
Madison’s experience on “Married At First Sight”(MAFS) has raised eyebrows, particularly regarding her relationship with Allen. From the outset, she has been vocal about her critiquing his fashion choices and overall style. While Madison has been candid about her perspective on their marriage, Allen has embraced a “nice guy”persona that may not resonate with her. Recently, revelations about Allen’s modeling background have ignited speculation that he might have been a “producer plant”on the show. If true, this could signal that he was never meant to be Madison’s ideal match, raising concerns about the genuine nature of their connection.
Allen Just Isn’t Madison’s Type
Physical Discrepancies
Madison has openly expressed her feelings regarding Allen’s appearance. She has shown little appreciation for his unique dressing style and quirky demeanor; in fact, their shared interests are virtually nonexistent. Madison, a fitness enthusiast who frequently hits the gym, finds Allen’s lack of commitment to exercise unattractive. Their discomfort surfaced during a notable conversation where Madison revealed her lack of attraction to him.
During this candid exchange, Madison even suggested that Allen should make certain changes in order to bolster their relationship—a significant red flag. The significance of physical attraction in romantic partnerships cannot be overstated. During a recent episode featuring Dr. Pepper Schwartz, Allen posed a question that Madison found perplexing: did she find anything attractive about him? Her response suggested that their connection lacked depth (via mafslifetime).
“I don’t know that’s like a weird question to ask.”
Given that Madison typically gravitates toward “metrosexual men, ”it seems unlikely that she would develop feelings for Allen. Despite his good looks and affable nature, the chemistry she sought on MAFS appears to be non-existent. This mismatch raises questions about the expert’s matching criteria—were they negligent, or was it a calculated risk for drama?
While some couples find love despite initial physical misalignments, this was not the case for Madison and Allen. Had the MAFS season 18 experts invested more time exploring compatibility aspects, Madison might have connected with someone more aligned with her fitness-oriented lifestyle, such as gym enthusiast David Trimble.
Allen’s Modeling Background and Casting Speculation
The Nature of His Casting

Prior to his appearance on MAFS, Allen had a stint as a model for a local morning show, as highlighted by the @MAFSFan account. This revelation led to fans questioning the authenticity of his participation, with many suggesting that he was merely “recruited”for the show. Although Allen insisted he was helping a friend and not being scouted, his modeling past raises eyebrows about the integrity of his casting.
The dynamics of reality television often expose participants’ histories, comparable to what occurred with “Love Is Blind”star Tyler Francis, whose off-screen drama unfolded post-show. MAFS producers likely understood the potential to leverage Allen’s modeling background for enhanced narrative appeal. Despite his assurances about being genuine, this revelation casts him in a light suggesting possible prior connections within the entertainment sphere.
This line of reasoning evokes suspicion that Allen may have been selected as a strategic casting choice due to his charismatic personality. It’s clear that Allen has gained popularity among viewers, attributed to his easygoing nature, yet questions about his authenticity linger.
Allen’s Personality Dynamics
Madison’s Assertive Character

Madison’s assertive demeanor often comes across as harsh. She is unapologetically vocal, and has not hesitated to reveal to Allen his shortcomings in her eyes. While her bluntness ensures clarity, it casts Allen’s more laidback personality as inadequate in comparison. During a therapy session with Dr. Pepper, Madison struggled to identify any qualities she appreciated about Allen, leaving him visibly perplexed.
Allen appears empathetic but is not naively passive; he has made it clear that he will not allow Madison to dominate their dynamic. Their pairing, however, raises concerns about the effectiveness of the MAFS matching system, suggesting a lack of thorough vetting, or perhaps a calculated decision to create narrative tension.
The Future of Allen & Madison’s Relationship
Uncertain Prospects
Given the evident mismatch between Allen and Madison, the prospect of their relationship enduring is slim. MAFS has hinted at rumors of a cheating scandal that potentially involves both Madison and David, a fellow contestant. Their situations mirror each other significantly; David quickly discerned that his match, Michelle Trimble, lacked interest, which adds to the tension.
Both Madison and David are rumored to be linked to an unfolding drama involving couple swapping, making the likelihood of Madison and Allen’s separation appear increasingly probable. Ending the relationship may spare both individuals from prolonged discontent.
If one were to encapsulate the struggles in Allen and Madison’s relationship, Usher’s song “U Got It Bad”would be fitting—illustrating the pain of unreciprocated feelings that Allen seems to endure. Their pairing stands as one of the most incongruous in the history of MAFS, leaving viewers to ponder whether it was an oversight by the experts or a deliberate move to incite drama.
Married At First Sight airs Tuesdays at 8 p.m. EST on Lifetime.
Sources: mafslifetime/Instagram, @MAFSFan/Instagram
Leave a Reply