Jason Momoa Cast as Lobo: Why Henry Cavill Deserves a Second Chance in James Gunn’s DC Universe After Being Shortchanged as Superman

Jason Momoa’s recent casting as Lobo in James Gunn’s planned DCU has sparked renewed speculation about the future of Henry Cavill within the franchise. Many fans are hopeful that he might be recast and find redemption following the abrupt end of his tenure as Superman. Despite a strong kickoff with Man of Steel, the DCEU struggled to maintain momentum due to a series of disappointments that ultimately distanced viewers from the cinematic universe.

While Gunn’s vision for the DCU represents a potential fresh start for the studio, it’s unfortunate that many actors’ journeys in their respective roles were cut short. One of the standout disappointments in recent memory is Cavill’s Superman, whose story arc seemed unceremoniously halted.

What Momoa’s Casting as Lobo Means for Cavill’s Return

Opportunities for Former DCEU Actors in the DCU

Jason Momoa has broken new ground by transitioning from his role as Aquaman to take on Lobo in the DCU, marking him as the first major character shift from the DCEU to Gunn’s reboot. His debut as Lobo is anticipated in the upcoming 2026 film, Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow. While others, such as Nathan Fillion (recast as Guy Gardner), have switched roles, Momoa’s shift from the Justice League to Lobo is particularly noteworthy.

Momoa’s longstanding desire to portray Lobo showcases Gunn’s flexibility regarding casting. While some actors retain their previous roles, Gunn appears open to reshuffling the roster, providing a pathway for other former DCEU talents to re-enter the fold. Although it’s unlikely certain actors like Ezra Miller or Ray Fisher will return, audiences remain eager for a Henry Cavill comeback in any capacity.

Cavill’s Recent Appearances Indicate His Interest in Superhero Roles

Fans Eager for Cavill’s Return in Any Franchise

Cavill made waves with his cameo in Black Adam, reigniting hopes that he could helm another solo Superman film. However, the prospect quickly dimmed after James Gunn took charge and announced Cavill’s retirement from the role shortly thereafter. This abrupt conclusion to Cavill’s Superman saga was disappointing for many, particularly following his tumultuous exit from The Witcher series.

In an intriguing turn, audiences began advocating for Cavill’s casting in Marvel properties, with many petitions suggesting characters like Captain Britain or Hyperion. Most notably, he briefly appeared as a variant of Wolverine in Deadpool & Wolverine, garnering significant applause and reinforcing his continued enthusiasm for superhero portrayals across both universes.

Gunn’s Interest in Recasting Cavill Sparks Speculation

Potential Plans for Cavill in the New DC Universe

In December 2022, just after the leadership transition at DC Studios, Gunn formally announced Cavill wouldn’t reprise his role as Superman in the new slate. However, he also hinted at exciting prospects for collaboration with Cavill down the line, suggesting a mutual admiration and desire for future involvement.

Though two years have passed since that announcement, indicating possible shifts in Cavill’s career trajectory, Gunn’s initial enthusiasm leaves room for speculation about his return. As evidenced by Momoa’s newfound role, there remains a wealth of potential for Cavill to join the reimagined DC universe.

Potential Roles for Cavill in the DC Universe

Cavill’s Versatility as a Character

Henry Cavill's Superman in a courtroom in Batman v Superman Dawn of Justice.

The DC Universe offers an expansive array of characters where Cavill could shine. While many fan theories have floated various roles for him post-DCEU, the notion of Cavill stepping into the shoes of Batman has gained traction. The upcoming Batman: The Brave and the Bold will introduce an older Bruce Wayne, allowing a distinct alignment with Cavill’s current life experiences.

Envisioning a confrontation between Batman and Superman—this time with Cavill as the Dark Knight—could create an unforgettable cinematic moment for fans both old and new. Other captivating suggestions include Bizarro, Jor-El, or Booster Gold, as the slate of upcoming DC projects continues to expand under Gunn’s direction. While Cavill’s Superman chapter may have concluded, the potential for his new adventures in the DCU is just beginning.

Source & Images