Choosing between Kingdom Hearts and Final Fantasy is akin to weighing the merits of oranges against apples. Both belong to the JRPG genre (the fruits of gaming), yet they offer distinct experiences and flavors. Each series shines in its unique way, making it challenging for fans like myself to determine which stands superior. Kingdom Hearts feels as if Final Fantasy had a collaboration with Disney; sometimes, the offspring can exceed the legacy of its parent, while at other times, it may fall short.
In this analysis, we will explore multiple facets of both franchises, ranking them from least to most significant. As a game design enthusiast, I’m excited to apply my insights into this debate. However, personal preferences may ultimately shape the conclusions drawn here.
To streamline this comparison, we will spotlight a specific game from each series that best exemplifies each aspect under discussion, culminating in a final verdict. Given the rich variety within both series, our focus will shift from determining a winner to recognizing which game excels in various attributes.
Let’s dive into the comparison!
10 Target Audience
Kingdom Hearts
From the perspective of game development, effective marketing can pose a formidable challenge, but having Disney as a partner provides a significant advantage.
When the first Kingdom Hearts installment hit the shelves, it represented an unconventional yet successful crossover. Rated E for Everyone, it appealed effortlessly to children raised on Disney movies, particularly those who had just acquired a PS2, much like myself. Its lighthearted narrative further broadened its reach, tapping into the nostalgia of players across generations. In fact, my first introduction to Final Fantasy stemmed from my love for Kingdom Hearts. For existing Final Fantasy aficionados, diving into Kingdom Hearts was a natural next step.
Contrarily, Final Fantasy generally carries a T rating and targets a teenage demographic. Parents wary of ESRB ratings might hesitate to purchase these titles for their younger children. However, the series’ anthology format allows new players to begin with virtually any entry. In contrast, Kingdom Hearts typically encourages starting with the inaugural game, as diving directly into the third installment can be confounding, though it does appeal to a wider age demographic.
9 Music
Final Fantasy VIII
When grinding levels for countless hours in an RPG, the quality of the music plays a crucial role.
Unparalleled in his contributions, Nobuo Uematsu has composed for most of the titles within the Final Fantasy legacy. While preferences for particular soundtracks vary, the eighth installment boasts numerous standout tracks, from the Overworld theme to Laguna’s battle music; not to mention the iconic “One-Winged Angel”from Final Fantasy VII.
Even beyond Uematsu’s talents, each game’s musical composition remains impressive, typically featuring a recognizable victory jingle. Notably, Yoko Shimomura, renowned for her work on Kingdom Hearts, also composed the soundtrack for Final Fantasy XV, showcasing the best of both franchises.
Kingdom Hearts features compelling music, without a doubt; Shimomura is adept at crafting original themes and remixes of beloved Disney tunes. Moreover, the contributions of Utada Hikaru to the series—including the opening and closing themes for each game—enhance the auditory experience. Nonetheless, Final Fantasy’s soundtrack encompasses a broader range of musical genres, from rock to pop.
8 Characters
Kingdom Hearts II
As a crossover between Final Fantasy and Disney, Kingdom Hearts shines notably when it comes to character inclusions, particularly in its second installment, which expands upon its predecessor.
In this edition, players witness the return of beloved characters such as Auron, Sephiroth, Cloud, Squall, Yuffie, and Tifa, along with a cameo from Vivi of Final Fantasy IX. Importantly, the Final Fantasy characters play crucial roles in the overarching storyline, while Disney characters join battles either as summons or active party members. Additionally, the introduction of Organization XIII presents players with some of the most memorable boss fights in the series, notably in the post-game edition of Kingdom Hearts II Final Mix.
Final Fantasy itself boasts an extensive and remarkable cast throughout its anthology, featuring running gags like the recurring character named Cid in every title. For fans of both franchises, Kingdom Hearts II exemplifies an optimal balance between iconic characters from each world. Although some beloved characters from earlier installments were relegated to downloadable content in Kingdom Hearts III, this second game excels in character integration.
7 Story
Final Fantasy X
As an anthology series, Final Fantasy offers narratives for every preference. Fan favorites range from the medieval-themed adventures of Final Fantasy IV, IX, and XII to the more mature tales found in VI, XIII, or XVI. For those seeking camaraderie and adventure, Final Fantasy XV delivers on that promise. The variety ensures there is an engaging storyline suited for everyone.
My personal favorite is Final Fantasy X, as it articulates captivating themes of spirituality, betrayal, and sacrifice, especially as the story unfolds towards its climax. For players desiring a lighter narrative experience, the sequel, X-2, offers a playful alternative.
In comparison, Kingdom Hearts often feels like a series of fragmented journeys through Disney worlds, with storylines that stick closely to their film counterparts—particularly noticeable in some entries like Kingdom Hearts III—until the final moments where everything converges into an action-packed denouement. The structure of the first two games provided a more rewarding experience compared to the later spin-offs, making the Disney worlds far more engaging. However, some later entries felt repetitive and convoluted.
In addition, the frequent themes of friendship and the nature of darkness often create perplexing narratives throughout the series. Players diving into Kingdom Hearts III without understanding the non-numbered titles—such as Birth by Sleep and Dream Drop Distance—may find themselves utterly confused. While both franchises have their share of complexity, the narrative threads in Final Fantasy often resolve within a single game, whereas Kingdom Hearts extends its story across multiple titles.
6 Villain
Final Fantasy VI
While Sephiroth and Sorceress Ultimecia from VII and VIII, respectively, are celebrated as iconic villains, Kefka Palazzo from Final Fantasy VI truly embodies the epitome of an effective antagonist as he successfully manifests his goals, unlike many classic heroes who thwart villains.
