Marvel Should Avoid Making Hugh Jackman Wolverine for Another 10 Years

Overview

Hugh Jackman may reprise his role as Wolverine in the MCU for the next decade.
Concerns about Jackman’s age and possible narrative redundancies are being voiced.
Many fans and experts argue for a fresh face to embody Wolverine as the X-Men enter the MCU.

Hugh Jackman’s portrayal of Wolverine has become iconic, with his performance as a member of the X-Men resonating with audiences since he first donned the role in 2000. His recent inclusion in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) as part of Deadpool’s franchise has rejuvenated interest in his character, showcasing his adaptability within this expanded universe.

Despite the nostalgic association, some argue it’s time for Jackman to move on. Speculation is rife about whether he will continue as Wolverine for additional years, with whispers suggesting he could reprise the role for up to a decade.

Could He Really Stay for Another Decade?

According to industry insider MyTimeToShineH, Jackman intends to continue as Wolverine for at least another ten years. Rumors suggest that the MCU may produce a trilogy featuring both Deadpool and Wolverine, especially given the remarkable success of their recent collaboration, which grossed over $1 billion in 2023. Additionally, plans for a potential Hulk vs. Wolverine film could introduce exciting new dynamics, positioning Jackman’s character in fresh scenarios.

Furthermore, Wolverine is set to appear in “Avengers: Doomsday”, marking his first appearance in an Avengers film, an anticipated development among audiences. Given Marvel’s extensive slate of future projects, there is undoubtedly room for Wolverine to play a significant role moving forward. However, questions linger about whether retaining Jackman for such an extended period is beneficial.

Is Jackman Too Old for Wolverine?

While Jackman has certainly maintained an impressive physique, the reality is that if he were to continue in the role for a decade, he would reach the age of 66. Such an adjustment could pose a challenge for him to retain the physicality needed to portray Wolverine convincingly alongside younger co-stars in the MCU. The pressure to look the part may lead to discrepancies that audiences could find jarring.

An older Wolverine could open up innovative narrative possibilities previously unexplored in the MCU. However, this approach runs the risk of evoking comparisons to “Logan”— often heralded as one of the greatest superhero films. Revisiting similar themes with an older Wolverine might not resonate well with fans who prefer fresh narratives over thematic repetition.

Time for a New Era: Recasting Wolverine

Recasting Wolverine is undoubtedly a complex discussion, primarily because of Jackman’s extraordinary legacy in the role. His continued physical capability to portray the character has led many to believe in the possibility of his extended involvement. While his inaugural MCU project has already been well-received, the conversation is shifting towards the necessity of introducing a new actor.

With the imminent introduction of X-Men into the MCU, this presents an opportune moment for Marvel to consider a younger Wolverine, allowing for the development of relationships and storylines that could prevail over a substantial timeline. The disparity in ages may create awkward dynamics among the cast of new characters if Jackman were to remain as the elder Wolverine, potentially sidelining the depth of inter-character relationships cherished by comic fans. Jackman’s remarkable contributions to the role are undeniable, but viewing it through a long-term lens may compel Marvel to take a chance with a new actor.

Source & Images