Linux Alternatives: This Operating System Outperforms Windows as a Replacement

While many proponents tout Linux as the ideal successor to Windows, the reality often involves software complications and constant adjustments. For many users, including myself, the preferred alternative is an operating system that simply works: macOS. Though it wasn’t the switch I initially intended to make, it has proven to be the most effective choice for my computing needs.

It’s important to note that transitioning to Apple devices might not be feasible for everyone, especially those on a budget since macOS devices tend to be more expensive than their Windows counterparts. For individuals unable to splurge on a Windows 11 setup, Linux might appear to be the more sensible option. Yet, numerous users are moving away from Windows, even when their existing PCs are capable of running it. This shift can be attributed to Microsoft’s trajectory: an increasing focus on data collection, stagnant features, and cumbersome updates, all evident in the disappointing Settings application.

4 Superior App Support on macOS

Before diving into features, it’s crucial to determine whether the applications you rely on will function on your operating system. This is where Linux often falls short, as essential workflows can experience significant disruptions due to app compatibility issues.

Consider this: mainstream applications like Microsoft Office and Adobe’s Creative Suite are absent on Linux. Although there are alternatives, such as LibreOffice and DaVinci Resolve, they do not fully meet the needs of long-time users accustomed to specific software. For those of us who have invested years into mastering certain applications, needing to relearn alternatives can be incredibly frustrating.

Asus ROG Ally running SteamOS — Image by Raghav

In reality, most professional-grade applications are readily available on both macOS and Windows. With my commitment to moving away from the latter, choosing a Mac became the most logical solution. Utilizing macOS alleviates concerns regarding application compatibility, providing assurance that the tools I need are supported.

However, it’s worth acknowledging that Linux has made strides in the gaming realm, often outperforming Windows on platforms like SteamOS, as I have experienced with my Asus ROG Ally. Nevertheless, while game compatibility has improved, broad application support still poses challenges for Linux users.

3 Steep Learning Curve of Linux

Although numerous Linux distributions cater to those transitioning from Windows, each often necessitates terminal commands to achieve basic functionality. As a developer, I navigate this environment with ease, yet I recognize that average users may find it daunting.

The reliance on terminal commands is a significant hurdle that can deter many potential users. With diverse distributions, package managers, and desktop environments to navigate, finding appropriate solutions can be troublesome. Consequently, online searches might lead to irrelevant information, leaving users frustrated and stuck.

Linux Mint desktop on a ThinkPad laptop, with a mouse and USB stick nearby — Image by Jayric Maning –no attributions required

On the contrary, Apple’s ecosystem offers a vastly different experience. By controlling both hardware and software, macOS avoids the fragmentation that can plague Linux. While this means sacrificing some of the freedom Linux provides, it results in a system that operates seamlessly.

In my opinion, macOS delivers the best out-of-the-box experience among the major operating systems. If someone were to ask for a laptop recommendation today, my go-to suggestion would be the MacBook Air, as it caters well to the needs of most users.

2 Unpredictable Hardware Support

Having installed Linux on numerous devices over the years, I’ve frequently encountered hardware issues. More often than not, I resort to the terminal to enable basic functionalities.

For instance, one of my secondary laptops struggled to boot Linux from a standard Western Digital M.2 SSD. After hours of troubleshooting online, I finally discovered that adding a specific boot argument in the bootloader was the solution. Nonetheless, this is not a feat the average user would be likely to tackle.

Even peripherals like fingerprint readers and printers can yield inconsistent support, potentially forcing users to forgo hardware they’ve already purchased.

M4 MacBook Pro screen tilted back on wooden table

This is precisely why Macs are appealing.macOS is inherently optimized for Apple hardware, ensuring a smooth experience right from the first boot. Users shouldn’t have to rummage through forums or type convoluted commands just to get essential functionalities to work.

Unless we see more appliances like the Steam Deck, which come preinstalled and configured for seamless operation, the headaches associated with Linux on diverse hardware will persist.

1 Installation Reluctance Among Users

The stark truth is that most users are not inclined to install a new operating system. The tasks involved in creating a bootable USB drive, wiping a storage device, or accessing the BIOS may seem easy to seasoned Linux users, but for the average person, even reaching the BIOS can be intimidating.

Dell XPS 13 running Ubuntu with a monitor in the background — Image by Raghav Sethi – no attribution required

Even Linus Torvalds, the creator of Linux, has acknowledged this reluctance as a major factor in Linux’s limited desktop market share. The absence of preinstallation on most devices further alienates potential users.

Most people simply seek a system that powers on and functions seamlessly without the need for extensive tinkering. As long as Linux remains dependent on manual installation processes, it will continue to be perceived as a niche solution.

Despite primarily using a Mac for my daily tasks, I have shifted away from Windows on my other devices in favor of Linux, which I still regard as a superior option compared to remaining on Windows. While Linux does present challenges for many casual users, if your workflows are well-supported, I encourage you to embrace its advantages, including the unique freedom it provides that macOS cannot match.

Source & Images