Married At First Sight Expert Faces Fan Criticism: Are They Losing Credibility?

Fans of Married at First Sight have recently directed criticism towards Pastor Cal Roberson, one of the show’s experts. Viewers argue that his performance as a therapist leaves much to be desired, raising questions about his effectiveness in guiding couples throughout the eight-week program. This reality series, which features three specialists tasked with pairing couples and supporting their journeys, has Dr. Pepper, the longest-serving expert since Season 1 at 79 years old. Pastor Cal, at 63, joined in Season 4, while Dr. Pia, the newest addition at 39, came aboard in Season 15.

The show’s experts have frequently been at the center of backlash, particularly due to the disappointing success rate of the couples they have matched. So far, out of 64 couples (not including Season 18), a mere 12 pairs have remained together. As Season 18 unfolds, with couples now celebrating their one-month anniversaries, Pastor Cal’s recent involvement has sparked considerable discontent among viewers.

What Motivates Pastor Cal to Be on MAFS?

Fame, Money, or Recognition?

Pastor Cal’s presence on Married at First Sight has drawn scrutiny, particularly regarding his motivations. Observers suggest that he may be more interested in fame and financial gain than in genuinely assisting the couples involved. A discussion on Reddit highlighted these concerns, with users expressing their disappointment in Pastor Cal’s commitment to his role.

“The only expert that I have a beef with is Cal. He is leveraging his collar for financial gain and that isn’t cool.”

Another viewer echoed similar sentiments, emphasizing the conflict between his role as a pastor and the show’s propensity to create divorces.

“Like I don’t understand how, as a pastor you could make money off of a show that’s just a machine that generates divorce.”

Is Pastor Cal Adequate for Modern Couples?

A Traditional Approach

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=re9-HOvFRqE

The Experts Select the Season 18 Couples | Married at First Sight Sight (Special) | Lifetime (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=re9-HOvFRqE)

Pastor Cal’s traditional views may not align well with the needs of today’s couples. His focus often emphasizes the woman’s role in uplifting her partner, which some fans argue is outdated. In contemporary relationships, a balanced perspective is essential, and viewers feel that Pastor Cal’s advice does not adequately reflect this need.

Does Pastor Cal Prioritize the Couples’ Welfare?

Concerns Over His Effectiveness

Pastor Cal Roberson from Married At First Sight — Custom Image by César García

Another significant concern raised by fans is Pastor Cal’s apparent lack of concern for the couples’ overall well-being. His tendency to overlook troubling behavior and fail to provide strong guidance has led to negative outcomes for many participants. A Reddit discussion highlighted this issue further, with users criticizing his commitment and approach.

“Their vested interest is to their client who is production not the couples. They care zero about these couples. That is fine for a sociologist, but for a Pastor to sell out like that is disgusting.”

Overall, disapproval of Pastor Cal’s methodology is mounting among Married at First Sight audiences. His conventional ideas, coupled with inadequate handling of critical situations, have led to widespread disappointment. Unless he significantly adapts his approach or is replaced, the backlash is likely to persist.

Married At First Sight airs Tuesdays at 8 p.m. EST on Lifetime.

Sources: u/No-Fuel-8886/Reddit, Lifetime/YouTube, u/Chris9835/Reddit

Source & Images