James Gunn’s Batman Choice: Potential Harm to DCU’s Future

Overview

James Gunn’s plan to exclude Robert Pattinson’s Batman from the revitalized DC Universe raises concerns.
The presence of multiple Batman iterations might overwhelm fans and dilute the franchise’s impact.
Choosing to disregard a successful Batman portrayal could jeopardize the future trajectory of the DCU.

After assuming the role of CEO at DC Studios, James Gunn is on a mission to transform the DC Universe. This task is particularly daunting considering the mixed performance of the DCU in contrast to the robust success of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Nevertheless, within the DC brand, Batman and Superman stand out as two of cinema’s most enduring figures.

Fans have been eagerly awaiting clarity on Gunn’s vision for Batman, especially since much of his initial attention has focused on Superman. Nevertheless, his recent decisions have sparked confusion among fans, who are left uncertain about the potential implications for the franchise.

What are James Gunn’s Plans for Batman?

The Batman Poster featuring Robert Pattinson

In 2022, Robert Pattinson stepped into the role of Batman, delivering a compelling and gritty interpretation that resonated with audiences. Garnering an impressive 85% rating on Rotten Tomatoes and a 7.8/10 on IMDb, many expected Pattinson to reprise his role in Gunn’s DCU. Although a sequel, The Batman Part II, is in the works, it will not be integrated into the new DCU framework.

As reported by Variety, Gunn has stated it is “very unlikely”that Pattinson will be featured in the DCU or in the forthcoming project, The Brave and the Bold, which aims to introduce Batman into the new universe. While he remains open to Pattinson appearing in other contexts, the direction seems firmly set on a new portrayal.

The Risks of Multiple Batman Characters

Having multiple actors take on the Batman role simultaneously may initially seem appealing to fans, but this approach could inadvertently undermine the films’ effectiveness. Given the appetite for Batman-related content, there is a risk of oversaturation which could dampen overall audience enthusiasm. Furthermore, if Gunn’s selection fails to resonate as effectively as Pattinson’s portrayal, direct comparisons will likely diminish viewer engagement.

Another significant concern is the potential for confusion among viewers regarding the narratives. While devoted comic book enthusiasts may distinguish between the two storylines, the average moviegoer may struggle to understand the different arcs. This lack of clarity could lead to expectations that do not align with the actual DCU storytelling, contrasting sharply with Marvel’s more cohesive approach. Such missteps could hinder the franchise’s growth at a time when it desperately needs a positive trajectory.

Gunn’s Surprising Omission of the Current Batman

The choice to exclude Pattinson seems puzzling given the critical and commercial success of his rendition of Batman. With a remarkable box office haul of $772 million against a budget of $185-200 million, The Batman was the seventh-highest-grossing film of 2022, also earning three nominations at the 95th Academy Awards. This undeniable success signals that maintaining this version could capitalize on a winning formula.

Moreover, the character of Penguin, brilliantly portrayed by Colin Farrell, is deeply intertwined within Pattinson’s universe, making it even less likely that Gunn will utilize this narrative thread. This decision represents yet another setback for the DCU, particularly since Farrell’s Penguin has garnered substantial fan acclaim. While Gunn has his vision for Batman’s future in the DCU, steering away from a proven success could prove disastrous, particularly for a character as paramount as Batman.

Source & Images