Indicators That Below Deck Sailing Yacht Producers Are Considering Replacing Daisy Kelliher After Her Struggles in Season 5

Indicators That Below Deck Sailing Yacht Producers Are Considering Replacing Daisy Kelliher After Her Struggles in Season 5

Daisy Kelliher’s journey in the fifth season of Below Deck Sailing Yacht has been anything but smooth, leading to speculation about her potential exit from the show. Captain Glenn Shephard once again helmed the crew, but both Daisy and Gary King contributed to a challenging atmosphere aboard the Parsifal III. Daisy faced mounting tensions with Stews Danni Warren and Diana Cruz, who frequently voiced their grievances regarding her leadership. Meanwhile, Gary King wrestled with his commitment to sobriety, quickly returning to his old habits against his intentions.

Historically, Daisy has embodied a no-nonsense approach as Chief Stew. While she retained a fragment of that assertiveness in the current season, there are signs of fatigue. Season 4 saw her explore a flirtation with former Chief Engineer Colin Macrae, which presented complications, especially after she had previously engaged off-camera with Gary, leading to jealousy and discord. The emotional undercurrents from these connections have continued to linger, impacting her performance this season.

Daisy Blamed the Guests for Her Service Struggles

Service Challenges This Season

Daisy Kelliher working on Below Deck Sailing Yacht

This season, Daisy’s ability to deliver exceptional charter service was compromised, leading her to place blame on the guests. The group proved to be particularly demanding from the outset and, although they unfavorably critiqued her services, Daisy could have taken steps to enhance their experience. For instance, during a cocktail-making class, she failed to gauge their preferences, resulting in a disappointing selection that they found too subtle for their tastes.

Typically composed, Daisy faltered when a drink was inadvertently spilled on her; her reaction involved uncertain laughter rather than professionalism. The guests expressed dissatisfaction with the Aperol Spritz she served, a situation that reflected her missed opportunity to align her offerings with their expectations. Her demeanor, oscillating between smiles and scowls, not only impacted her interactions but also affected the mood among her fellow Stews and the guests themselves.

When Captain Glenn approached Daisy to discuss her performance, her emotional response highlighted the stress she faced from both demanding guests and her peers’ attitudes. The decision by producers to bring Danni and Diana onto the crew has had significant repercussions for Daisy, who appears to be near her breaking point as the season reaches its climax.

Disregarding Captain Glenn’s Rules

A Shift in Professionalism

Daisy Kelliher's behavior criticized

As the next charter unfolded, while the guests brought a more enjoyable energy, they also demanded high maintenance. Chef Cloyce Martin initially struggled with dinner preparation but managed to adapt successfully. Although the guests appreciated Daisy’s efforts, her relationships with the supporting Stews remained strained. The atmosphere lightened when Gary, Chase, and Keith Allen entertained at a drag show, leading to a nightcap invitation that exclusively involved Daisy, Gary, Chase, and Keith.

Daisy Kelliher Below Deck Sailing Yacht
Age 36
Job Chief Stew
Hometown Dublin, Ireland

Under typical circumstances, crew members should refrain from mingling socially with guests, especially regarding alcohol. Nonetheless, Captain Glenn relaxed these restrictions, believing he could trust the selected crew members. He specifically instructed Daisy, Keith, Gary, and Chase to return by 2 a.m.while enforcing a two-drink maximum. Unfortunately, Daisy and Keith exceeded those limits, with Daisy consuming at least four drinks and Gary maxing out at ten, despite claiming he had less.

Daisy’s choice to disregard these rules, especially given the likelihood of being recorded, raised eyebrows. Although she does not have a drinking problem, her actions directly defied Captain Glenn. In a show of accountability, Daisy quickly offered an apology during their subsequent meeting, expressing genuine remorse. Conversely, Gary’s defiance did not go unnoticed, insisting it would have been impolite not to join the guests. This response did not resonate well with Captain Glenn, who opted to withhold only a portion of their tips instead of imposing stricter penalties.

Potential Departure If Gary King Is Dismissed

The Nature of Their Relationship

Gary King and Daisy Kelliher

Daisy’s bond with Gary is complex, and there is speculation that she may consider leaving the show if he faces termination. Though she previously opted out of rekindling a romantic relationship due to his questionable behaviors, she continues to uphold a solid friendship with him. Daisy has frequently defended Gary against allegations of misconduct while expressing her commitment to support him despite notable transgressions. This loyalty suggests that Daisy’s own future on the series might hinge on Gary’s status.

Producers Eyeing a New Chief Stew

A Possible Shift in Leadership

Daisy Kelliher and Gary King serious moment

As season five continues, it is becoming apparent that Below Deck Sailing Yacht producers may be considering a change in leadership with Daisy. Amid her tumultuous interactions with both Danni and Diana, signs suggest that the franchise is preparing for her departure. In fact, Daisy recently shared her thoughts on taking significant life steps, such as freezing her eggs—a clear indication that she is contemplating her future beyond the show. Additionally, she has started to make health-conscious decisions regarding her relationships, shifting towards more respectful and mature men.

Among potential replacements, Faye Clarke from Below Deck Adventure and Natalya Scudder from Below Deck Mediterranean have been noted as possible candidates. However, some speculate the franchise may opt for introducing a fresh face to the series, similar to how Aesha Scott’s role was filled on Below Deck Down Under. As the series progresses, it becomes evident that it may be time for Daisy to navigate towards new horizons.

Viewers can catch new episodes of Below Deck Sailing Yacht on Mondays at 9 p.m. ET on Bravo and stream episodes the following day on Peacock.

Source & Images

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *