Magic: The Gathering’s Film and TV Universe Aligns Perfectly With Netflix’s Vision for a Fantasy Franchise 5 Years Earlier

After years of exploration into creating a shared fantasy universe, Magic: The Gathering emerges as Netflix’s next substantial project. As one of the paramount titles in tabletop gaming, it boasts an impressive collection of over 27, 000 unique cards, establishing it as one of the most intricate strategy games available today. With a rich history of development, Magic: The Gathering is brimming with captivating lore and a diverse cast of vibrant characters, making it an ideal candidate for adaptation into a streaming format. In February 2025, reports surfaced indicating that Netflix is gearing up to launch a shared universe based on MTG, commencing with an initial film.

The 2020s have witnessed a surge in fantasy television series, with numerous streaming platforms vying to replicate the success of Game of Thrones. Despite the cultural impact of HBO’s flagship show, no other series has yet matched its broad appeal. Prime Video has introduced titles such as The Wheel of Time and The Rings of Power, both of which have met with mixed reviews. HBO’s own House of the Dragon started strong but lost momentum after a contentious second season. Meanwhile, Netflix’s The Witcher is set to return for its fourth season, but it has faced numerous challenges. Fans are hopeful that MTG will finally deliver the quality that fantasy enthusiasts truly deserve.

Challenges with Netflix’s Attempt to Create a Shared Universe Through The Witcher

The Mixed Reception of The Witcher Franchise

Magic: The Gathering poster featuring characters from the card game.

The Witcher series is adapted from a cherished series of fantasy novels and a massively popular video game franchise, with The Witcher 3 often heralded as one of the greatest games of all time. Given this esteemed backdrop, Netflix’s adaptation has not fully met audience expectations. As the first major fantasy series to follow after Game of Thrones, it generated considerable hype, particularly with movie star Henry Cavill cast in the lead role of Geralt of Rivia.

However, the reception of The Witcher: Blood Origin was overwhelmingly negative, receiving harsh criticism from both fans and reviewers alike. Despite the main series maintaining strong viewership, each subsequent season has shown a decline in quality. Now, with Liam Hemsworth stepping in for Henry Cavill, the series faces another significant challenge. Netflix has attempted to expand The Witcher with spinoff shows and animated features, but the ambitious shared universe concept has faltered. While the animated offerings garnered some critical praise, they lacked the broader resonance Netflix desperately requires to attract a substantial audience.

Magic: The Gathering’s Movie and TV Universe: A New Hope for Netflix

MTG: The Latest Venture in Netflix’s Fantasy Endeavors

Despite the challenges it has encountered, Netflix remains committed to The Witcher, with the upcoming fourth season in 2025 presenting a critical juncture to regain its footing. However, the platform is actively searching for alternatives that could serve as flagship fantasy properties. For over a year, Netflix has been developing a film series based on The Chronicles of Narnia, and now, Magic: The Gathering represents their latest venture into the fantasy realm. This initiative marks the first major endeavor since The Witcher to create a comprehensive fantasy universe.

While The Chronicles of Narnia offers a straightforward narrative, attempts to further expand titles like Shadow and Bone have not generated sufficient appeal. Netflix’s bold strategy for Magic: The Gathering involves potentially laying the groundwork for multiple projects even before the first one premieres—a move that could fulfill the ambitions they sought with The Witcher. Although The Witcher offers rich material for adaptation, the source material is limited in scope for crafting a variety of interconnected stories across different eras.

Advantages of Magic: The Gathering for a Shared Universe

MTG: A Bountiful Source of Stories and Characters

Three Planeswalkers from Magic: The Gathering.

Thanks to its multiverse concept, the storytelling possibilities for Netflix with Magic: The Gathering are virtually limitless. In addition to the well-known cards, there exists an extensive array of books, graphic novels, and other media from which to draw stories. With decades of established material, Netflix is well-equipped to deliver captivating narratives without the need to build from scratch. While Magic: The Gathering may not be widely recognized for its storytelling prowess, it is a treasure trove of content. All that remains is for Netflix to remain true to its core essence.

Source&Images