Kieran Culkin’s Oscar Nomination: Addressing Category Fraud Concerns Amidst Genuine Competition

Kieran Culkin has recently faced scrutiny regarding his nomination for Best Supporting Actor at the upcoming Oscars, with some critics arguing that he should not be in this category. However, his role in A Real Pain fundamentally aligns with the definition of a supporting actor. In this film, directed and written by Jesse Eisenberg, Culkin portrays Benji, one half of a duo of Jewish American cousins. Their journey takes them through significant Holocaust sites in Poland as they pay tribute to their deceased grandmother, all while navigating personal conflicts that eventually strengthen their relationship.

When the 2025 Oscar nominations were unveiled, A Real Pain gained recognition in two categories: Best Original Screenplay for Eisenberg and Best Supporting Actor for Culkin. While Eisenberg’s nomination was widely expected, Culkin’s choice has sparked debate, primarily focused on whether his role is truly supporting. Many detractors contend that Culkin embodies more of a co-leader role rather than a supporting one. However, these claims fail to acknowledge the nuanced nature of Benji’s character within the film’s narrative framework.

Kieran Culkin’s Benji: A Supporting Character with a Larger-than-Life Presence

Benji’s Vibrant Personality

Benji’s character establishes the narrative framework of A Real Pain, beginning and concluding with him contemplating his solitude in an airport setting. Despite this prominence, the film remains focused on Dave’s perspective. The story opens with Dave heading to the airport and concludes with his return home, emphasizing his emotional and narrative journey. Even when the cousins become separated during their travels, the film’s lens stays trained on Dave.

Contrasting with Dave’s reserved and introverted nature, Benji is characterized by his extroverted, charismatic demeanor. This disparity in personalities is not merely for comedic effect; it serves as a key dynamic in the film. While comparisons can be drawn to Culkin’s role as Roman Roy in Succession, Benji distinguishes himself through his relatable sociality and emotional openness, qualities often absent in Roman. Both characters exhibit sharp wit, making them compelling to watch, yet it is Benji’s empathy that sets him apart.

Benji’s Role as the Center of Attention Reflects Their Relationship Dynamic

Benji’s Character Takes Center Stage, Highlighting Dave’s Insecurities

Kieran Culkin and Jesse Eisenberg in A Real Pain

Much of the perception that Benji steals the spotlight from Dave stems from his exuberant personality. His actions often divert attention, emphasizing the relationship’s power dynamics rather than depicting a failure of storytelling focus. Benji’s ability to dominate interactions shines a light on Dave’s feelings of invisibility and serves as a narrative device to explore the essence of their relationship.

A Real Pain has received critical acclaim, being named among the top 10 films of 2024 by the American Film Institute and the National Board of Review. This recognition is largely attributed to how effectively Eisenberg captures the insecurities inherent in Dave’s character, particularly during a poignant dinner monologue where he expresses his envy of Benji’s infectious energy. This scene reinforces the notion that while Dave is positioned as the protagonist, it is Benji who embodies the role of a central figure in their lives.

Can Kieran Culkin Claim the Best Supporting Actor Title?

A Strong Contender in a Packed Field

Currently, Culkin is emerging as a leading contender for the Best Supporting Actor award at the 97th Academy Awards, particularly following his recent Golden Globe win, which has increased his visibility in the race. However, he faces stiff competition from an array of talented nominees, including Yura Borisov for Anora, Edward Norton for A Complete Unknown, Guy Pearce for The Brutalist, and Jeremy Strong, Culkin’s co-star from Succession, for The Apprentice.

Best Supporting Actor Nominee	Movie
Kieran Culkin	A Real Pain
Yura Borisov	Pomegranate
Edward Norton	A Complete Unknown
Guy Pearce	The Brutalist
Jeremy Strong	The Apprentice

Norton effectively complements Timothée Chalamet’s portrayal of Bob Dylan in A Complete Unknown, while Strong’s interpretation of Roy Cohn in The Apprentice captivates audiences, consistently drawing focus in his scenes. Each nominee brings a unique strength to their performances, presenting a valid case for a potential win. Still, Culkin appears to have the edge amidst a competitive field for the Best Supporting Actor category at this year’s Oscars.

Source & Images