Hulu’s Paradise Faces Significant Challenge Ahead

Warning: Spoilers for episodes 1-3 of Paradise are included below.

The premiere of Paradise, crafted by Dan Fogelman of This Is Us fame, introduces viewers to a complex fusion of murder mystery, political intrigue, and dystopian science fiction. The series stars Sterling K. Brown as Xavier Collins, a Secret Service agent whose duty is to protect President Cal Bradford, portrayed by James Marsden. However, the narrative swiftly unravels as the shocking murder of President Bradford sends Xavier into a gripping search for answers.

Operating within the confines of an underground city—results of a devastating cataclysm—Xavier’s quest deepens when the story juxtaposes present-day events with insightful flashbacks that explore his relationship with the president, as well as Samantha “Sinatra”Redmond (Julianne Nicholson) and other vital characters. While the opening episodes of Paradise hold a promising premise, they grapple with a significant challenge that may hinder their potential.

The Intriguing Conflict: Flashbacks Outshine Present-Day Narrative

Flashbacks Offer Rich Emotional Layers

Xavier Collins beside President Cal Bradford on the White House Lawn in Paradise

While the unexpected demise of President Bradford sets the stage for a captivating narrative, the flashbacks have rapidly emerged as the more engrossing aspect of Paradise. The intricate relationships between Xavier and President Bradford, the poignant backstory of Sinatra, along with Xavier’s familial ties, hold unique emotional weight that currently overshadows the unfolding events in the present timeline.

These flashbacks serve a crucial role in delving into Xavier’s and Sinatra’s backgrounds, providing essential context for the narrative’s central mystery. The deeply moving tales—such as Sinatra grappling with her child’s death and Xavier urging his father (Glynn Turman) to retire from flying due to Parkinson’s—resonate with palpable emotions. Additionally, the flashbacks gradually reveal the backstory of the cataclysm that led to the formation of their underground community, making these sequences far more engaging than the current plot developments.

An Inevitable Flashback Dilemma Arises in Paradise

Marsden’s Character Limited to Flashbacks

Given the storyline revolves around President Bradford’s death, viewers only encounter Marsden’s character in the flashbacks, diminishing his presence in the ongoing narrative. The interactions and character development during these flashbacks are some of the most compelling elements of the show. Marsden’s charismatic and complex portrayal sheds light on how President Bradford endeared himself to the public, creating a void in his absence from the present-day storyline.

Moreover, Xavier’s father is also absent from the current timeline, further narrowing the emotional landscape. Turman’s appearance delivers a heartbreaking performance that highlights the father-son bond, especially during poignant moments, such as when Xavier insists his father retire for health reasons. The absence of these richly developed characters in the present timeline exacerbates the flashback dilemma.

Enhancing Engagement: Solutions for Paradise’s Flashback Dilemma

Increased Focus on Present-Day Characters

To address the flashback issue, Paradise should invest in enhancing the present-day character arcs and storylines, offering audiences more reasons to connect with them. Currently, apart from unraveling the murder of President Bradford, the engagement from the present-day narrative significantly lags behind the flashbacks. By deepening character developments for pivotal figures such as Dr. Gabriela Torabi (Sarah Shahi), Agent Nicole Robinson (Krys Marshall), and Agent Billy Page (Jon Beavers), the series can foster greater emotional investments. Additionally, the relationships Xavier has with his children, Presley (Aliyah Mastin) and James (Percy Daggs IV), also deserve more exploration.

Notably, Xavier’s children draw their names from cultural references, those of Elvis Presley and the classic tale James and the Giant Peach.

Furthermore, to enrich the narrative, the series could delve deeper into the plethora of dystopian themes presented, capitalizing on the twist introduced in episode one. Dr. Torabi’s revelations in episode three regarding the conditions of their underground community lay the groundwork for further exploration. By allowing audiences more insights into the characters and their complex environment, the murder mystery becomes more engaging, facilitating a deeper investment in various suspects.

Upcoming Episodes of Paradise	Release Dates
Episode 4	February 4
Episode 5	February 11
Episode 6	February 18
Episode 7	February 25
Episode 8	March 4

Additionally, exploring narratives beyond the death of President Bradford could greatly enrich the storyline. While interwoven narratives are significant, threads such as the budding friendship between Presley and Jeremy (Bradford’s son, played by Charlie Evans), or the developing relationships shared by Xavier and Gabriela, offer promising avenues to explore. Expanding on these dynamics could render the present-day storyline just as compelling as the flashbacks in Paradise.

Source & Images