Judge Finds Amazon Employed Dark Patterns to Manipulate Users into Prime Subscriptions and Complicate Cancellations Before FTC Trial

Amazon Prime has ingrained itself into the daily lives of many, primarily recognized for its two-day shipping, vast streaming options, and exclusive discounts. Despite this convenience, recent scrutiny from the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) reveals a more complicated aspect of the service. Allegations suggest that Amazon has resorted to questionable tactics to secure memberships, raising concerns over ethical practices.

FTC Investigates Amazon Prime’s Sign-Up Strategies and Cancellation Difficulties

The process of canceling a subscription can often prove tedious, but Amazon Prime takes this to another level. Many users find the cancellation experience cumbersome, riddled with prompts that lead to confusion and second-guessing. This has prompted the FTC to label Amazon’s methods as manipulative, arguing that users have been unwittingly enrolled in the service and then find it nearly impossible to exit.

In 2023, the FTC filed a case against Amazon, citing the company’s utilization of deceptive design tactics—commonly known as “dark patterns”—to facilitate Prime memberships without clear paths for cancellation. A significant development occurred in September 2025, when a federal judge determined that Amazon had breached the Restore Online Shoppers’ Confidence Act (ROSCA) by obtaining payment details before fully disclosing the terms of service, as reported by The Verge.

This upcoming trial presents both challenges and opportunities; it is viewed as a partial victory for the FTC, as the judge acknowledged that users were indeed misled by the convoluted cancellation processes. Furthermore, two of Amazon’s top executives may be held liable if the FTC successfully substantiates its claims. Nevertheless, Amazon persistently refutes these allegations, maintaining that its sign-up and cancellation procedures adhere to legal standards and are user-friendly.

Should the FTC prevail, the ramifications could significantly alter the subscription framework for Amazon Prime and beyond. Users might gain clearer insights into their commitments, as opaque terms and conditions could be eliminated. This shift has the potential to transform the subscription landscape, prioritizing transparency and trust alongside profitability. As the legal battle unfolds, it is essential for consumers to remain aware of the digital services they engage with, taking proactive measures to foster trust and ensure they understand what they are subscribing to.

Source & Images