Missable Content in Chapter 4 of Red Dead Redemption 2

As the Van der Linde gang transitions to a new camp at Red Dead Redemption 2, they encounter various opportunities amid the advancing civilization represented by Saint Denis. This chapter, particularly with Shady Belle as their new shelter, is filled with potential missable content during Chapter 4, crucial for players aiming for 100% completion.

Chapter 4 presents an extensive array of missable elements. To successfully engage in all additional missions, cooperative activities with companions, and to collect essential items, players should familiarize themselves with the details before diving into gameplay.

11 Rob a Bank with Charles Smith

Robbery of the Rhodes Bank with Charles and Uncle

Exclusive to Special and Ultimate Edition Owners

This mission is exclusive to owners of the Special and Ultimate Editions of Red Dead Redemption 2. However, players without these editions need not worry too much, as the mission is less thrilling than anticipated. Charles, situated at Shady Belle, seeks Arthur’s assistance to execute a plan involving a schematics for robbing the Rhodes Bank.

The heist involves Charles and Uncle reluctantly accompanying Arthur to blow open a bank wall and seize its wealth. Though quick, this mission allows Arthur to pocket close to $150, making it a noteworthy missable mission.

10 Help a Brother Out

Assist in Rescuing Human Trafficking Victims with Brother Dorkins

Location: Near the Trapper in the Market of Saint Denis

Arthur can find Brother Dorkins near the bustling market of Saint Denis, where the monk solicits donations. While contributing isn’t mandatory, Brother Dorkins urges Arthur to investigate a local Fence, suspecting it may be involved in human trafficking.

Upon entering and inspecting a bookshelf, Arthur confirms Dorkins’ suspicions. This Stranger Mission serves as a moment for Arthur to showcase his compassion, providing him with high honor should he choose to donate without expecting anything in return.

9 Brothers and Sisters, One and All

Retrieve Sister Calderon’s Crucifix to Earn More Honor

Arthur speaks to Brother Dorkins and Sister Calderon

Location: Northeast entrance of Saint Denis

Following the assistance of Brother Dorkins, players unlock a new Stranger Mission involving Sister Calderon. She and Brother Dorkins aim to educate impoverished youth, but a child absconds with Sister Calderon’s cherished crucifix, a keepsake from her deceased mother.

This prompts a chase through Saint Denis as Arthur strives to recover the stolen item, all while evading law enforcement after encountering Edith Downes and addressing past grievances.

8 Money Lending and Other Sins 5

Recover Unpaid Debts from the Vulnerable

Algie Davison – Catfish Jacksons

Once again, Strauss has ensnared more desperate individuals into his web of debt. Arthur must confront Algie Davison, a drunken fisherman who owes money to the gang at Catfish Jackson.

This mission presents a moral dilemma, highlighting Arthur’s internal conflict as he faces the consequences of his actions against vulnerable families seeking a better life.

7 Fatherhood and Other Dreams 1 and 2

Assist Mary Linton in Saint Denis

Location: Saint Denis

Upon receiving a message from Mary Linton, Arthur feels obliged to respond despite their complicated relationship. Their bond is distant, yet Arthur finds himself drawn to assist Mary as she faces complications with her father.

The quest takes Arthur through Saint Denis, involving stealth, dialogue, and morally grey situations that reveal the remnants of their past romance.

6 Hunting with Pearson

Search for Crayfish and Gator Eggs Alongside Pearson

To enhance camp meals, Arthur joins Pearson on an expedition into the alligator-infested swamps bordering Shady Belle to collect crayfish. This pursuit not only showcases a unique side of gameplay but also deepens the relationship between the camp cook and Arthur.

Throughout their excursion, players learn more about Pearson’s naval history while gathering valuable alligator eggs, which hold a lucrative market appeal.

5 Coach Robbery with Lenny

Teach Lenny the Art of Coach Robbery

Lenny has devised a plan to rob a stagecoach in Scarlett Meadows, and Arthur feels compelled to guide him through this venture. They find themselves in a precarious situation, pinned down by soldiers protecting the vehicle.

This serves as both a learning curve for Lenny and a moment of camaraderie between the two, reflecting their growing friendship amidst the dangers they face.

4 Coach Robbery with Micah

Execute a Robbery in the Bayou with Micah and Bill

The Bayou Nwa poses its dangers with the lurking Night Folk, but it’s also ripe for an ambush on a stagecoach. Partnering with Micah and Bill, Arthur embarks on this robbery and stands to reap a reward of $50 following a successful job.

Players should prepare for an intense encounter when working with Micah, and Bill’s unpredictable nature adds to the overall chaos.

3 Cow Rustling with Uncle

Rustle Cows to Trade with Clay & Clive

Engaging in cattle rustling poses a serious risk of legal ramifications, yet Arthur and Uncle find the adventure entertaining as they head to Hill Haven Ranch. While the ranch owner is preoccupied with liquor, the duo manages to lead the cattle to Clemens Cove’s horse lot for a payout of approximately $60.

This mission is a lighthearted respite amidst the broader narrative, allowing for bonding time between Arthur and Uncle.

2 Camp Companion Item Requests for Chapter 4

Fulfill Companion Item Requests Before Progressing

Chapter 4 marks the pivotal moment for players to fulfill the Camp Companion Item Requests, making completion essential before advancing further. Below are the various missable companion requests:

Companion	Requested Item	Source	Reward
Bill	Hair Pomade	Any General Store	Repeater Ammo
Charles	Moonshine	Any Fence	Fire Arrows
Charles	Oleander Sage	Around the Lemoyne Swamps & Marshes	Poison Arrows
Dutch	Pipe	Vetter’s Echo, South of Little Creek River, West Elizabeth	Cowboy Rider Spurs
Hosea	The Case of the Shrew in the Fog	Hagen Orchards, North West of Saint Denis	Predator Bait
Lenny	Pocket Watch	Vetter’s Echo, South of Little Creek River	Dynamite
Pearson	Naval Compass	Braithwaite Manor Boathouse	Guarma Rooms
Sadie	Harmonica	Granger’s Hoggery, East of Flatneck Station, New Hanover	Gun Oil
Susan	2 Oregano	Between the A and D of Scarlett Meadows	Potent Miracle Tonic
Tilly	Necklace	Random loot from people and lockboxes	2 Medicine

1 Collectibles in Chapter 4

While Chapter 4 lacks numerous collectibles, three items are notable and can easily be overlooked in missions later on in the chapter. Here’s what players should keep an eye out for:

Collectible	How to Obtain
Letter to Bronte From the Mayor	Located inside the Mayor’s House in The Gilded Cage, prior to venturing outside.
List of Accounts	Found atop Angelo Bronte’s table during the mission Revenge is a Dish Best Eaten.
Telegram to Police Chief Lambert	Also located on Angelo Bronte’s table in Revenge is a Dish Best Eaten.

Source & Images