Netflix’s Harlan Coben Show Sparks Complaints Similar to Fool Me Once

WARNING: SPOILERS AHEAD for Missing You.

Netflix has once again partnered with renowned author Harlan Coben to deliver Missing You, which premiered on January 1, 2025. The series has quickly gained traction, emerging as one of the platform’s most popular new titles of the year. Featuring a talented cast that includes Rosalind Eleazar, Ashley Walters, Mary Malone, Jessica Plummer, Richard Armitage, and Charlie Hamblett, Missing You showcases the directorial skills of Nimer Rashed and Isher Sahota.

This show marks the latest addition to Netflix’s Harlan Coben Collection, a lineup that also comprises titles like The Stranger, Stay Close, Safe, Hold Tight, The Innocent, Gone For Good, and the previously released Fool Me Once in 2024. While it has captivated a portion of the audience, Missing You has received mixed critical reviews, reflected in its mediocre ratings of 52% on Rotten Tomatoes and a concerning 27% from viewers. Critics largely attribute the low audience score to the series’ numerous plot holes and perplexing narratives.

Like Fool Me Once, Missing You Features Many Plot Holes and Confounding Moments

A Frustrating Viewing Experience

Rosalind Eleazar as Detective Inspector Kat Donovan

Much like its predecessor, Fool Me Once, Missing You has drawn criticism for its convoluted storylines and irregular timelines. Viewers often find themselves grappling with moments that defy logic, leading to a conclusion that many feel is unreasonable. Although the series delivers enjoyable segments, it ultimately struggles with coherence.

Critics have pointed out the series’ failure to resolve various storylines and its somewhat predictable conclusion. Some argue that the overabundance of plot twists detracts from the overall narrative coherence, and parallels to the criticism leveled at Fool Me Once are noticeable. In both cases, the strong performances are overshadowed by the challenges posed by the narrative structure.

Do the Plot Holes in Missing You and Fool Me Once Truly Matter?

Significance of Plot Holes Depends on Viewing Intent

Rosalind Eleazar looking shocked in Missing You

Ultimately, both Missing You and Fool Me Once serve as entertaining thrillers, particularly for viewers who prioritize a light viewing experience over a compelling storyline. For those seeking depth and a captivating narrative, exploring other options may provide a more satisfying experience. There is a distinctly whimsical tone present in both series, which has elicited frustration from certain viewers and critics alike. However, if the primary goal is easy-to-watch entertainment, both titles still offer an enjoyable escape on Netflix despite their narrative shortcomings.

Source & Images