yeah, I’ve definitely encountered way too many films recently about serial killers appearing on dating shows. Oh, for the nostalgic days of 1997,” remarked another Reddit commenter.

Overview of Woman of the Hour

Woman of the Hour is a 2024 film that intertwines true crime elements with thrilling drama, directed by Anna Kendrick. The movie is based on the factual occurrences involving serial killer Rodney Alcala, who infamously appeared on the television series The Dating Game while actively committing murders.

The narrative follows Cheryl Bradshaw, portrayed by Kendrick, an unsuspecting contestant who selects Alcala as her date on the show. The film contrasts Alcala’s public persona as a charismatic bachelor with the horrific reality of his criminal activities.

By examining the events that unfolded during and after the game show, Woman of the Hour explores the dark and often overlooked intersection of media exposure and criminal behavior. It underscores the shocking truth that Alcala’s history of violence was unknown to the producers at the time, despite his television appearance coinciding with a series of heinous acts.

Those curious about this chilling tale can watch Woman of the Hour now available on Netflix.

Source