Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 – Choosing Between Pebbles and Herring: What’s the Best Option?

Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 – Choosing Between Pebbles and Herring: What’s the Best Option?

In Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2, acquiring a horse is a pivotal part of the protagonist Henry’s journey. A mount significantly enhances mobility across the vast game world and facilitates the transportation of additional loot after encounters with bandits or item collection. Players are likely to first encounter Pebbles, Henry’s loyal mare, at the Semine stables.

As the questline progresses, particularly with the completion of “For Whom the Bell Tolls”and the commencement of “Back In The Saddle, ”players face a critical decision about whether to stick with Pebbles or opt for Herring, an alternative horse offered for free at the Trosky Castle stables. While Herring appears to be an appealing upgrade, several factors should be weighed before making a choice.

Comparing Pebbles and Herring: Which is the Superior Horse in Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2?

Statistics Comparison between Pebbles and Herring
Pebbles, a versatile horse in Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2
Herring, one of the best early-game horses
Reclaiming Pebbles in Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2
Pebbles in Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2

In the initial stages of the game, Herring often proves more advantageous due to its superior Stamina, Speed, Courage, and overall Value compared to Pebbles. This makes the exchange seem like a wise option, especially considering Herring is offered free of charge.

Stamina

Capacity

Speed

Courage

Value

Pebbles

127

138

32

12

100

Herring

169

138

40

14

1260

Should players opt for Herring, it would become Henry’s primary steed. However, should regrets arise, players can return to the Semine stables (the original location where Pebbles was acquired) up to a specific point in the main storyline. Here, they can either repurchase Pebbles from Groom Ballatay or steal it back, permitting a hands-on comparison of both horses.

The Hidden Advantages of Herring and Pebbles

While Herring demonstrates superior stats, there are compelling reasons to keep Pebbles. Primarily, Pebbles represents Henry’s longstanding companion from the first game. After riding over 35 kilometers with Pebbles, players unlock the hidden perk “Good Old Pebbles, ”which significantly enhances its attributes, solidifying its status as one of the top horses in the game.

Conversely, Herring has its own secret perk, “Red Herring, ”which equally boosts its potential but requires riding 50 kilometers— a much longer distance for a perk that offers slight advantages over Pebbles.

Stamina

Capacity

Speed

Courage

Value

Pebbles

210

338

55

12

4660

Herring

231

288

56

14

4910

Ultimately, many players may find it more beneficial to retain Pebbles. Her backstory and emotional connection to Henry from the first game are significant, and her enhanced carry capacity offers practical gameplay advantages. While Herring provides greater Stamina, Speed, and Courage, the differences in performance are generally minimal and do not greatly affect the overall gameplay experience.

Kabat’s Proposition

Kabat's proposition to Henry after choosing Pebbles

For players interested in maximizing their early-game earnings in Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2, sticking with Pebbles offers an additional financial incentive. After informing Kabat about the decision to keep Pebbles, he suggests a clever ruse involving the Chamberlain. By claiming Henry accepted Herring but then selling it to a Nomad, players can earn a reward of 300 Groschen, with the possibility of increasing this amount through a skill check.

Source & Images

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *