MCU’s Spider-Man Movies Have a Golden Opportunity to Incorporate Tobey Maguire’s Cut Villain Story from Spider-Man 4

The prospect of revisiting elements from Tobey Maguire’s originally planned fourth Spider-Man film is both intriguing and nostalgic—almost two decades after its cancellation, fans are still captivated by what could have been. The significance of the original trilogy, especially following Tobey Maguire’s much-anticipated return in Spider-Man: No Way Home, has reignited discussions about the fate of the long-abandoned project. While Marvel Studios is currently focused on crafting a new narrative for Tom Holland’s Spider-Man, speculation suggests that the storyline may delve into multiversal themes, potentially allowing for another cameo by Maguire as Peter Parker.

The Planned Story for Spider-Man 4 Included the Vultress

Sony’s Vision for Spider-Man 4

John Malkovich's Vulture and Willem Dafoe's Green Goblin face Tobey Maguire's Spidey in Sam Raimi's Spider-Man 4 — Image by Nicolas Ayala

Diving into the ambitious plans for Sony’s iteration of Spider-Man 4, director Sam Raimi envisioned an epic confrontation with the formidable Vulture, portrayed by actor John Malkovich. Unfortunately, the project’s potential was thwarted by studio interference during the production of Spider-Man 3, leading Raimi to opt out of directing a sequel that felt more like a product of corporate mandates than artistic vision.

Nonetheless, those involved with the film revealed captivating insights regarding its intended direction. Reports indicate that the story was set to progress dramatically following the Vulture’s demise, with the villain’s daughter assumed to inherit her father’s legacy. Sony had aspirations of casting Angelina Jolie in this role, which would have created a new villain known as Vultress—an original character inspired by the comic’s lore.

The MCU’s Setup for Spider-Man 4’s Villain Narrative

A Parallel Storyline in the MCU

This narrative becomes even more engaging in light of the groundwork already laid by the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU).In Spider-Man: Homecoming, we saw Peter Parker (Tom Holland) face off against the Vulture, whose daughter Liz emerged as one of the storyline’s key figures. The climactic twist revealed Liz as the daughter of Adrian Toomes, effectively linking her life experiences to Spider-Man’s heroic journey.

While the film concluded with Liz relocating to Oregon post-her father’s arrest, the MCU possesses ample opportunity to reintroduce her character as Vultress, echoing Raimi’s initial vision. If the MCU addresses the fallout from the Vulture’s arrest, Liz could return, harboring resentment towards Spider-Man, thus setting the stage for a compelling conflict that mirrors the essential themes of the canceled Spider-Man 4.

Hoping the MCU Adopts Spider-Man 4’s Narrative

Potential Benefits for the MCU

Split image of Tobey Maguire Spider-Man and Tom Holland Spider-Man — Image by David Miller

There are numerous reasons to be optimistic about the MCU potentially borrowing from the narrative threads of Tobey Maguire’s disenfranchised Spider-Man 4. Primarily, such a storyline would resonate better with the franchise’s street-level hero persona, addressing critiques regarding the character’s disconnect from his “friendly neighborhood”roots within the vast MCU. A return of Liz as a villain could pave the way for more intimate, emotionally-focused narratives that fans have longed for.

Furthermore, transforming Liz into a writing-forward antagonist offers immense storytelling potential, adding depth to her character arc that largely felt one-dimensional in Homecoming. While Laura Harrier portrayed Liz admirably, the character lacked compelling motivations, primarily serving as a love interest. Rebranding her as Vultress would allow for an integrated backstory, making her a formidable adversary that could effectively link back to the original plot intentions of Maguire’s Spider-Man 4.

Source & Images