Jackie Chan’s Top Kung Fu Fantasy Film: The Ultimate Live-Action Dragon Ball Adaptation

Since its inception by Akira Toriyama in 1984, Dragon Ball has solidified its status as a global phenomenon in the shounen anime genre, particularly in the 1990s and early 2000s. The franchise has continually expanded its reach, giving rise to a multitude of content, including video games, manga adaptations, and cinematic releases.

In 2009, an attempt was made to transition this beloved series to live-action format with the film Dragonball Evolution. Unfortunately, the film was met with overwhelming disapproval from both audiences and critics alike. Many felt that it failed to capture the essence of the original anime and manga, breeding skepticism toward future adaptations of anime into films. However, before the infamous Dragonball Evolution, a film starring Jackie Chan showcased how narratives can be effectively translated between different mediums.

The Forbidden Kingdom & Dragon Ball: Shared Story Roots

Inspired by a Timeless Chinese Classic

Title card from episode 3 of Dragon Ball

Jet Li and Yifei Liu in The Forbidden Kingdom

Akira Toriyama was notably influenced by the 16th-century literary masterpiece, Journey to the West, while conceptualizing Dragon Ball. Regarded as a cornerstone of Chinese literature, this novel chronicles the epic pilgrimage of the monk Xuanzang as he endeavors to retrieve sacred Buddhist scriptures from India. In crafting Dragon Ball, Toriyama adeptly melded this narrative framework with elements drawn from iconic Hong Kong martial arts films. Interestingly, The Forbidden Kingdom, a film featuring Jackie Chan, employs a similar fusion of storytelling.

Despite its $55 million budget, The Forbidden Kingdom achieved a global box office gross of $128 million. This film, directed by Rob Minkoff, boasts a prominent cast, including Jackie Chan, Jet Li, Michael Angarano, and Liu Yifei. While it also draws inspiration from Journey to the West, it intertwines this classic tale with modern themes. Unfortunately, although it marked the first collaboration between martial arts legends Chan and Li on screen, the film underperformed at the box office and received mixed reviews.

Why The Forbidden Kingdom Stands Out in Chan’s Filmography

Celebrating Chinese Mythology Through Universal Storytelling

The narrative of The Forbidden Kingdom unfolds much like a typical Isekai anime, as it follows an American teenager named Jason Tripitikas who is magically whisked away to a mythical Chinese village. The film taps into the dream many young boys fantasize about: stepping into a magical universe filled with martial arts warriors and embarking on a quest to become “the chosen one.”While this archetypal hero’s journey can feel somewhat formulaic, it resonates with audiences familiar with the genre.

Jackie Chan’s character, Lu Yan, who is influenced by historical scholars, practices a unique style of drunken kung-fu, paying homage to classic martial arts films like Drunken Master and Dance of the Drunken Mantis. The film excels in expanding its depiction of ancient China, integrating real myths and legendary figures, which amplifies its dramatic impact. Additionally, the story invokes the legendary Monkey King, weaving themes of self-discovery and personal growth that resonate with contemporary viewers.

The Forbidden Kingdom: A Potential Canonical Representation of Dragon Ball

The Unlikelihood of Another Dragon Ball Live-Action Adaptation

Goku joyfully holding a Dragon Ball aloft

Dragonball Evolution failed to honor its source material thoroughly, offering a superficial portrayal of Goku’s character and even misspelling the title. Such missteps laid a heavy shadow over potential future adaptations of the beloved franchise. The disjointed execution and unfavorable reception of Dragonball Evolution cast doubts on whether another live-action adaptation of the series would ever be welcomed by fans.

Dragon Ball Evolution Key Facts
Directed By	James Wong
Rotten Tomatoes Critics’ Score	14%
Rotten Tomatoes Audience Score	19%
Budget	$30 million
Box Office	$56.5 million

While some recent adaptations, such as Netflix’s One Piece, have demonstrated that shounen anime can transition successfully to live-action, audiences remain hesitant due to the failures of prior projects like Death Note and Cowboy Bebop. This skepticism may lead studios to think twice before investing in another Dragon Ball live-action project.

Though The Forbidden Kingdom does not directly adapt Dragon Ball, its successful portrayal of adventure, martial arts, and the journey of a young hero effectively hints at what a well-executed live-action adaptation of Dragon Ball could achieve. Viewers might find solace in considering it as a stand-in for a Dragon Ball movie, especially since it may be the best live-action portrayal fans can expect from the franchise.

Source & Images