In contrast, the villains within the Kingdom Hearts series often succumb easily to Sora’s prowess, particularly the Disney villains. Although Organization XIII is formidable, and Xehanort serves as an entertaining overarching nemesis, any lingering threats dissipate by the time the saga concludes in the third game. Notably, Xemnas does present a thrilling final battle, yet he doesn’t instill the same sense of dread as Kefka.
5 Combat
Kingdom Hearts III
While Kingdom Hearts II had its own merits, particularly with the utility of the Reflect spell, the third installment elevates combat to an exhilarating new level. Players can genuinely feel that Sora is worthy of the Keyblade’s legacy, regardless of his previous setback in Dream Drop Distance.
Though some players may be divided on the inclusion of attraction arts and transformations—elements that can be turned off if desired—the Re:Mind DLC introduces other characters and offers thrilling encounters reminiscent of anime battles. In contrast, most Final Fantasy games utilize turn-based combat, and even the more action-oriented titles like XVI often lack the dynamic intensity seen in Kingdom Hearts. Personally, I appreciate the combat systems in Final Fantasy X and Final Fantasy: Tactics Advance, yet Kingdom Hearts distinctly keeps you engaged, especially on critical mode.
4 Setting
Final Fantasy IX
Among the entries in the Final Fantasy series, Final Fantasy IX stands out as a fan favorite deserving of a remake. Titles such as IV and World of Final Fantasy also exude charm, but IX represents a return to the series’ foundational elements after the darker themes of its predecessors. The protagonist, Zidane, is more lighthearted when compared to Squall or Cloud.
The straightforward adventure, encapsulated by the iconic Black Mage Village, has won the hearts of many due to its enchanting fantasy-like setting—especially in light of the contemporary futuristic elements found in some recent titles. The passion for a potential fan-created remake speaks volumes about its enduring appeal.
In contrast, Kingdom Hearts thrives as a crossover but primarily immerses players in Disney worlds, with a few unique settings. While locales like The World That Never Was and Castle Oblivion have their merits, they struggle to compete with the beloved scenery of Gaia from Final Fantasy IX.
3 Lore
Kingdom Hearts: Dream Drop Distance
Both series are notorious for the complexity of their narratives, particularly in entries like Final Fantasy VII. However, when it comes to intricate lore, Kingdom Hearts takes the lead.
The third installment presents a challenge, especially for newcomers who haven’t engaged with the preceding titles. Conversely, Final Fantasy narratives typically encapsulate their plots within individual games, while Kingdom Hearts continues the overarching saga—most notably the complex Xehanort narrative.
Dream Drop Distance intensifies this complexity with time travel elements, intertwining character arcs that blend with Xehanort’s history. Furthermore, the game introduces aspects from The World Ends With You and Dream Eaters, enriching the mechanics.
What initially begins as a Mark of Mastery exam for Sora and Riku devolves into a perilous expedition, wherein “darkness within darkness”awaits our heroes. It’s a crucial chapter within the lore, though it pushes storytelling boundaries to the extreme.
2 Gameplay
Final Fantasy VII: Rebirth
JRPGs garner attention for their amalgamation of engaging narratives and gameplay. Yet, the gameplay often governs the overall experience, as some players prioritize action over story elements. The Final Fantasy series showcases a rich diversity in gameplay styles—from turn-based mechanics in earlier titles to action-oriented engagements in more recent installments, as well as inventive strategies in Tactics and entertaining experiences in games like Dissidia and Theatrhythm.
Kingdom Hearts frequently employs fast-paced, action-centric gameplay that eschews turn-taking mechanics, except for its card-based spin-off, Chain of Memories. In its rhythm game iteration, Melody of Memory offers a unique change of pace, but the gameplay remains predominantly action-focused throughout the series.
Kingdom Hearts excels in providing post-game content, filled with a plethora of challenges to conquer following the main story. Its level design and various mini-games, including the Gummi Ship and Remy’s Bistro, contribute additional playtime. Nonetheless, Final Fantasy has continuously delivered diverse challenges and mini-games. Titles within the series may offer rich optional content, including unique challenges like the no-sphere-grid run in Final Fantasy X and optional blitzball matches.
With its innovations in gameplay, Final Fantasy VII: Rebirth exemplifies the pinnacle of the series, featuring engaging minigames while masterfully blending turn-based and action elements. The intricate level design in differing chapters effectively showcases each character’s distinct strengths and weaknesses. While not all Final Fantasy games include expansive overworlds, Rebirth amplifies the gameplay experience.
1 The Final Verdict
Final Fantasy
Despite my fondness for Kingdom Hearts and its intricate lore, it ultimately does not eclipse its predecessor. I find myself questioning whether my genuine affection for the series is rooted in childhood nostalgia, leading to reflections on its timeless appeal. Moreover, the target demographics diverge, with adult fans comprising the majority, while children often gravitate towards other gaming experiences like Roblox.
Experiencing the HD collections is undoubtedly worthwhile, as they promise hours of enjoyment—despite my underwhelming sentiments regarding Kingdom Hearts III. The prolonged anticipatory period fostered too many theories, resulting in a disappointing release akin to the dissatisfaction reflected in Season 8 of Game of Thrones.
Nevertheless, in terms of overall engagement, narrative depth, and gameplay diversity appealing to all gamer types, Final Fantasy stands tall. It’s telling that the community often discusses Final Fantasy news more frequently than Kingdom Hearts updates. I sometimes ponder whether a fresh, anthology-style approach could rejuvenate Kingdom Hearts by focusing on different keyblade wielders, thereby sidestepping central plot entanglements. But in the end, the comparison remains, like that of oranges to apples. Kingdom Hearts resembles an orange, while Final Fantasy takes the form of an apple. Both are undeniably excellent, yet the versatility of apples mirrors the overall appeal of Final Fantasy.
Leave a Reply