Joe Hill’s Blue Bloods Finale Diminishes Hopes for a Spinoff Series

Blue Bloods has successfully closed the door on any potential spinoff featuring Joe Hill (Will Hochman) by concluding his narrative arc in a definitive manner. As the last addition to the Reagan family introduced in Season 10, Joe emerged when Sean (Andrew Terraciano) stumbled upon him through a genealogy project for school. Joe’s connection to the family stemmed from being the son of the late Joe Reagan, a fact kept hidden by his mother until Joe was an adult and began questioning his heritage.

Throughout his five-year tenure on Blue Bloods, Joe’s integration into the Reagan family was challenging. Both Danny and Jamie struggled with his presence, as he served as a constant reminder of their loss. Similarly, Joe found it difficult to navigate his relationship with Frank, who juggled his responsibilities as a father and a police commissioner. In the series finale, however, a shift occurred where Joe and the Reagans reached a meaningful acceptance of one another. He concluded his story by expressing that Jamie and Eddie’s newborn would be fortunate to belong to such a family.

Why Joe Hill Was an Ideal Candidate for a Blue Bloods Spinoff

A Unique Character with Distinct Connections

The cancellation of Blue Bloods, primarily due to financial issues, indicated that any spinoff would require a smaller cast, minimizing the frequency of full Reagan family appearances. Joe’s character offered a compelling opportunity in this respect, as he could maintain a narrative connection to the Reagans while standing on his own. This separation would allow for rich storytelling without necessitating constant references to the broader family unit.

Moreover, Joe emerged as a fan-favorite character, even though actor Will Hochman’s schedule limited his screen time. A spinoff centered around Joe would draw on the audience’s existing affection for him, potentially garnering higher viewership than other proposed series. Nevertheless, any spinoff would face the challenge of audience disappointment over the non-renewal of Blue Bloods for a fifteenth season. Yet, a show featuring a well-liked character like Joe would likely have a stronger foundation for success.

Joe Hill’s Embrace of His Reagan Heritage in the Finale Diminishes Spinoff Prospects

Diminished Spinoff Feasibility Due to Family Ties

Blue Bloods family dinner — Courtesy of CBS/John Paul Filo

Joe’s narrative received a beautiful conclusion during the series finale, where he became more prominently featured in the show’s closing arcs. This allowed for not only a heartfelt resolution but also a clear acceptance of his place within the Reagan lineage. Throughout the finale, he actively supported Jamie following Eddie’s injury and participated in the final Reagan family dinner, achieving a sense of closure regarding his connection to his father. His acceptance marked a celebratory ending to his character arc, reflecting the importance of family.

However, this resolution complicates the feasibility of a standalone spinoff. The close relationships Joe established with the Reagans in the finale imply that regular interactions with them would be expected, which would overshadow any independent narrative he might have pursued. While it is unfortunate that Joe’s potential to explore the themes of family and law enforcement was curtailed, it ultimately cemented his role within the beloved series’ legacy.

Source & Images