Outbyte PC Repair

One Piece Analysis: The Missteps of Eiichiro Oda in Portraying Big Mom

One Piece Analysis: The Missteps of Eiichiro Oda in Portraying Big Mom

Overview of Big Mom’s Role in One Piece

  • Eiichiro Oda has crafted a richly detailed universe in which even minor elements hold significant importance.
  • Big Mom, a formidable antagonist in One Piece, possesses extraordinary abilities, including soul manipulation and the creation of Homies.
  • Despite her formidable nature, Big Mom’s character was poorly utilized, leading to an unsatisfying defeat in the narrative.

Eiichiro Oda, the mastermind behind One Piece, has achieved unparalleled success with over 500 million copies sold, far surpassing iconic series like Naruto. This enormous gap illustrates the storytelling prowess that defines One Piece, where every detail matters, and intricacies within characters contribute to the overarching narrative.

Oda’s skill set in world-building has resulted in a vast array of complex characters, each meticulously crafted. However, his handling of certain narratives has drawn criticism over the years, notably exemplified in the character of Charlotte Linlin, commonly known as Big Mom. Although her initial introduction was impressive, subsequent character development has left much to be desired.

Big Mom: A Behemoth of Power

big-mom-young
  • Consumed the Question Question no Devil Fruit
  • Mastered all forms of Haki

Big Mom was first introduced during the Whole Cake Island arc, emerging as a notorious antagonist driven by ruthlessness. Her chilling disposition was starkly illustrated by her willingness to murder her son to achieve her goals. In terms of raw power, few characters in the One Piece universe could rival her strength. Possessing the Soru Soru no Mi—a Paramecia-type Devil Fruit—Big Mom had the chilling ability to manipulate souls, which allowed her to eradicate opponents by stealing their souls or even enhancing her own power through fusion.

Everyone might die. –Big Mom

Additionally, Big Mom could create sentient beings known as Homies by embedding soul fragments into ordinary objects. She commanded a formidable roster of Homies—Hera, Prometheus, Zeus, and Napoleon—each capable of wreaking havoc independently. Despite her overwhelming advantages, her abilities did have limitations: she could not extract souls from those who did not succumb to her fear.

Nevertheless, Big Mom had an arsenal of other skills at her disposal. As one of the Four Emperors of the Sea, she wielded all three varieties of Haki, demonstrating exceptional mastery, which made her a virtually insurmountable opponent. In terms of sheer physical power, she stood on equal footing with Kaido, renowned as the strongest creature in the world.

Oda’s Disappointment with Big Mom

None
None
None
None

Given Big Mom’s impressive character design and potential, one can only ponder how Oda could have maximized her impact. For example, she had the capacity to destroy everyone on Whole Cake Island, yet Oda handicapped her by introducing a condition that clouded her moral judgment. Her gradual weight loss was another factor that diminished her strength, ultimately rendering her powerless as she passively observed her reputation erode at the hands of the Straw Hat Pirates.

Big Mom’s Return in the Wano Country Arc

Big Mom

Big Mom faced off against Eustass Kid and Trafalgar Law, formidable adversaries but not on her level. Once again, Oda opted to scale back her abilities, preventing her from utilizing her Conqueror’s Haki, which allowed the two younger pirates to defeat her. In stark contrast, Kaido maintained his reputation as a terrifying force within the arc.

The manner of Big Mom’s defeat was disheartening and aligned solely with plot requirements; it appeared necessary to eliminate her in a way that would allow the two Supernovas to shine. Fans can only hope that Oda avoids similar pitfalls with other characters as the narrative progresses.

For those interested, One Piece is currently available for streaming on Crunchyroll.

Source & Images

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *