James Gunn’s Ideal Stylistic Approach for Superman

On December 19, 2024, excitement surged through the fan base as the teaser trailer for James Gunn’s Superman film made its debut on YouTube. Starring David Corenswet as the iconic Man of Steel, the trailer garnered an astonishing 250 million views within the first 24 hours, establishing itself as the most-watched trailer in the history of DC and Warner Bros. This favorable reception marked a pivotal moment for DC Universe fans, many of whom expressed renewed hope for a franchise that has been struggling to capture its audience’s attention in recent years.

Despite this overwhelming enthusiasm, a vocal minority criticized the film’s vibrant color palette and stylistic choices, comparing it to the lighter tones of The CW’s DC television series. This shift away from the darker aesthetic of the Snyderverse’s portrayal presents a deliberate and refreshing transformation for the character, which Gunn appears to navigate with confidence.

Gunn’s Superman Embraces Comic Book Roots

Superman (David Corenswet) with Krypto the Superdog — Warner Bros.

James Gunn, a well-regarded comic book aficionado, has consistently endeavored to bring lesser-known characters to mainstream audiences, evident in works like Guardians of the Galaxy and The Suicide Squad. His understanding of source material resonates throughout the Superman teaser, as he captures the essence of the character’s Golden Age while infusing contemporary elements. With a bold design inspired by both Art Deco and classic comic aesthetics, Gunn reintroduces audiences to a Superman adorned in bright primary colors.

Additionally, the teaser features unexpected appearances from characters such as Nathan Fillion’s Guy Gardner and Isabela Merced’s Hawkgirl, alongside Superman’s beloved sidekick, Krypto the Superdog—an unexpected yet delightful highlight that evokes nostalgia among fans.

In contrast to previous interpretations, especially those presented by Zack Snyder and Bryan Singer, Gunn’s approach emphasizes a more relatable and hopeful Superman, rekindling the character’s core values of decency and heroism. While some viewers uphold Snyder’s vision, many comics enthusiasts criticized it for straying too far from what made Superman a symbol of hope.

The Case for Color in Superman’s Narrative

Superman (David Corenswet) in the teaser — Warner Bros.

Historically, many Superman films have resisted their comic book origins, opting instead for a more somber tone. In stark contrast, Gunn’s perspective wholeheartedly embraces the celebratory aspects of the comic genre, a shift that has found favor with audiences as evident in the enthusiastic comments on the trailer’s YouTube release. Many users reminisced about past Superman films, sharing personal connections and fond memories associated with the franchise.

The prior Snyder era’s focus on a darker narrative led to criticisms regarding the tone, particularly when stacked against Marvel’s more lighthearted offerings. DC Studios recognized this backlash, subsequently pivoting towards humor and a more approachable tone in films like Shazam!. This shift appears to be reflected in Gunn’s stewardship as the creative force behind DC Studios, which aims to bring a sense of joy back to the genre.

This is not to discount the merits of Snyder and Singer’s films, which brought their own unique interpretations to the character. While Snyder’s rendition of Superman delivered a visually impactful experience, that vision often felt disconnected from the quintessential ideals associated with the hero. Similarly, Singer’s quieter narrative was introspective but did not capture the brightness fans hoped to see.

Having navigated a legacy steeped in heaviness, it is refreshing to witness Gunn’s vision for Superman, prioritizing color and lightness in an era of gloom. Set to redefine Superman for a new generation, Gunn’s interpretation stands out not just for its visual flair but for its commitment to affirming the more hopeful, approachable aspects of the character. Being a filmmaker with a deep passion for the source material, Gunn is undoubtedly poised to deliver a Superman that resonates with old fans and new alike.

Source & Images