Overview
- Character deaths play a vital role in enhancing plot dynamics and character arcs.
- Figures like Edward Newgate serve critical narrative functions through their demise within the story.
- Ignoring character deaths can dilute the emotional richness and continuity of the narrative.
Spoiler Alert: This article discusses major plot points in One Piece.
In a recent development in One Piece, the character Jaguar D. Saul—an ally of Nico Robin who was presumed dead—was revealed to be alive. His survival sparked debate among fans, as some argue it undermines the emotional gravity of Robin’s backstory, while others feel it adds layers to her tragic narrative. This article will explore additional One Piece characters who are believed to be deceased and whose deaths should remain intact for narrative integrity.
5. Vinsmoke Sora
Sanji’s Mother
- Debut: Episode 804
The Vinsmoke family leads the Germa 66, a military group that employs fascist imagery to conquer territories like North Blue. At the helm is Judge Vinsmoke, whose ambition was to transform his children into heartless superhuman weapons. In contrast, his wife Sora was against this cruel ethos.
Judge forced Sora to undergo a prenatal procedure to enhance their children’s physical abilities. Sora attempted to counteract this with a medication that ultimately harmed her third son, Sanji, who faced relentless bullying from his siblings. Tragically, Sora’s health deteriorated due to the drug, leading to her death when Sanji was just a child.
Her passing became a tool for Judge to further mold their other children into ruthless weapons, intensifying the bullying Sanji endured. Despite this, Sora instilled in him a love for cooking, which became his solace and a way to honor her memory. Retconning her death would significantly undermine Sanji’s character development and the overarching theme of inherited will throughout the series.
4. Donquixote Mjosgard
The One Good World Noble
- Debut: Episode 545
Mjosgard, part of the infamous Donquixote family, enjoyed the privileges of being a World Noble until significant personal changes led him to reevaluate his views. His transformation began after he lost his Fish-Man slaves due to Jimbei’s intervention, prompting him to confront the consequences of his upbringing.
Finding himself under the protection of Queen Otohime of Fish-Man Island after a violent encounter with former slaves, Mjosgard gradually evolved, renouncing the notion of nobility and slavery. Unfortunately, his newfound morality resulted in isolation from the other World Nobles.
Mjosgard’s eventual execution for defending Shirahoshi showcased the vulnerability of even the most privileged individuals against the collective will of their peers. Undoing his demise would not only diminish its impact but also weaken the narrative’s message about the accountability of the World Nobles.
3. Ashura Doji
Loyal in the End
- Debut: Episode 910
Before the climactic battles of Wano, Ashura Doji was a strong ally and retainer of Kozuki Oden, embodying the spirit of loyalty despite previous revolts against authority. Although initially disheartened by Oden’s death and the fall of comrades, Ashura found purpose again through their cause, fanning the flames of rebellion.
Tragically, Ashura’s self-sacrifice during a pivotal moment reflected his redemptive arc, proving that he was willing to put his life on the line for the ideals Oden represented. Reviving Ashura would diminish this profound character evolution, which serves as a testament to loyalty and sacrifice.
2. Edward Newgate
Roger’s Rival
- Debut: Episode 151
As a legendary figure in the world of piracy and a rival to Gol D. Roger, Edward Newgate, known as Whitebeard, epitomized the concept of a protector rather than a conqueror. He governed his crew more like a father than a captain, showing extraordinary dedication to their welfare and safety.
Whitebeard’s tragic end during his battle against Blackbeard marked a significant point in the One Piece universe, setting the stage for Blackbeard’s rise to power. Resurrecting Whitebeard would disrupt the established balance of power and negate the consequences of his heroic sacrifice, which fundamentally shaped the pirate world.
1.Jaygarcia Saturn
A Withered Elder
- Debut: Episode 151
Jaygarcia Saturn emerged as a notable member of the Five Elders, whose appearances signify the World Government’s authoritative presence. Serving under the enigmatic figure of Imu, Saturn was the designated Warrior God of Science and Defense, enhancing the mystery surrounding the government structures.
His eventual demise, a result of failing to maintain control over a critical situation, underlines the ruthlessness of Imu’s authority. This moment amplifies the theme of disposability among the higher echelons of power within the story. Restoring Saturn would undermine the narrative’s focus on the cost of failure in the face of overwhelming power and authority.
Leave a Reply