Mufasa: The Lion King Reveals Scar’s Misunderstood Motivations Through a Flawed Comparison

Warning: SPOILERS ahead for Mufasa: The Lion King!

The film Mufasa: The Lion King unfolds a relatively clear origin narrative surrounding Scar’s deep-seated animosity toward his brother, Mufasa. However, certain elements may lead viewers to misunderstand the complexity of Scar’s character. While Scar, born Taka, initially appears as a resentful and isolated figure vying for kingship over the Pride Lands, the film introduces additional layers to his motivations that merit exploration.

In tracing Mufasa’s backstory, we learn that young Taka was raised with the expectation of ascending to the throne. The film suggests that Taka’s deep-seated bitterness springs from feelings of betrayal he perceives from Mufasa. This notion is cleverly foreshadowed by Rafiki, who remarks to Kiara, Mufasa’s daughter, that hatred generally arises from a lack of love. While Rafiki’s observation holds some truth, reducing Taka’s emotional turmoil to mere rejection obscures the authentic depth of his character.

Examining Scar’s Origin Story and Its Misleading Parallels

The Outsiders in Mufasa: A Deeper Lack of Belonging

Rafiki sheds light on the Outsiders, highlighting that characters like Kiros harbor resentment because they were ostracized from their prides due to their unique white fur. This casts a parallel to Taka, who feels unloved by his family. Yet, it is essential to note that Mufasa never actively betrays Taka. When Sarabi, Taka’s mother, proclaims Mufasa the rightful king, it’s a blow to Taka’s sense of purpose, asserting that his birthright was merely to support Mufasa. Despite this, throughout their story, Mufasa regularly acknowledges Taka’s royal lineage.

The film implies that Scar’s transformation into a villain is largely motivated by jealousy surrounding Mufasa’s romance with Sarabi. However, this situation does not mirror the Outsiders’ experience of familial love being forcibly retracted. Mufasa’s loving feelings for Sarabi are involuntary, and his attempts to reign them in for Taka’s sake clearly demonstrate his loyalty. The tragedy lies not in Taka suffering outright betrayal, but rather in his inability to recognize the difference between loyalty and boiling resentment, further complicating Scar’s character.

Understanding Rafiki’s Perspective on Scar’s Origin

Taka’s Downfall: The Absence of a Father’s Love

When discussing the deprivation of love in Taka’s life, it becomes apparent that the principal offender is not Mufasa, but rather their father, Obasi. Taka’s life is largely characterized by love from his mother, Eshe, and his brother, Mufasa. Unfortunately, Obasi’s attempts to isolate Mufasa not only diminish Taka’s opportunities to bond with him but also instigate feelings of jealousy as he years for the affection Mufasa receives from their mother.

Obasi further deepens the rift by instilling distrust in Taka, predicting Mufasa would eventually betray him. This betrayal manifests in Taka’s villainous anthem, “Brother Betrayed, ” where he painfully recants his earlier feelings of brotherhood, doubting their familial ties altogether.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LnqikN644lM

I Always Wanted A Brother (From "Mufasa: The Lion King") (Official Video) (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LnqikN644lM)

Additionally, Obasi complicates Taka’s ability to cultivate self-love, shaping him into a character devoid of a moral compass. After Taka forsakes his brothers to combat the Outsiders on his own, he is led to deceive to maintain appearances. This ultimately reinforces Taka’s fears, emphasizing that he fears Mufasa’s potential as a superior ruler, driving him to embrace negative traits early on.

The Advantages of a Multifaceted Origin Story in Mufasa: The Lion King

Mufasa’s Nobility: No Need for Betrayal

Scar and the hyenas in The Lion King 2019

Interpreting Rafiki’s lesson at face value could have drawn a direct comparison between Taka, Scar, and classic Disney villains, but such a reading would diminish Mufasa’s portrayal as a virtuous leader. At its core, the narrative aims to illustrate how Mufasa evolves into the wise, noble figure recognized in The Lion King. For Mufasa’s integrity to be compromised by outright betrayal towards Taka would contradict the character’s evolution and the integral bond they share, especially since Taka saves Mufasa multiple times throughout the film.

Even in the wake of Taka’s misguided attempts at fratricide, he maintains some ethical standing, never directly seeking to end Mufasa’s life, demonstrating his intrinsic value as a brother. Had his father not imposed such segregation and denial of love, Taka might have grown into a character closer in virtue to Mufasa. His attempt at redemption, by stepping in to save Mufasa from Kiros, poignantly illustrates the tragic fallout of their relationship.

While Mufasa: The Lion King spares Taka from outright banishment akin to Kiros, his fate resonates as deeply tragic. Following Taka’s betrayal, Mufasa chooses to allow him to remain within the pride, yet he never refers to him by name again. This resonates with Rafiki’s earlier premise, linking to Scar’s motivations in The Lion King. Ultimately, Scar is left to govern a pack of hyenas—a bitter ruler robbed of both his name and his royal heritage, a reality shaped by Obasi’s legacy. For Scar, the loss symbolizes an irreversible void where his identity once thrived.

Source & Images