Is There Hope for Below Deck Sailing Yacht After Disappointing Season 5? (Crew Changes May Be Necessary)

Season 5 of Below Deck Sailing Yacht is nearing its conclusion, prompting discussions about potential cast changes to ensure the longevity of the series. Under the leadership of Captain Glenn Shephard aboard the Parsifal III, the crew faced numerous challenges this season. Notably, First Mate Gary King, Chief Stew Daisy Kelliher, and Chef Cloyce Martin were part of the core team. Despite initial hints of mending their friendship, Daisy and Gary’s conflicts resurfaced, raising concerns about their dynamic.

Compounding the drama, crew members Danni Warren and Diana Cruz frequently challenged Daisy’s leadership, creating an environment rife with tension. Gary struggled with sobriety, pushing the limits with Captain Glenn’s patience, while Cloyce’s inconsistent culinary offerings heightened guest dissatisfaction. Furthermore, Danni’s relationship with Deckhand Chase Lemacks faced obstacles, spotlighting Daisy’s insufficient guest engagement. As the season wraps, a significant overhaul of the cast may be necessary. Here’s why a change could be beneficial for the franchise.

The Case for a Leadership Change

A Fresh Start is Needed

Daisy Kelliher has been the Chief Stew since season 2, stepping in for Jenna MacGillivray. Although Daisy initially earned recognition for her professionalism, her leadership skills have diminished over time. The complications of her love triangle with former Chief Engineer Colin Macrae and Gary during season 4 distracted her from her responsibilities. With Colin’s departure and Daisy’s evident focus on her personal relationships rather than the yacht’s operations, her effectiveness as a leader has come into question.

Moreover, Daisy’s personal life saw significant changes, including freezing her eggs last year and traveling to support her sister in Thailand during a medical crisis. While Gary yearns for a romantic resolution with Daisy, it’s clear that she has grown beyond the drama of their dynamic. Thus, a conclusion to Daisy’s tenure on the show may serve her and the series well.

Gary’s Behavior Hindered the Season

Limited Accountability for Actions

This season was marred by allegations of sexual misconduct against Gary King, which stemmed from a drunken incident involving a former Bravo employee, Samantha Suarez. Gary denied the allegations, but uncertainty regarding the details has cast a shadow over his reputation.

Despite being a fan-favorite, Gary’s unacceptable behavior throughout filming cannot be overlooked. The season commenced on a negative note due to these controversies, and even his efforts towards sobriety did not mitigate the damage done to his image. Given these circumstances, it may be time for producers to consider parting ways with Gary as well.

Reviving Below Deck Sailing Yacht: Is It Possible?

Potential for Restoration Exists

Rather than canceling Below Deck Sailing Yacht outright, producers should evaluate potential cast adjustments to revitalize the program. While Gary’s chaotic presence poses risks, his moments of sobriety reflect a capable crew member and entertaining television personality. However, the network must not continue to tolerate detrimental conduct.

Daisy Kelliher	Below Deck Sailing Yacht
Age	36
Job	Chief Stew
Hometown	Dublin, Ireland

If producers decide to let Gary go, it’s essential for Daisy to remain, as she continues to be one of the most competent individuals on the crew. Additionally, there exists potential for her relationship with Deckhand Keith Allen to add intrigue in future seasons. Aside from Captain Glenn, it might be beneficial to refresh the remaining crew for a new direction on Below Deck Sailing Yacht.

Catch all the action of Below Deck Sailing Yacht streaming now on Peacock.

Source & Images