Why has Luca Guadagnino, the acclaimed director behind two of 2024’s standout films, been completely overlooked by the Academy Awards? His works, Challengers and Queer, have captivated audiences, yet inexplicably, they received no nominations. This raises a crucial question: Are the Oscars voters failing to engage with Guadagnino’s cinematic creations?
It’s concerning to note that some Academy members have openly admitted to not finishing Guadagnino’s work, specifically mentioning they found The Brutalist a “dull” watch due to its length. This makes one wonder if such biases lead to significant outcomes at award season. Adding to this perplexity is the absence of any recognition for the striking score by Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross for Challengers, especially given their recent triumph at the Golden Globes and nominations across other prestigious awards.
Everyone involved in the film industry understands that awards season is often influenced by intricate politics—networking, promotional packages, and other forms of strategic visibility play a pivotal role. However, as a devoted film enthusiast, I remain committed to championing the narratives and directors that resonate with me. That explains why films like Challengers and my personal favorite, Hit Man, continue to dominate discussions among cinephiles.
Throughout the year, Guadagnino’s name has been frequently mentioned due to the impact of his films, making his total exclusion from nominations baffling. Was there a divide between votes for Queer and Challengers? This unexplainable snubbing truly demands scrutiny.
As a fan of renowned directors like Christopher Nolan, Greta Gerwig, and David Fincher, witnessing the exclusion of their work is not a new experience for me. Now, I find myself grappling with the same disappointment regarding Guadagnino—an artist whose vision deserves recognition.
The Disregard for Talented Directors
Awards season operates much like a competitive arena. Some deserving directors do achieve recognition, as seen with Brady Corbet for The Brutalist and Coralie Fargeat for The Substance. However, I must admit, my greatest frustration regarding the directorial nominations revolves around Jacques Audiard for Emilia Pérez—an underwhelming musical in my opinion.
What’s particularly striking about this awards cycle is not only the omission of Guadagnino but also the snubbing of notable actors and actresses, such as Zendaya and Daniel Craig, who have received acclaim elsewhere. Additionally, the lack of acknowledgment for cinematography and scoring aspects of his films is indeed baffling.
Ultimately, the insistence on ignoring Guadagnino’s brilliance and the excellence of Challengers and Queer leads me to a disheartening conclusion: the voters seem reluctant to recognize the exceptional quality that these films contribute to contemporary cinema. What other explanation could there be for such blatant oversight?
Leave a Reply